Scott Warren, a volunteer for the humanitarian aid group No More Deaths, stands in the group's office on May 11, 2019 in Ajo, Arizona. (Photo: John Moore/Getty Images)
Attempt to 'Criminalize Basic Human Kindness' Fails as Activist Scott Warren Found Not Guilty on All Charges
"The Trump administration is wrong to try to prosecute people who are only trying to save lives. By threatening Dr. Warren with a decade in prison, the U.S. government sought to criminalize compassion."
An Arizona jury on Wednesday found human rights activist Scott Warren not guilty of "harboring" undocumented migrants, charges that were levied by federal prosecutors after the geography teacher provided food, water, and shelter to two men traveling through the desert in 2018.
"The government failed in its attempt to criminalize basic human kindness," Warren, a volunteer worker with advocacy group No More Deaths, said from the steps of the Arizona courthouse following his acquittal. "As we stand here, people's brothers, sister, father, spouses, and children are in the midst of the perilous desert crossing. The need for humanitarian aid continues."
"This verdict is validation of what we have always known: that humanitarian aid is never a crime. We will continue to provide food, water, and medical aid to all those who need it."
--No More Deaths
On Twitter, No More Deaths applauded the jury's decision.
"Yet again, No More Deaths has withstood the government's attempts to criminalize basic human compassion," the group said. "This verdict is validation of what we have always known: that humanitarian aid is never a crime. We will continue to provide food, water, and medical aid to all those who need it, until the day that no one dies or disappears while crossing the deserts and oceans of the world."
If convicted, Warren would have faced up to a decade in prison. As Reuters reported, the Tucson jury took just over two hours to find Warren not guilty on two federal charges.
After the case concluded Wednesday, one of the jurors told The Intercept's Ryan Devereaux outside the courthouse, "I think we all agreed that what he and these people do is fantastic."
Devereaux reported on Twitter that "we also received a very significant decision in Warren's misdemeanor case from earlier this year: the judge found that that Warren's religious freedom defense overcame that charge he faced for leaving water for migrants on public lands."
\u201c@NoMoreDeaths @mollycrabapple @pmingram @RafaelCarranza To put this another way: there is no indication that this was a case of jury nullification. The government lost all on its own by putting on a case that was unconvincing to the jurors.\u201d— Ryan Devereaux (@Ryan Devereaux) 1573606804
Erika Guevara-Rosas, Americas director at Amnesty International, which supported Warren throughout the legal process, applauded the verdict in a statement Wednesday night.
"Sense has prevailed today with the jury exonerating Dr. Scott Warren for a simple reason: humanitarian aid is never a crime," Guevara-Rosas said. "The Trump administration is wrong to try to prosecute people who are only trying to save lives. By threatening Dr. Warren with a decade in prison, the U.S. government sought to criminalize compassion and weaponize the deadly desert against people who make the perilous journey to the United States in search of safety."
\u201c\u270a Solidarity with all people crossing borders and those who provide aid to help them make their way safely. Here\u2019s to a world in which migration for any reason is seen for what it is- an act of courage and resilience \u270a\n\nhttps://t.co/MP9bYCkomm\u201d— Alli McCracken #FreePalestine \u26a1\ufe0f #CloseGuantanamo (@Alli McCracken #FreePalestine \u26a1\ufe0f #CloseGuantanamo) 1574299562
Before the trial began, Amnesty circulated a petition pushing the government to #DropTheCharges. Warren's trial that wrapped up Wednesday followed a trial that ended with a hung jury in June. Prosecutors announced in July that they were dropping a conspiracy charge but would retry him for harboring.
Dozens of Warren's supporters and fellow volunteers gathered outside the courthouse Wednesday to celebrate the acquittal.
\u201cJubilant crowd outside the #Tucson federal courthouse as @NoMoreDeaths volunteers and supporters celebrate Scott Warren\u2019s acquittal on felony harboring charges. Jury took just 2 hours to deliberate. First trial they took over 2 days and could not agree on verdict.\u201d— Rafael Carranza \ud83c\udf35 (@Rafael Carranza \ud83c\udf35) 1574269952
\u201cJury finds @NoMoreDeaths volunteer #ScottWarren not guilty in two harboring charges brought by the U.S. government. Photographed for @Wochenzeitung.\u201d— caitlin o\u2019hara (@caitlin o\u2019hara) 1574296801
Jamil Dakwar, director of the ACLU's Human Rights Program, took to Twitter Wednesday night to celebrate the jury's verdict. "Excellent news!" he wrote. "Advocacy for migrants' rights and human compassion are not a crime."
The Congressional Hispanic Caucus also welcomed Warren's acquittal on Twitter.
"Human compassion shouldn't be illegal," the caucus tweeted. "Providing food and water to those in need should not be illegal. We must stand by our values and help immigrants in need, just as Scott did."
\u201cSome good news \u2013 Scott Warren has been found not guilty after providing migrants in need with aid.\n\nHuman compassion shouldn\u2019t be illegal. Providing food & water to those in need should not be illegal.\n\nWe must stand by our values & help immigrants in need, just as Scott did.\u201d— Congressional Hispanic Caucus (@Congressional Hispanic Caucus) 1574291302
Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), a top-tier candidate in the 2020 Democratic presidential primary race, acknowledged Warren's acquittal in a tweet Thursday morning, writing that "if we criminalize compassion, we have lost our way as a society."
\u201cGood. If we criminalize compassion, we have lost our way as a society. Providing humanitarian aid to men, women and children so that they do not die in the desert\u2014whether on the border or anywhere\u2014is not a crime.\u201d— Bernie Sanders (@Bernie Sanders) 1574350503
The grassroots group New Sanctuary Coalition tied Warren's case to the broader circumstances surrounding his volunteer work, tweeting: "Now, we demand an end to the Trump administration's continued targeting of migrant justice activists, the dehumanization of migrants and refugees."
This post has been updated with background on Scott Warren's case as well as reporting from the courthouse Wednesday and more statements from supporters.
An Urgent Message From Our Co-Founder
Dear Common Dreams reader, The U.S. is on a fast track to authoritarianism like nothing I've ever seen. Meanwhile, corporate news outlets are utterly capitulating to Trump, twisting their coverage to avoid drawing his ire while lining up to stuff cash in his pockets. That's why I believe that Common Dreams is doing the best and most consequential reporting that we've ever done. Our small but mighty team is a progressive reporting powerhouse, covering the news every day that the corporate media never will. Our mission has always been simple: To inform. To inspire. And to ignite change for the common good. Now here's the key piece that I want all our readers to understand: None of this would be possible without your financial support. That's not just some fundraising cliche. It's the absolute and literal truth. We don't accept corporate advertising and never will. We don't have a paywall because we don't think people should be blocked from critical news based on their ability to pay. Everything we do is funded by the donations of readers like you. The final deadline for our crucial Summer Campaign fundraising drive is just days away, and we’re falling short of our must-hit goal. Will you donate now to help power the nonprofit, independent reporting of Common Dreams? Thank you for being a vital member of our community. Together, we can keep independent journalism alive when it’s needed most. - Craig Brown, Co-founder |
An Arizona jury on Wednesday found human rights activist Scott Warren not guilty of "harboring" undocumented migrants, charges that were levied by federal prosecutors after the geography teacher provided food, water, and shelter to two men traveling through the desert in 2018.
"The government failed in its attempt to criminalize basic human kindness," Warren, a volunteer worker with advocacy group No More Deaths, said from the steps of the Arizona courthouse following his acquittal. "As we stand here, people's brothers, sister, father, spouses, and children are in the midst of the perilous desert crossing. The need for humanitarian aid continues."
"This verdict is validation of what we have always known: that humanitarian aid is never a crime. We will continue to provide food, water, and medical aid to all those who need it."
--No More Deaths
On Twitter, No More Deaths applauded the jury's decision.
"Yet again, No More Deaths has withstood the government's attempts to criminalize basic human compassion," the group said. "This verdict is validation of what we have always known: that humanitarian aid is never a crime. We will continue to provide food, water, and medical aid to all those who need it, until the day that no one dies or disappears while crossing the deserts and oceans of the world."
If convicted, Warren would have faced up to a decade in prison. As Reuters reported, the Tucson jury took just over two hours to find Warren not guilty on two federal charges.
After the case concluded Wednesday, one of the jurors told The Intercept's Ryan Devereaux outside the courthouse, "I think we all agreed that what he and these people do is fantastic."
Devereaux reported on Twitter that "we also received a very significant decision in Warren's misdemeanor case from earlier this year: the judge found that that Warren's religious freedom defense overcame that charge he faced for leaving water for migrants on public lands."
\u201c@NoMoreDeaths @mollycrabapple @pmingram @RafaelCarranza To put this another way: there is no indication that this was a case of jury nullification. The government lost all on its own by putting on a case that was unconvincing to the jurors.\u201d— Ryan Devereaux (@Ryan Devereaux) 1573606804
Erika Guevara-Rosas, Americas director at Amnesty International, which supported Warren throughout the legal process, applauded the verdict in a statement Wednesday night.
"Sense has prevailed today with the jury exonerating Dr. Scott Warren for a simple reason: humanitarian aid is never a crime," Guevara-Rosas said. "The Trump administration is wrong to try to prosecute people who are only trying to save lives. By threatening Dr. Warren with a decade in prison, the U.S. government sought to criminalize compassion and weaponize the deadly desert against people who make the perilous journey to the United States in search of safety."
\u201c\u270a Solidarity with all people crossing borders and those who provide aid to help them make their way safely. Here\u2019s to a world in which migration for any reason is seen for what it is- an act of courage and resilience \u270a\n\nhttps://t.co/MP9bYCkomm\u201d— Alli McCracken #FreePalestine \u26a1\ufe0f #CloseGuantanamo (@Alli McCracken #FreePalestine \u26a1\ufe0f #CloseGuantanamo) 1574299562
Before the trial began, Amnesty circulated a petition pushing the government to #DropTheCharges. Warren's trial that wrapped up Wednesday followed a trial that ended with a hung jury in June. Prosecutors announced in July that they were dropping a conspiracy charge but would retry him for harboring.
Dozens of Warren's supporters and fellow volunteers gathered outside the courthouse Wednesday to celebrate the acquittal.
\u201cJubilant crowd outside the #Tucson federal courthouse as @NoMoreDeaths volunteers and supporters celebrate Scott Warren\u2019s acquittal on felony harboring charges. Jury took just 2 hours to deliberate. First trial they took over 2 days and could not agree on verdict.\u201d— Rafael Carranza \ud83c\udf35 (@Rafael Carranza \ud83c\udf35) 1574269952
\u201cJury finds @NoMoreDeaths volunteer #ScottWarren not guilty in two harboring charges brought by the U.S. government. Photographed for @Wochenzeitung.\u201d— caitlin o\u2019hara (@caitlin o\u2019hara) 1574296801
Jamil Dakwar, director of the ACLU's Human Rights Program, took to Twitter Wednesday night to celebrate the jury's verdict. "Excellent news!" he wrote. "Advocacy for migrants' rights and human compassion are not a crime."
The Congressional Hispanic Caucus also welcomed Warren's acquittal on Twitter.
"Human compassion shouldn't be illegal," the caucus tweeted. "Providing food and water to those in need should not be illegal. We must stand by our values and help immigrants in need, just as Scott did."
\u201cSome good news \u2013 Scott Warren has been found not guilty after providing migrants in need with aid.\n\nHuman compassion shouldn\u2019t be illegal. Providing food & water to those in need should not be illegal.\n\nWe must stand by our values & help immigrants in need, just as Scott did.\u201d— Congressional Hispanic Caucus (@Congressional Hispanic Caucus) 1574291302
Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), a top-tier candidate in the 2020 Democratic presidential primary race, acknowledged Warren's acquittal in a tweet Thursday morning, writing that "if we criminalize compassion, we have lost our way as a society."
\u201cGood. If we criminalize compassion, we have lost our way as a society. Providing humanitarian aid to men, women and children so that they do not die in the desert\u2014whether on the border or anywhere\u2014is not a crime.\u201d— Bernie Sanders (@Bernie Sanders) 1574350503
The grassroots group New Sanctuary Coalition tied Warren's case to the broader circumstances surrounding his volunteer work, tweeting: "Now, we demand an end to the Trump administration's continued targeting of migrant justice activists, the dehumanization of migrants and refugees."
This post has been updated with background on Scott Warren's case as well as reporting from the courthouse Wednesday and more statements from supporters.
An Arizona jury on Wednesday found human rights activist Scott Warren not guilty of "harboring" undocumented migrants, charges that were levied by federal prosecutors after the geography teacher provided food, water, and shelter to two men traveling through the desert in 2018.
"The government failed in its attempt to criminalize basic human kindness," Warren, a volunteer worker with advocacy group No More Deaths, said from the steps of the Arizona courthouse following his acquittal. "As we stand here, people's brothers, sister, father, spouses, and children are in the midst of the perilous desert crossing. The need for humanitarian aid continues."
"This verdict is validation of what we have always known: that humanitarian aid is never a crime. We will continue to provide food, water, and medical aid to all those who need it."
--No More Deaths
On Twitter, No More Deaths applauded the jury's decision.
"Yet again, No More Deaths has withstood the government's attempts to criminalize basic human compassion," the group said. "This verdict is validation of what we have always known: that humanitarian aid is never a crime. We will continue to provide food, water, and medical aid to all those who need it, until the day that no one dies or disappears while crossing the deserts and oceans of the world."
If convicted, Warren would have faced up to a decade in prison. As Reuters reported, the Tucson jury took just over two hours to find Warren not guilty on two federal charges.
After the case concluded Wednesday, one of the jurors told The Intercept's Ryan Devereaux outside the courthouse, "I think we all agreed that what he and these people do is fantastic."
Devereaux reported on Twitter that "we also received a very significant decision in Warren's misdemeanor case from earlier this year: the judge found that that Warren's religious freedom defense overcame that charge he faced for leaving water for migrants on public lands."
\u201c@NoMoreDeaths @mollycrabapple @pmingram @RafaelCarranza To put this another way: there is no indication that this was a case of jury nullification. The government lost all on its own by putting on a case that was unconvincing to the jurors.\u201d— Ryan Devereaux (@Ryan Devereaux) 1573606804
Erika Guevara-Rosas, Americas director at Amnesty International, which supported Warren throughout the legal process, applauded the verdict in a statement Wednesday night.
"Sense has prevailed today with the jury exonerating Dr. Scott Warren for a simple reason: humanitarian aid is never a crime," Guevara-Rosas said. "The Trump administration is wrong to try to prosecute people who are only trying to save lives. By threatening Dr. Warren with a decade in prison, the U.S. government sought to criminalize compassion and weaponize the deadly desert against people who make the perilous journey to the United States in search of safety."
\u201c\u270a Solidarity with all people crossing borders and those who provide aid to help them make their way safely. Here\u2019s to a world in which migration for any reason is seen for what it is- an act of courage and resilience \u270a\n\nhttps://t.co/MP9bYCkomm\u201d— Alli McCracken #FreePalestine \u26a1\ufe0f #CloseGuantanamo (@Alli McCracken #FreePalestine \u26a1\ufe0f #CloseGuantanamo) 1574299562
Before the trial began, Amnesty circulated a petition pushing the government to #DropTheCharges. Warren's trial that wrapped up Wednesday followed a trial that ended with a hung jury in June. Prosecutors announced in July that they were dropping a conspiracy charge but would retry him for harboring.
Dozens of Warren's supporters and fellow volunteers gathered outside the courthouse Wednesday to celebrate the acquittal.
\u201cJubilant crowd outside the #Tucson federal courthouse as @NoMoreDeaths volunteers and supporters celebrate Scott Warren\u2019s acquittal on felony harboring charges. Jury took just 2 hours to deliberate. First trial they took over 2 days and could not agree on verdict.\u201d— Rafael Carranza \ud83c\udf35 (@Rafael Carranza \ud83c\udf35) 1574269952
\u201cJury finds @NoMoreDeaths volunteer #ScottWarren not guilty in two harboring charges brought by the U.S. government. Photographed for @Wochenzeitung.\u201d— caitlin o\u2019hara (@caitlin o\u2019hara) 1574296801
Jamil Dakwar, director of the ACLU's Human Rights Program, took to Twitter Wednesday night to celebrate the jury's verdict. "Excellent news!" he wrote. "Advocacy for migrants' rights and human compassion are not a crime."
The Congressional Hispanic Caucus also welcomed Warren's acquittal on Twitter.
"Human compassion shouldn't be illegal," the caucus tweeted. "Providing food and water to those in need should not be illegal. We must stand by our values and help immigrants in need, just as Scott did."
\u201cSome good news \u2013 Scott Warren has been found not guilty after providing migrants in need with aid.\n\nHuman compassion shouldn\u2019t be illegal. Providing food & water to those in need should not be illegal.\n\nWe must stand by our values & help immigrants in need, just as Scott did.\u201d— Congressional Hispanic Caucus (@Congressional Hispanic Caucus) 1574291302
Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), a top-tier candidate in the 2020 Democratic presidential primary race, acknowledged Warren's acquittal in a tweet Thursday morning, writing that "if we criminalize compassion, we have lost our way as a society."
\u201cGood. If we criminalize compassion, we have lost our way as a society. Providing humanitarian aid to men, women and children so that they do not die in the desert\u2014whether on the border or anywhere\u2014is not a crime.\u201d— Bernie Sanders (@Bernie Sanders) 1574350503
The grassroots group New Sanctuary Coalition tied Warren's case to the broader circumstances surrounding his volunteer work, tweeting: "Now, we demand an end to the Trump administration's continued targeting of migrant justice activists, the dehumanization of migrants and refugees."
This post has been updated with background on Scott Warren's case as well as reporting from the courthouse Wednesday and more statements from supporters.