Rep. Josh Gottheimer (D-N.J.) discusses immigration policy with a constituent in video captured TK. (Image: screenshot)
Activist Confronts Democrat Josh Gottheimer on Video for Funding Trump's War on Immigrants
'Never again' demands courage in the face of bigotry. This is cowardice."
A New Jersey man confronted a Democratic congressman Thursday on video over support for President Donald Trump's war on immigrants--and caught the conversation on video.
'Never again' demands courage in the face of bigotry. This is cowardice."
--Samuel Finkelstein
Samuel Finkelstein, a progressive activist who is a student at Seton Hall University, told Common Dreams that he drove nearly 60 miles on Thursday from his home in New Jersey's 11th Congressional district to the 5th Congressional district to confront Rep. Josh Gottheimer (D-N.J.) at the congressman's appearance at the Blairstown Diner in Blairstown, New Jersey.
Finkelstein asked Gottheimer about Gottheimer's votes in favor of the president's border policies.
Here's a video of me confronting @RepJoshG about his support for Trump's concentration camps. Invoking the Holocaust to defend present day barbarism is a disgrace to the memory of those killed by the Nazis. 'Never again' demands courage in the face of bigotry - this is cowardice. pic.twitter.com/psDX4VDowv
-- Samuel Douglas (@CANCEL_SAM) August 8, 2019
"I want to hold Gottheimer accountable for screwing the House Progressives on the emergency border funding bill," Finkelstein told Common Dreams. "N.J. voters want representatives who will stand up for undocumented Americans. There are thousands of undocumented people in N.J.-5, and Josh Gottheimer is failing to represent them."
In particular, Finkelstein wanted answers on why Gottheimer voted in favor of a June border funding omnibus bill that funneled nearly $5 billion into the Trump administration's anti-immigrant policies, including what Finkelstein described as "concentration camps" that are holding detained migrants indefinitely in horrific conditions. Gottheimer also pushed to include anti-immigrant language into a gun control bill that passed the House earlier this year.
"Why did you vote to fund Trump's concentration camps with no strings attached as far as, 'this has to go to humanitarian aid?'" Finkelstein asked Gottheimer. "We know that after that funding bill was passed, ICE said that they were building more camps."
"Obviously I have a very different perspective on that legislation," said Gottheimer, who told Finkelstein after confirming Finklestein was recording the encounter that Gottheimer would return with a binder to discuss the border funding bill and his reasons for voting for it.
"None of these guys are capable of defending anything they do without asking some aide to bring them a binder," said The New Republic's Alex Pareene.
Gottheimer never returned to discuss the bill, said Finkelstein. Before leaving, however, the congressman added that he felt Finkelstein calling the border detention centers "concentration camps" was inappropriate because of the Holocaust, where both men lost family.
Finklestein said in a tweet describing the encounter that he found this excuse to be "a disgrace to the memory of those killed by the Nazis."
"'Never again' demands courage in the face of bigotry," said Finkelstein. "This is cowardice."
As Common Dreams reported on July 30, Gottheimer is facing a primary challenger, Arati Kreibich. In a Wednesday tweet reacting to Trump's latest assault on immigrants, this time in Mississippi where the administration targeted 680 migrants for detention, wrenching them away from their families, Kreibich took a different tone to the crisis from her opponent.
"These raids don't make us any safer," Kreibich tweeted. "They terrorize communities and tear families apart. It's time for Congress to pass immigration reform with a path to citizenship so that families that have built lives here can stay."
Kreibich earned the support of one former Gottheimer intern, Brian O'Connor, who said in a tweet reacting to Finkelstein's video that he was "appalled" at Gottheimer's response.
"I interned for Josh in 2017 and I couldn't be more disappointed," said O'Connor. "I am donating to Arati Kreibich and you should too."
ReWire News editor-in-chief Jodi Jacobson tweeted that Gottheimer was "a disgrace."
"You are supporting concentration camps and your denial of this fact makes you as complicit as any person who ignored what was happening during the Holocaust," said Jacobson.
We are at a crossroads
This country and this world are at a monumental crossroads. US voters have an opportunity to beat back the forces of fascism and confront the billionaires who are rigging the economy, our media system, and our democracy, making it increasingly impossible for ordinary people to get by. We’re not just talking about the election. We’re talking about what must be done once these fascist elements are vanquished from power. We need a bolder set of solutions than what either major party has so far been willing to offer and a working-class movement ready to fight like hell for it. Trump didn't emerge from nowhere. The conditions that fueled MAGA authoritarianism were created by decades of radical neoliberal economic policies and a corrupt political system dominated by corporate interests. They slashed taxes on the super-rich, promising that the benefits would trickle down. They said giveaways to the corporate titans would make life more affordable for the rest of us. It was all bullshit. And when a bitter, betrayed populace searches for someone to blame, right-wing demagogues have little trouble finding scapegoats. People know when they're being lied to, but you won't hear any of this from the corporate media. Only independent journalism—powered and funded by people who believe in building a better world—can deliver truly trustworthy daily news. Our Fall Campaign is underway, and we need your help. To power our newsroom through the rest of the year, we need to raise $125,000 by midnight on October 31. So if you share our vision, please contribute whatever you can to sustain our work. |
A New Jersey man confronted a Democratic congressman Thursday on video over support for President Donald Trump's war on immigrants--and caught the conversation on video.
'Never again' demands courage in the face of bigotry. This is cowardice."
--Samuel Finkelstein
Samuel Finkelstein, a progressive activist who is a student at Seton Hall University, told Common Dreams that he drove nearly 60 miles on Thursday from his home in New Jersey's 11th Congressional district to the 5th Congressional district to confront Rep. Josh Gottheimer (D-N.J.) at the congressman's appearance at the Blairstown Diner in Blairstown, New Jersey.
Finkelstein asked Gottheimer about Gottheimer's votes in favor of the president's border policies.
Here's a video of me confronting @RepJoshG about his support for Trump's concentration camps. Invoking the Holocaust to defend present day barbarism is a disgrace to the memory of those killed by the Nazis. 'Never again' demands courage in the face of bigotry - this is cowardice. pic.twitter.com/psDX4VDowv
-- Samuel Douglas (@CANCEL_SAM) August 8, 2019
"I want to hold Gottheimer accountable for screwing the House Progressives on the emergency border funding bill," Finkelstein told Common Dreams. "N.J. voters want representatives who will stand up for undocumented Americans. There are thousands of undocumented people in N.J.-5, and Josh Gottheimer is failing to represent them."
In particular, Finkelstein wanted answers on why Gottheimer voted in favor of a June border funding omnibus bill that funneled nearly $5 billion into the Trump administration's anti-immigrant policies, including what Finkelstein described as "concentration camps" that are holding detained migrants indefinitely in horrific conditions. Gottheimer also pushed to include anti-immigrant language into a gun control bill that passed the House earlier this year.
"Why did you vote to fund Trump's concentration camps with no strings attached as far as, 'this has to go to humanitarian aid?'" Finkelstein asked Gottheimer. "We know that after that funding bill was passed, ICE said that they were building more camps."
"Obviously I have a very different perspective on that legislation," said Gottheimer, who told Finkelstein after confirming Finklestein was recording the encounter that Gottheimer would return with a binder to discuss the border funding bill and his reasons for voting for it.
"None of these guys are capable of defending anything they do without asking some aide to bring them a binder," said The New Republic's Alex Pareene.
Gottheimer never returned to discuss the bill, said Finkelstein. Before leaving, however, the congressman added that he felt Finkelstein calling the border detention centers "concentration camps" was inappropriate because of the Holocaust, where both men lost family.
Finklestein said in a tweet describing the encounter that he found this excuse to be "a disgrace to the memory of those killed by the Nazis."
"'Never again' demands courage in the face of bigotry," said Finkelstein. "This is cowardice."
As Common Dreams reported on July 30, Gottheimer is facing a primary challenger, Arati Kreibich. In a Wednesday tweet reacting to Trump's latest assault on immigrants, this time in Mississippi where the administration targeted 680 migrants for detention, wrenching them away from their families, Kreibich took a different tone to the crisis from her opponent.
"These raids don't make us any safer," Kreibich tweeted. "They terrorize communities and tear families apart. It's time for Congress to pass immigration reform with a path to citizenship so that families that have built lives here can stay."
Kreibich earned the support of one former Gottheimer intern, Brian O'Connor, who said in a tweet reacting to Finkelstein's video that he was "appalled" at Gottheimer's response.
"I interned for Josh in 2017 and I couldn't be more disappointed," said O'Connor. "I am donating to Arati Kreibich and you should too."
ReWire News editor-in-chief Jodi Jacobson tweeted that Gottheimer was "a disgrace."
"You are supporting concentration camps and your denial of this fact makes you as complicit as any person who ignored what was happening during the Holocaust," said Jacobson.
A New Jersey man confronted a Democratic congressman Thursday on video over support for President Donald Trump's war on immigrants--and caught the conversation on video.
'Never again' demands courage in the face of bigotry. This is cowardice."
--Samuel Finkelstein
Samuel Finkelstein, a progressive activist who is a student at Seton Hall University, told Common Dreams that he drove nearly 60 miles on Thursday from his home in New Jersey's 11th Congressional district to the 5th Congressional district to confront Rep. Josh Gottheimer (D-N.J.) at the congressman's appearance at the Blairstown Diner in Blairstown, New Jersey.
Finkelstein asked Gottheimer about Gottheimer's votes in favor of the president's border policies.
Here's a video of me confronting @RepJoshG about his support for Trump's concentration camps. Invoking the Holocaust to defend present day barbarism is a disgrace to the memory of those killed by the Nazis. 'Never again' demands courage in the face of bigotry - this is cowardice. pic.twitter.com/psDX4VDowv
-- Samuel Douglas (@CANCEL_SAM) August 8, 2019
"I want to hold Gottheimer accountable for screwing the House Progressives on the emergency border funding bill," Finkelstein told Common Dreams. "N.J. voters want representatives who will stand up for undocumented Americans. There are thousands of undocumented people in N.J.-5, and Josh Gottheimer is failing to represent them."
In particular, Finkelstein wanted answers on why Gottheimer voted in favor of a June border funding omnibus bill that funneled nearly $5 billion into the Trump administration's anti-immigrant policies, including what Finkelstein described as "concentration camps" that are holding detained migrants indefinitely in horrific conditions. Gottheimer also pushed to include anti-immigrant language into a gun control bill that passed the House earlier this year.
"Why did you vote to fund Trump's concentration camps with no strings attached as far as, 'this has to go to humanitarian aid?'" Finkelstein asked Gottheimer. "We know that after that funding bill was passed, ICE said that they were building more camps."
"Obviously I have a very different perspective on that legislation," said Gottheimer, who told Finkelstein after confirming Finklestein was recording the encounter that Gottheimer would return with a binder to discuss the border funding bill and his reasons for voting for it.
"None of these guys are capable of defending anything they do without asking some aide to bring them a binder," said The New Republic's Alex Pareene.
Gottheimer never returned to discuss the bill, said Finkelstein. Before leaving, however, the congressman added that he felt Finkelstein calling the border detention centers "concentration camps" was inappropriate because of the Holocaust, where both men lost family.
Finklestein said in a tweet describing the encounter that he found this excuse to be "a disgrace to the memory of those killed by the Nazis."
"'Never again' demands courage in the face of bigotry," said Finkelstein. "This is cowardice."
As Common Dreams reported on July 30, Gottheimer is facing a primary challenger, Arati Kreibich. In a Wednesday tweet reacting to Trump's latest assault on immigrants, this time in Mississippi where the administration targeted 680 migrants for detention, wrenching them away from their families, Kreibich took a different tone to the crisis from her opponent.
"These raids don't make us any safer," Kreibich tweeted. "They terrorize communities and tear families apart. It's time for Congress to pass immigration reform with a path to citizenship so that families that have built lives here can stay."
Kreibich earned the support of one former Gottheimer intern, Brian O'Connor, who said in a tweet reacting to Finkelstein's video that he was "appalled" at Gottheimer's response.
"I interned for Josh in 2017 and I couldn't be more disappointed," said O'Connor. "I am donating to Arati Kreibich and you should too."
ReWire News editor-in-chief Jodi Jacobson tweeted that Gottheimer was "a disgrace."
"You are supporting concentration camps and your denial of this fact makes you as complicit as any person who ignored what was happening during the Holocaust," said Jacobson.