Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

Yemeni national Moath Hamza Ahmed al-Alwi, who petitioned the Supreme Court for his release, has been detained at Guantanamo Bay prison in Cuba for more than 17 years. (Photo: Joint Task Force Guantánamo Bay/Flickr/cc)

Legal Expert Says 'Congress Must Repeal the AUMF' After Supreme Court Rejects Yemeni Man's Appeal for Release From Gitmo

"The Supreme Court can no longer be trusted to enforce due process. If Congress doesn't put a stop to this unconstitutional cruelty, no one will."

Jake Johnson

The Supreme Court's decision Monday to not hear a Yemeni Guantanamo prisoner's appeal for release prompted Justice Stephen Breyer to call for a serious examination of the constitutional questions raised by detention of so-called "enemy combatants" in an age of endless war, and led one legal expert to argue it is time for Congress to tackle the problem at its root.

In a detailed examination of the Supreme Court's refusal to hear the petition of Moath Hamza Ahmed al-Alwi, lawyer and Slate legal journalist Mark Joseph Stern welcomed Breyer's belated concerns about perpetual detention but said nothing will change until Congress rolls back the 2001 Authorization for Use of Military Force (AUMF).

"I respect Breyer's Guantanamo opinion today, but perhaps he should've considered this problem before he cast the fifth vote in Hamdi permitting the government to detain 'enemy combatants' for the 'duration of the relevant conflict' without trial."
—Mark Joseph Stern, Slate

With the help of the Supreme Court, Stern wrote, the Bush administration interpreted and used the AUMF as a broad license to detain any individual deemed an enemy of the U.S. in the so-called "war on terror."

"Congress must repeal the AUMF, as well as any statute—particularly immigration laws—that can arguably be read to allow endless imprisonment," Stern argued. "The Supreme Court can no longer be trusted to enforce due process, despite Breyer's pleas. If Congress doesn't put a stop to this unconstitutional cruelty, no one will."

As Stern pointed out, the Supreme Court—including Breyer—"endorsed a key part of the Bush administration's AUMF theory" in its 2004 Hamdi v. Rumsfeld decision.

"Yaser Esam Hamdi was a U.S. citizen captured in Afghanistan, taken to Guantanamo, then transferred to a naval brig in the United States," Stern wrote. "Accused of joining the Taliban, Hamdi was deemed an enemy combatant, and the government asserted a right to hold him indefinitely without even bringing formal charges, let alone giving him a trial."

Hamdi challenged his detention, but the Supreme Court ultimately "agreed that the 2001 AUMF allowed the president to detain those he determines to be an enemy combatant," Stern wrote.

"The plurality," Stern added, "also agreed that these individuals are not owed full due process, even if they're U.S. citizens."

In his statement on Monday, Breyer pointed to the consequences of the Hamdi decision and said it is "past time to confront" the question of whether the Constitution permits the kind of perpetual detention that has kept Moath Hamza Ahmed al-Alwi and others behind bars for years without trial.

"Al-Alwi faces the real prospect that he will spend the rest of his life in detention based on his status as an enemy combatant a generation ago."
—Justice Stephen Breyer

"Some 17 years have elapsed since petitioner Moath Hamza Ahmed al-Alwi, a Yemeni national, was first held at the United States Naval Base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba," Breyer wrote.

The U.S. government, Breyer added, claims the "hostilities" that provided a legal rationale for al-Alwi's detention "are ongoing, but does not state that any end is in sight."

"As a consequence," Breyer wrote, "al-Alwi faces the real prospect that he will spend the rest of his life in detention based on his status as an enemy combatant a generation ago, even though today's conflict may differ substantially from the one Congress anticipated when it passed the AUMF."

Despite his expressed concerns and desire to reexamine the Hamdi decision, Breyer voted with his fellow justices to not hear al-Alwi's appeal for release, saying he will wait for "an appropriate case."

"Why isn't al-Alwi's case appropriate? Breyer didn't say," wrote Stern.

Following the Supreme Court's decision on Monday, lawyers for al-Alwi said the U.S. government has no justification for keeping him in detention.

"This has nothing to do with security. Moath is a victim of geopolitical and domestic politics," Ramzi Kassem, a law professor at the City University of New York and part of al-Alwi's legal team, told The Independent. "Both the U.S. government and the courts accept that he has never raised a hand against America.

"If his passport didn't say Yemen on its cover, if he were from a different, more important country, he would probably be home today," Kassem said. "This administration and the two previous ones have kept [Guantanamo] open for political reasons unrelated to sound policy. Today, keeping the prison open pleases Trump's base. So, from that point of view, Guantanamo pays."

Over the past several years, Rep. Barbara Lee (D-Calif.)—the only member of the House to vote against the 2001 AUMF—has led numerous unsuccessful efforts to repeal the "blank check for endless war."

Last month, Lee put forth an amendment to the 2020 Defense Appropriations Act that would sunset the AUMF over a period of eight months. The amendment passed the House Appropriations Committee by a party line vote of 30-22.

"As the Trump administration escalates tensions with Iran, it is more important than ever for Congress to reassert its constitutional authority," Lee said in a statement. "We must start by repealing the overly broad 2001 AUMF and do our job to debate and vote on any replacement."

Other members of Congress have expressed support for the effort to repeal the AUMF, including Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.).

"I think that our decision to enter unlimited engagement in Afghanistan, particularly through the AUMF + Congress' abdication of power + decision-making w[ith] passage of the AUMF, was a mistake," Ocasio-Cortez tweeted in March.

Stern expressed agreement with Ocasio-Cortez's view, writing in a tweet Tuesday, "AOC is right, repeal the AUMF."

Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.

We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.

Fears of Hate-Inspired Serial Killer Grow as 4th Muslim Man Murdered in Albuquerque

"We're scared for our families, we're scared for our children," said one local Muslim leader. "And we are incredibly confused about why this is happening."

Jake Johnson ·

UN Chief Denounces Shelling of Ukraine Nuclear Plant as 'Suicidal'

To avert a public health calamity, Ukrainian officials are calling for the Zaporizhzhia site to be demilitarized and run by a team of peacekeepers.

Kenny Stancil ·

Big Pharma Bemoans 'Tragic Loss' as Democrats Take Modest Action to Curb Drug Prices

Patient advocates, meanwhile, applauded passage of the Inflation Reduction Act as a "historic victory for consumers and a historic defeat for Big Pharma's monopoly control."

Jake Johnson ·

Sanders Says Senate Bill 'Nowhere Near' Enough as Dems, GOP Tank His Amendments

The Vermont senator nevertheless supported final passage of the Inflation Reduction Act, calling it "a step forward" on climate and drug prices.

Jake Johnson ·

Senate Barely Approves Scaled Back Legislation on Climate, Taxes, Healthcare

But thanks to Senator Kyrsten Sinema (D-AZ), there was a huge, last-minute win for the private equity and hedge fund industries

Common Dreams staff ·

Common Dreams Logo