Feb 18, 2009
On Tuesday, President Obama announced the deployment of 17,000 additional US troops to Afghanistan.
Two decades and two days after the Soviet army withdrew from its
disastrous occupation in Afghanistan, it saddens me that we're heading
down a path that has ensnared the British empire and the former Soviet
Union. What's especially troubling is that Obama, who wisely ordered a
fundamental review of US options in that country, is sending troops
without even waiting for the review process to conclude. Although Obama
insisted in his statement of Tuesday that "this troop increase does not
pre-determine the outcome of that strategic review," one has to ask :
Why not wait for the results of a comprehensive review that, if
conducted honestly, may well determine that the Administration should
take military escalation off the table in favor of a non-military
regional strategy to stabilize Afghanistan and strengthen Pakistan?
As Tom Andrews, National Director of Win Without War put it, "The first
principle for someone who finds himself in a hole is to stop digging,
The US policy 'hole' in Afghanistan is not of the new Administration's
making. But it is important for the President to consider if adding new
US combat forces in Afghanistan, without a new and comprehensive plan,
for US policy there, might be digging an even bigger hole."
Escalating the occupation of Afghanistan will bleed us of the resources
needed for economic recovery, further destabilize Pakistan, open a rift
with our European allies, and negate the positive consequences of
withdrawing from Iraq on our image in the Muslim world. Escalation will
not secure a better future for the Afghan people or increase US
security. How will additional troops help meet the "clear and
achievable objectives in Afghanistan and the region" that Obama spoke
of Tuesday afternoon? We have not received a clear answer to that
fundamental question.
Those who support non-military solutions should affect the outcome of
the Obama Administration's ongoing strategic review process ends. Write
your Representatives. Go to GETAFGHANISTANRIGHT.COM to find ideas for
how you might get involved and what you can do.
Tell your Representatives that the short and longterm costs of this
conflict demand alternatives. Tell them that they should think twice
before sending young men and women to die in the mountains and deserts
of Afghanistan. The people of this country deserve a national
conversation --and oversight--before any decision is made, and before
we know what the mission and strategy is.
The decision Obama makes in the coming weeks will tell us a lot about
whether his presidency will succeed in restoring America --or, as Win
Without War's Tom Andrews warns, dig us into an even bigger hole!
President Obama--don't make this your war!
Join Us: News for people demanding a better world
Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place. We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference. Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. Join with us today! |
© 2023 The Nation
Katrina Vanden Heuvel
Katrina vanden Heuvel is an American editor and publisher. She is the editor, publisher, and part-owner of the magazine The Nation. She has been the magazine's editor since 1995.
On Tuesday, President Obama announced the deployment of 17,000 additional US troops to Afghanistan.
Two decades and two days after the Soviet army withdrew from its
disastrous occupation in Afghanistan, it saddens me that we're heading
down a path that has ensnared the British empire and the former Soviet
Union. What's especially troubling is that Obama, who wisely ordered a
fundamental review of US options in that country, is sending troops
without even waiting for the review process to conclude. Although Obama
insisted in his statement of Tuesday that "this troop increase does not
pre-determine the outcome of that strategic review," one has to ask :
Why not wait for the results of a comprehensive review that, if
conducted honestly, may well determine that the Administration should
take military escalation off the table in favor of a non-military
regional strategy to stabilize Afghanistan and strengthen Pakistan?
As Tom Andrews, National Director of Win Without War put it, "The first
principle for someone who finds himself in a hole is to stop digging,
The US policy 'hole' in Afghanistan is not of the new Administration's
making. But it is important for the President to consider if adding new
US combat forces in Afghanistan, without a new and comprehensive plan,
for US policy there, might be digging an even bigger hole."
Escalating the occupation of Afghanistan will bleed us of the resources
needed for economic recovery, further destabilize Pakistan, open a rift
with our European allies, and negate the positive consequences of
withdrawing from Iraq on our image in the Muslim world. Escalation will
not secure a better future for the Afghan people or increase US
security. How will additional troops help meet the "clear and
achievable objectives in Afghanistan and the region" that Obama spoke
of Tuesday afternoon? We have not received a clear answer to that
fundamental question.
Those who support non-military solutions should affect the outcome of
the Obama Administration's ongoing strategic review process ends. Write
your Representatives. Go to GETAFGHANISTANRIGHT.COM to find ideas for
how you might get involved and what you can do.
Tell your Representatives that the short and longterm costs of this
conflict demand alternatives. Tell them that they should think twice
before sending young men and women to die in the mountains and deserts
of Afghanistan. The people of this country deserve a national
conversation --and oversight--before any decision is made, and before
we know what the mission and strategy is.
The decision Obama makes in the coming weeks will tell us a lot about
whether his presidency will succeed in restoring America --or, as Win
Without War's Tom Andrews warns, dig us into an even bigger hole!
President Obama--don't make this your war!
Katrina Vanden Heuvel
Katrina vanden Heuvel is an American editor and publisher. She is the editor, publisher, and part-owner of the magazine The Nation. She has been the magazine's editor since 1995.
On Tuesday, President Obama announced the deployment of 17,000 additional US troops to Afghanistan.
Two decades and two days after the Soviet army withdrew from its
disastrous occupation in Afghanistan, it saddens me that we're heading
down a path that has ensnared the British empire and the former Soviet
Union. What's especially troubling is that Obama, who wisely ordered a
fundamental review of US options in that country, is sending troops
without even waiting for the review process to conclude. Although Obama
insisted in his statement of Tuesday that "this troop increase does not
pre-determine the outcome of that strategic review," one has to ask :
Why not wait for the results of a comprehensive review that, if
conducted honestly, may well determine that the Administration should
take military escalation off the table in favor of a non-military
regional strategy to stabilize Afghanistan and strengthen Pakistan?
As Tom Andrews, National Director of Win Without War put it, "The first
principle for someone who finds himself in a hole is to stop digging,
The US policy 'hole' in Afghanistan is not of the new Administration's
making. But it is important for the President to consider if adding new
US combat forces in Afghanistan, without a new and comprehensive plan,
for US policy there, might be digging an even bigger hole."
Escalating the occupation of Afghanistan will bleed us of the resources
needed for economic recovery, further destabilize Pakistan, open a rift
with our European allies, and negate the positive consequences of
withdrawing from Iraq on our image in the Muslim world. Escalation will
not secure a better future for the Afghan people or increase US
security. How will additional troops help meet the "clear and
achievable objectives in Afghanistan and the region" that Obama spoke
of Tuesday afternoon? We have not received a clear answer to that
fundamental question.
Those who support non-military solutions should affect the outcome of
the Obama Administration's ongoing strategic review process ends. Write
your Representatives. Go to GETAFGHANISTANRIGHT.COM to find ideas for
how you might get involved and what you can do.
Tell your Representatives that the short and longterm costs of this
conflict demand alternatives. Tell them that they should think twice
before sending young men and women to die in the mountains and deserts
of Afghanistan. The people of this country deserve a national
conversation --and oversight--before any decision is made, and before
we know what the mission and strategy is.
The decision Obama makes in the coming weeks will tell us a lot about
whether his presidency will succeed in restoring America --or, as Win
Without War's Tom Andrews warns, dig us into an even bigger hole!
President Obama--don't make this your war!
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.