May 21, 2021
Journalists condemned the Associated Press overnight and into Friday after the news agency dismissed a recently hired staffer following observations she made on social media about coverage of the Israeli occupation of Palestine.
Emily Wilder, who began working at the AP as a news associate on May 3, was fired Wednesday--three days after tweeting that despite promoting "objectivity" in reporting, many in the corporate media make "political choices" in how they choose to cover Israel and Palestine.
\u201c\u201cobjectivity\u201d feels fickle when the basic terms we use to report news implicitly stake a claim. using \u201cisrael\u201d but never \u201cpalestine,\u201d or \u201cwar\u201d but not \u201csiege and occupation\u201d are political choices\u2014yet media make those exact choices all the time without being flagged as biased\u201d— emily wilder (@emily wilder) 1621208060
The AP told Wilder she had violated the company's social media policy and fired her, but according to an interview with the San Francisco Chronicle, Wilder was not told which of her social media posts had led to the decision.
Although the AP's policy as written only applies to social media posts during a staff member's employment--and a spokesperson for the outlet told reporters Wilder was dismissed for posts made "during her time at AP"--Wilder said she believed she was fired because of old social media posts she wrote when she was a college student at Stanford University, from which she graduated in 2020.
Wilder, who is Jewish, was an active member of Jewish Voice for Peace and Students for Justice in Palestine and posted about Palestinian rights while in school.
Following her post on Sunday, the Stanford College Republicans publicly branded Wilder as an "anti-Israel agitator" and denounced the AP for hiring her.
The Federalist, Washington Free Beacon, and Fox News quickly picked up the story, noting that Wilder had led rallies for Palestinian rights while in college and attempting to connect her employment to the Israel Defense Forces attack on the building which housed the AP's Gaza bureau, which Israel claimed also contained an office run by Hamas.
Wilder said the firing was a response to the negative publicity.
"This is clearly a case of selective enforcement," of the social media policy, Wilder told the Chronicle. "I don't buy their convenient cover story at all because they never told me what specifically I did wrong, and in the termination letter, they said the harassment campaign prompted the review, and in that review they found supposed violations of their policy."
"That's an admission this was prompted by the campaign against me, and it's really unfortunate the Associated Press is abdicating their responsibility to not only me, but to all journalists just because a group of college students wanted to engage in a witch hunt," she said.
Journalists and media critics came to Wilder's defense, with some noting that the news of her firing came as reports surfaced about CNN anchor Chris Cuomo advising his brother, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, about how to respond to sexual harassment allegations earlier this year.
Cuomo, the host of "Cuomo Prime Time," apologized on air during his show Thursday night. According to The Hill, CNN has no plans to the disciplinary action against the host.
\u201cthe punishment disparities between Chris Cuomo and Emily Wilder is a good example of how this industry often works\u201d— Steven Rich (@Steven Rich) 1621544953
\u201cToday in journalism news: Chris Cuomo still has a job after it was revealed he was helping his Governor brother do PR for sexual harassment allegations. Emily Wilder was fired by AP for wanting a free Palestine.\u201d— Sana Saeed (@Sana Saeed) 1621566039
\u201cToday in nonsensical media news, Chris Cuomo faces no discipline and Emily Wilder has no job. https://t.co/RDr9qsftc3\u201d— Blair Miller (@Blair Miller) 1621559883
\u201cThe gross disparity between the treatment of @ChrisCuomo and @vv1lder has me in such a dark place. I\u2019m happy to see so many journalists speaking out against the outrageous failures of two legacy news organizations. But I am so TIRED of seeing us do so but seeing ZERO change.\u201d— Katie Campbell (@Katie Campbell) 1621568905
"These social media policies are so nebulous, almost by design, so that they can be selectively enforced...in a way that polices and harms the most vulnerable journalists among us," Wilder told the Washington Post.
If Not Now, the Jewish-led pro-Palestinian rights organization, was among those that expressed solidarity with Wilder.
\u201cThis is awful - we need more journalists who believe in freedom for Palestinians, not fewer. \n\nSolidarity with Emily Wilder.\u201d— IfNotNow\ud83d\udd25 (@IfNotNow\ud83d\udd25) 1621547020
"This is completely unjust and outrageous and unaccountable behavior from AP management," tweeted Los Angeles Times reporter Matt Pearce, the president of Media Guild of the West. "If you can't explain to someone what policy they've violated, you have no business firing them."
Join Us: News for people demanding a better world
Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place. We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference. Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
Journalists condemned the Associated Press overnight and into Friday after the news agency dismissed a recently hired staffer following observations she made on social media about coverage of the Israeli occupation of Palestine.
Emily Wilder, who began working at the AP as a news associate on May 3, was fired Wednesday--three days after tweeting that despite promoting "objectivity" in reporting, many in the corporate media make "political choices" in how they choose to cover Israel and Palestine.
\u201c\u201cobjectivity\u201d feels fickle when the basic terms we use to report news implicitly stake a claim. using \u201cisrael\u201d but never \u201cpalestine,\u201d or \u201cwar\u201d but not \u201csiege and occupation\u201d are political choices\u2014yet media make those exact choices all the time without being flagged as biased\u201d— emily wilder (@emily wilder) 1621208060
The AP told Wilder she had violated the company's social media policy and fired her, but according to an interview with the San Francisco Chronicle, Wilder was not told which of her social media posts had led to the decision.
Although the AP's policy as written only applies to social media posts during a staff member's employment--and a spokesperson for the outlet told reporters Wilder was dismissed for posts made "during her time at AP"--Wilder said she believed she was fired because of old social media posts she wrote when she was a college student at Stanford University, from which she graduated in 2020.
Wilder, who is Jewish, was an active member of Jewish Voice for Peace and Students for Justice in Palestine and posted about Palestinian rights while in school.
Following her post on Sunday, the Stanford College Republicans publicly branded Wilder as an "anti-Israel agitator" and denounced the AP for hiring her.
The Federalist, Washington Free Beacon, and Fox News quickly picked up the story, noting that Wilder had led rallies for Palestinian rights while in college and attempting to connect her employment to the Israel Defense Forces attack on the building which housed the AP's Gaza bureau, which Israel claimed also contained an office run by Hamas.
Wilder said the firing was a response to the negative publicity.
"This is clearly a case of selective enforcement," of the social media policy, Wilder told the Chronicle. "I don't buy their convenient cover story at all because they never told me what specifically I did wrong, and in the termination letter, they said the harassment campaign prompted the review, and in that review they found supposed violations of their policy."
"That's an admission this was prompted by the campaign against me, and it's really unfortunate the Associated Press is abdicating their responsibility to not only me, but to all journalists just because a group of college students wanted to engage in a witch hunt," she said.
Journalists and media critics came to Wilder's defense, with some noting that the news of her firing came as reports surfaced about CNN anchor Chris Cuomo advising his brother, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, about how to respond to sexual harassment allegations earlier this year.
Cuomo, the host of "Cuomo Prime Time," apologized on air during his show Thursday night. According to The Hill, CNN has no plans to the disciplinary action against the host.
\u201cthe punishment disparities between Chris Cuomo and Emily Wilder is a good example of how this industry often works\u201d— Steven Rich (@Steven Rich) 1621544953
\u201cToday in journalism news: Chris Cuomo still has a job after it was revealed he was helping his Governor brother do PR for sexual harassment allegations. Emily Wilder was fired by AP for wanting a free Palestine.\u201d— Sana Saeed (@Sana Saeed) 1621566039
\u201cToday in nonsensical media news, Chris Cuomo faces no discipline and Emily Wilder has no job. https://t.co/RDr9qsftc3\u201d— Blair Miller (@Blair Miller) 1621559883
\u201cThe gross disparity between the treatment of @ChrisCuomo and @vv1lder has me in such a dark place. I\u2019m happy to see so many journalists speaking out against the outrageous failures of two legacy news organizations. But I am so TIRED of seeing us do so but seeing ZERO change.\u201d— Katie Campbell (@Katie Campbell) 1621568905
"These social media policies are so nebulous, almost by design, so that they can be selectively enforced...in a way that polices and harms the most vulnerable journalists among us," Wilder told the Washington Post.
If Not Now, the Jewish-led pro-Palestinian rights organization, was among those that expressed solidarity with Wilder.
\u201cThis is awful - we need more journalists who believe in freedom for Palestinians, not fewer. \n\nSolidarity with Emily Wilder.\u201d— IfNotNow\ud83d\udd25 (@IfNotNow\ud83d\udd25) 1621547020
"This is completely unjust and outrageous and unaccountable behavior from AP management," tweeted Los Angeles Times reporter Matt Pearce, the president of Media Guild of the West. "If you can't explain to someone what policy they've violated, you have no business firing them."
Journalists condemned the Associated Press overnight and into Friday after the news agency dismissed a recently hired staffer following observations she made on social media about coverage of the Israeli occupation of Palestine.
Emily Wilder, who began working at the AP as a news associate on May 3, was fired Wednesday--three days after tweeting that despite promoting "objectivity" in reporting, many in the corporate media make "political choices" in how they choose to cover Israel and Palestine.
\u201c\u201cobjectivity\u201d feels fickle when the basic terms we use to report news implicitly stake a claim. using \u201cisrael\u201d but never \u201cpalestine,\u201d or \u201cwar\u201d but not \u201csiege and occupation\u201d are political choices\u2014yet media make those exact choices all the time without being flagged as biased\u201d— emily wilder (@emily wilder) 1621208060
The AP told Wilder she had violated the company's social media policy and fired her, but according to an interview with the San Francisco Chronicle, Wilder was not told which of her social media posts had led to the decision.
Although the AP's policy as written only applies to social media posts during a staff member's employment--and a spokesperson for the outlet told reporters Wilder was dismissed for posts made "during her time at AP"--Wilder said she believed she was fired because of old social media posts she wrote when she was a college student at Stanford University, from which she graduated in 2020.
Wilder, who is Jewish, was an active member of Jewish Voice for Peace and Students for Justice in Palestine and posted about Palestinian rights while in school.
Following her post on Sunday, the Stanford College Republicans publicly branded Wilder as an "anti-Israel agitator" and denounced the AP for hiring her.
The Federalist, Washington Free Beacon, and Fox News quickly picked up the story, noting that Wilder had led rallies for Palestinian rights while in college and attempting to connect her employment to the Israel Defense Forces attack on the building which housed the AP's Gaza bureau, which Israel claimed also contained an office run by Hamas.
Wilder said the firing was a response to the negative publicity.
"This is clearly a case of selective enforcement," of the social media policy, Wilder told the Chronicle. "I don't buy their convenient cover story at all because they never told me what specifically I did wrong, and in the termination letter, they said the harassment campaign prompted the review, and in that review they found supposed violations of their policy."
"That's an admission this was prompted by the campaign against me, and it's really unfortunate the Associated Press is abdicating their responsibility to not only me, but to all journalists just because a group of college students wanted to engage in a witch hunt," she said.
Journalists and media critics came to Wilder's defense, with some noting that the news of her firing came as reports surfaced about CNN anchor Chris Cuomo advising his brother, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, about how to respond to sexual harassment allegations earlier this year.
Cuomo, the host of "Cuomo Prime Time," apologized on air during his show Thursday night. According to The Hill, CNN has no plans to the disciplinary action against the host.
\u201cthe punishment disparities between Chris Cuomo and Emily Wilder is a good example of how this industry often works\u201d— Steven Rich (@Steven Rich) 1621544953
\u201cToday in journalism news: Chris Cuomo still has a job after it was revealed he was helping his Governor brother do PR for sexual harassment allegations. Emily Wilder was fired by AP for wanting a free Palestine.\u201d— Sana Saeed (@Sana Saeed) 1621566039
\u201cToday in nonsensical media news, Chris Cuomo faces no discipline and Emily Wilder has no job. https://t.co/RDr9qsftc3\u201d— Blair Miller (@Blair Miller) 1621559883
\u201cThe gross disparity between the treatment of @ChrisCuomo and @vv1lder has me in such a dark place. I\u2019m happy to see so many journalists speaking out against the outrageous failures of two legacy news organizations. But I am so TIRED of seeing us do so but seeing ZERO change.\u201d— Katie Campbell (@Katie Campbell) 1621568905
"These social media policies are so nebulous, almost by design, so that they can be selectively enforced...in a way that polices and harms the most vulnerable journalists among us," Wilder told the Washington Post.
If Not Now, the Jewish-led pro-Palestinian rights organization, was among those that expressed solidarity with Wilder.
\u201cThis is awful - we need more journalists who believe in freedom for Palestinians, not fewer. \n\nSolidarity with Emily Wilder.\u201d— IfNotNow\ud83d\udd25 (@IfNotNow\ud83d\udd25) 1621547020
"This is completely unjust and outrageous and unaccountable behavior from AP management," tweeted Los Angeles Times reporter Matt Pearce, the president of Media Guild of the West. "If you can't explain to someone what policy they've violated, you have no business firing them."
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.