Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

"This bill is a clear threat to everyone's privacy and security," said Neema Singh Guliani, legislative counsel with the ACLU. (Photo: Laura Bittner/flickr/cc)

Leaked Encryption Draft Bill 'Ignores Economic, Security, and Technical Reality'

"This bill makes effective cybersecurity illegal."

Andrea Germanos

A draft of a proposed bill mandating companies give, under a court order, the government access to encrypted data is being derided by technology experts as "ludicrous," as it "ignores technical reality" and threatens everyone's security.

The Hill reports that it obtained a discussion draft of the legislation, and others have posted the purported 9-page draft online.

The bill's proposers, Senators Richard Burr (R-North Carolina), Chair of the Senate Intelligence Committee, and Dianne Feinstein (D-California), top Democratic on the committee, neither disavowed the document nor confirmed its legitimacy, the Wall Street Journal reports.

The draft states that, if faced with a government court order for data access, the company must "provide such information or data to such government in an intelligible format; or provide such technical assistance as is necessary to obtain such information or data in an intelligible format."

Essentially, writes Joshua Kopstein at Mothernboard, "the draft bill is an encryption-specific version of the All Writs Act, the controversial 1789 statute that the US government invoked to force Apple to build software capable of hacking into the San Bernardino shooter's iPhone."

Describing the proposal at technology news website Techdirt, Mike Masnick writes that it is "even more ridiculous than originally expected," adding that "what this bill requires is for tech companies to undermine the basics of encryption to make everyone less safe."

Such a possible risk to security was also underscored by the American Civil Liberties Union.

"This bill is a clear threat to everyone's privacy and security," said Neema Singh Guliani, legislative counsel with the ACLU, in a statement Friday.

"Instead of heeding the warnings of experts, the senators have written a bill that ignores economic, security, and technical reality. It would force companies to deliberately weaken the security of their products by providing backdoors into the devices and services that everyone relies on. Senators Burr and Feinstein should abandon their efforts to create a government backdoor," Singh Guliani stated.

Masnick added, "This bill makes effective cybersecurity illegal," referring to encryption allowing the "building [of] systems as secure as possible to protect people from malicious attacks."

Wired cited numerous technology experts who denounced the bills' implications, such as Kevin Bankston, the director of the New America Foundation's Open Technology Institute, who said: "I gotta say in my nearly 20 years of work in tech policy this is easily the most ludicrous, dangerous, technically illiterate proposal I've ever seen." Wired's reporting adds:

“Apple’s app store, Google’s play store, any platform for software applications somehow has to vet every app to ensure they have backdoored or little enough security to comply,” says Bankston. That means, he says, that this would “seem to also be a massive internet censorship bill.”

Sen. Ron Wyden, also a member of the intelligence committee, responded to the draft on Friday, stating that it "would definitely require [companies] to build a back door."

"For the first time in America, companies who want to provide their customers with stronger security would not have that choice—they would be required to decide how to weaken their products to make you less safe," his statement continued.

Other commentators charge that the document reveals a total absence of technological savvy on the part of the senators:

Actor and writer Will Wheaton also curated tweets under the title "Feinstein-Burr's anti-crypto bill is a technologically illiterate disaster," which you can see here.

"It's pretty disturbing that these two particularly clueless people happen to be the highest ranking members on the Senate Intelligence Committee," Masnick added, while Bankston told Wired, "If this is the level of nuance and understanding with which are policymakers are viewing technical issues we’re in a profoundly worrisome place."

Burr and Feinstein said in a statement Friday, "We’re still in the process of soliciting input from stakeholders and hope to have final language ready soon," according to the WSJ.

Reuters reported Thursday that the "White House is declining to offer public support" for Feinstein and Burr's legislation.

As the draft encryption bill makes waves, the Justice Department on Friday is continuing its push to get "Apple to unlock a drug dealer's device even after the man pleaded guilty,"  the Guardian reports.

In a letter to U.S. District Judge Margo Brodie, prosecutors wrote: "The government's application is not moot, and the government continues to require Apple's assistance in accessing the data that it is authorized to search by warrant."


Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.

... We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.

GOP 'Silence Speaks Volumes,' Says Ilhan Omar as Boebert's Bigotry Goes Unpunished

"Normalizing this bigotry not only endangers my life but the lives of all Muslims. Anti-Muslim bigotry has no place in Congress."

Brett Wilkins ·


Africans Should Be 'Applauded, Not Punished,' Say Advocates Amid Omicron Travel Ban

"What is going on right now is inevitable," said African Union Vaccine Delivery Alliance co-chair Dr. Ayoade Alakija. "It's a result of the world's failure to vaccinate in an equitable, urgent, and speedy manner."

Brett Wilkins ·


Biden Drilling Report Blasted as 'Shocking Capitulation to the Needs of Corporate Polluters'

"Greenlighting more fossil fuel extraction, then pretending it's OK by nudging up royalty rates, is like rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic," said one campaigner.

Jessica Corbett ·


UNESCO Members Adopt First Global AI Ethics Agreement 'To Benefit Humanity'

"We're at a critical juncture in history," said Ethics in Tech founder Vahid Razavi. "We need as humans to come together and decide what is the best course of action to take with these technologies before they surpass us in their abilities."

Brett Wilkins ·


Progressive US Lawmakers Mark Black Friday With Calls to Pass the PRO Act

"The right to organize, fight for better working conditions, and fair pay must always be protected."

Jessica Corbett ·

Support our work.

We are independent, non-profit, advertising-free and 100% reader supported.

Subscribe to our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values.
Direct to your inbox.

Subscribe to our Newsletter.


Common Dreams, Inc. Founded 1997. Registered 501(c3) Non-Profit | Privacy Policy
Common Dreams Logo