SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE NEWSLETTER
Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
"Mick Mulvaney of the Office of Management and Budget is individually responsible for choosing and implementing those cuts," Barkan told Flake. "He thinks people on disability are just slackers, so what happens? What should I tell my son or what should you tell my son if you pass this bill and he cuts funding for disability and I can't get a ventilator?" (Photo: Twitter/Screengrab)
'You Can Save My Life': Traveling on Same Plane, Man With ALS Confronts Sen. Flake Over GOP Tax Bill
"What should I tell my son or what should you tell my son if you pass this bill?"
Dec 07, 2017
Sen. Jeff Flake (R-Ariz.) boarded a plane leaving Washington, D.C. on Thursday, less than a week after voting for a tax bill that could result in devastating cuts to disability programs.
Ady Barkan, a 33-year-old father living with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), boarded the same flight after spending several days protesting the very legislation Flake helped ram through the Senate.
Barkan, who could be one of the millions of Americans severely harmed by the bill, wanted an explanation.
Approaching Flake on the Thursday night flight to Arizona, Barkan demanded to know how the senator who in October condemned President Donald Trump for his "flagrant disregard of truth and decency" could proceed, just weeks later, to vote for a bill that may trigger life-threatening cuts to programs that children, the elderly, and the disabled depend upon for survival.
"Mick Mulvaney of the Office of Management and Budget is individually responsible for choosing and implementing those cuts," Barkan told Flake. "He thinks people on disability are just slackers, so what happens? What should I tell my son or what should you tell my son if you pass this bill and he cuts funding for disability and I can't get a ventilator?"
ALS, Barkan explained to Flake, "has a life expectancy of three to four years, no treatment, no cure." As the condition progresses, Barkan's medical bills will soar, and he will continue to need additional assistance to stay alive. The GOP tax plan could deprive him of these necessities.
After Flake commended him for being "very up on everything," Barkan responded: "My life depends on it. For the rest of your life, you will be proud if you vote this bill down. You will be proud on your deathbed, I promise you."
"You can save my life. Please," Barkan concluded. "Please remember this conversation."
Much of Barkan's conversation with Flake was captured on video and posted on social media. Here is the 8-clip series of the interaction, in order:
\u201cPart 1 of the #flakesonaplane saga @AdyBarkan tells his story to @JeffFlake, the swing vote on the #GOPTaxScam.\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512706754
\u201cPart 2 #flakesonaplane @JeffFlake tells a skeptical @AdyBarkan that he trusts @RepPaulRyan and @SenateMajLdr to not betray the American people #GOPTaxScam\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512707470
\u201cPart 3 @AdyBarkan and @JeffFlake go head to head on the #GOPTaxScam and discuss the defecit and economic growth #flakesonaplane\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512708605
\u201cPart 4 of #flakesonaplane @JeffFlake tells @AdyBarkan how he thinks we settle the debt #GOPTaxScam\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512708215
\u201cPart 5 @JeffFlake talks #DACA and @AdyBarkan asks how he dealt with the white house and @realDonaldTrump... #flakesonaplane @_dreamersunited #GOPTaxScam\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512709041
\u201cPart 6 @JeffFlake said he will fight for these kids for the @_dreamersunited #DACA @AdyBarkan holds him to it #GOPTaxScam #FlakesOnAPlane\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512709155
\u201cPart 7 we talk #CHIP and @JeffFlake tells @AdyBarkan he doesn't think it will be part of #GOPTaxScam #FlakesOnAPlane\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512708923
\u201cGrand finale @AdyBarkan tells @JeffFlake this is his chance to be the American hero and #killthebill the #GOPTaxScam and help him live and save millions of Americans. #flakesonaplane\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512709457
Why Your Ongoing Support Is Essential
Donald Trump’s attacks on democracy, justice, and a free press are escalating — putting everything we stand for at risk. We believe a better world is possible, but we can’t get there without your support. Common Dreams stands apart. We answer only to you — our readers, activists, and changemakers — not to billionaires or corporations. Our independence allows us to cover the vital stories that others won’t, spotlighting movements for peace, equality, and human rights. Right now, our work faces unprecedented challenges. Misinformation is spreading, journalists are under attack, and financial pressures are mounting. As a reader-supported, nonprofit newsroom, your support is crucial to keep this journalism alive. Whatever you can give — $10, $25, or $100 — helps us stay strong and responsive when the world needs us most. Together, we’ll continue to build the independent, courageous journalism our movement relies on. Thank you for being part of this community. |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
Sen. Jeff Flake (R-Ariz.) boarded a plane leaving Washington, D.C. on Thursday, less than a week after voting for a tax bill that could result in devastating cuts to disability programs.
Ady Barkan, a 33-year-old father living with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), boarded the same flight after spending several days protesting the very legislation Flake helped ram through the Senate.
Barkan, who could be one of the millions of Americans severely harmed by the bill, wanted an explanation.
Approaching Flake on the Thursday night flight to Arizona, Barkan demanded to know how the senator who in October condemned President Donald Trump for his "flagrant disregard of truth and decency" could proceed, just weeks later, to vote for a bill that may trigger life-threatening cuts to programs that children, the elderly, and the disabled depend upon for survival.
"Mick Mulvaney of the Office of Management and Budget is individually responsible for choosing and implementing those cuts," Barkan told Flake. "He thinks people on disability are just slackers, so what happens? What should I tell my son or what should you tell my son if you pass this bill and he cuts funding for disability and I can't get a ventilator?"
ALS, Barkan explained to Flake, "has a life expectancy of three to four years, no treatment, no cure." As the condition progresses, Barkan's medical bills will soar, and he will continue to need additional assistance to stay alive. The GOP tax plan could deprive him of these necessities.
After Flake commended him for being "very up on everything," Barkan responded: "My life depends on it. For the rest of your life, you will be proud if you vote this bill down. You will be proud on your deathbed, I promise you."
"You can save my life. Please," Barkan concluded. "Please remember this conversation."
Much of Barkan's conversation with Flake was captured on video and posted on social media. Here is the 8-clip series of the interaction, in order:
\u201cPart 1 of the #flakesonaplane saga @AdyBarkan tells his story to @JeffFlake, the swing vote on the #GOPTaxScam.\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512706754
\u201cPart 2 #flakesonaplane @JeffFlake tells a skeptical @AdyBarkan that he trusts @RepPaulRyan and @SenateMajLdr to not betray the American people #GOPTaxScam\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512707470
\u201cPart 3 @AdyBarkan and @JeffFlake go head to head on the #GOPTaxScam and discuss the defecit and economic growth #flakesonaplane\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512708605
\u201cPart 4 of #flakesonaplane @JeffFlake tells @AdyBarkan how he thinks we settle the debt #GOPTaxScam\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512708215
\u201cPart 5 @JeffFlake talks #DACA and @AdyBarkan asks how he dealt with the white house and @realDonaldTrump... #flakesonaplane @_dreamersunited #GOPTaxScam\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512709041
\u201cPart 6 @JeffFlake said he will fight for these kids for the @_dreamersunited #DACA @AdyBarkan holds him to it #GOPTaxScam #FlakesOnAPlane\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512709155
\u201cPart 7 we talk #CHIP and @JeffFlake tells @AdyBarkan he doesn't think it will be part of #GOPTaxScam #FlakesOnAPlane\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512708923
\u201cGrand finale @AdyBarkan tells @JeffFlake this is his chance to be the American hero and #killthebill the #GOPTaxScam and help him live and save millions of Americans. #flakesonaplane\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512709457
Sen. Jeff Flake (R-Ariz.) boarded a plane leaving Washington, D.C. on Thursday, less than a week after voting for a tax bill that could result in devastating cuts to disability programs.
Ady Barkan, a 33-year-old father living with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), boarded the same flight after spending several days protesting the very legislation Flake helped ram through the Senate.
Barkan, who could be one of the millions of Americans severely harmed by the bill, wanted an explanation.
Approaching Flake on the Thursday night flight to Arizona, Barkan demanded to know how the senator who in October condemned President Donald Trump for his "flagrant disregard of truth and decency" could proceed, just weeks later, to vote for a bill that may trigger life-threatening cuts to programs that children, the elderly, and the disabled depend upon for survival.
"Mick Mulvaney of the Office of Management and Budget is individually responsible for choosing and implementing those cuts," Barkan told Flake. "He thinks people on disability are just slackers, so what happens? What should I tell my son or what should you tell my son if you pass this bill and he cuts funding for disability and I can't get a ventilator?"
ALS, Barkan explained to Flake, "has a life expectancy of three to four years, no treatment, no cure." As the condition progresses, Barkan's medical bills will soar, and he will continue to need additional assistance to stay alive. The GOP tax plan could deprive him of these necessities.
After Flake commended him for being "very up on everything," Barkan responded: "My life depends on it. For the rest of your life, you will be proud if you vote this bill down. You will be proud on your deathbed, I promise you."
"You can save my life. Please," Barkan concluded. "Please remember this conversation."
Much of Barkan's conversation with Flake was captured on video and posted on social media. Here is the 8-clip series of the interaction, in order:
\u201cPart 1 of the #flakesonaplane saga @AdyBarkan tells his story to @JeffFlake, the swing vote on the #GOPTaxScam.\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512706754
\u201cPart 2 #flakesonaplane @JeffFlake tells a skeptical @AdyBarkan that he trusts @RepPaulRyan and @SenateMajLdr to not betray the American people #GOPTaxScam\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512707470
\u201cPart 3 @AdyBarkan and @JeffFlake go head to head on the #GOPTaxScam and discuss the defecit and economic growth #flakesonaplane\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512708605
\u201cPart 4 of #flakesonaplane @JeffFlake tells @AdyBarkan how he thinks we settle the debt #GOPTaxScam\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512708215
\u201cPart 5 @JeffFlake talks #DACA and @AdyBarkan asks how he dealt with the white house and @realDonaldTrump... #flakesonaplane @_dreamersunited #GOPTaxScam\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512709041
\u201cPart 6 @JeffFlake said he will fight for these kids for the @_dreamersunited #DACA @AdyBarkan holds him to it #GOPTaxScam #FlakesOnAPlane\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512709155
\u201cPart 7 we talk #CHIP and @JeffFlake tells @AdyBarkan he doesn't think it will be part of #GOPTaxScam #FlakesOnAPlane\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512708923
\u201cGrand finale @AdyBarkan tells @JeffFlake this is his chance to be the American hero and #killthebill the #GOPTaxScam and help him live and save millions of Americans. #flakesonaplane\u201d— Liz J. (@Liz J.) 1512709457
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.