Last year, an artist projected "Pay Trump bribes here" and "Emoluments Welcome" onto the Trump Hotel in Washington, D.C. to protest President Donald Trump's refusal to divest from his businesses. (Photo: @igorvolsky/Twitter)
Jul 25, 2018
A government watchdog claimed its latest victory on Wednesday as a federal judge rejected President Donald Trump's bid to block a lawsuit challenging his continued involvement with his businesses--which ethics groups say amounts to a blatant violation of the U.S. Constitution.
\u201c#BREAKING: Judge allows our #emoluments case to proceed. \n\nWe are one step closer to stopping President Trump from violating the Constitution\u2019s original anti-corruption provisions. \n\nStay tuned\u2014more to come. \n\nThanks to AG @BrianFrosh and co-counsel @CREWcrew.\u201d— AG Karl A. Racine (@AG Karl A. Racine) 1532535153
U.S. District Judge Peter Missette did not accept the Trump administration's argument that a violation of the Constitution's emoluments clause--which states that a president cannot accept gifts or benefits from state officials or foreign governments--must involve a bribe that is explicitly offered to the president.
With Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW) acting as co-counsel, the state of Maryland and the District of Columbia have argued in their lawsuit that the frequent use of the Trump International Hotel in Washington, D.C. by state governors and foreign officials constitutes illegal payments to the president.
"The court determines that plaintiffs have convincingly argued that the term 'emolument' in both the foreign and domestic Emoluments Clauses, with slight refinements that the court will address, means any 'profit,' 'gain,' or 'advantage' and that accordingly they have stated claims to the effect that the president, in certain instances, has violated both theforeign and domestic Clauses," Missette wrote in his ruling.
The Trump International Hotel has rented space "to the embassies of Kuwait and the Philippines and hosted visiting leaders from Malaysia and Romania," since Trump took office, and has reported $150,000 in "foreign profits" in the last year, according to the Washington Post.
Trump has not fully divested from the Trump Organization, which owns the hotel and his other properties. Instead, he handed over control of the business to his two eldest sons, Eric and Donald, Jr., but receives updates on the organization's finances and is able to withdraw funds from it at any time.
Noah Bookbinder, executive director of CREW, lauded Missette's decision as marking "a historic day for the Constitution."
"Americans need to know that their president is acting in their interest and not in the interest of his private businesses," Bookbinder said in a statement. "President Trump has refused again and again to separate himself from his business empire to avoid pervasive conflicts of interest and constitutional violations. A court has now decided that the Emoluments Clauses, put in place by the framers of the Constitution to protect against corruption, are broad and can be enforced in court."
CREW Chair Norm Eisen was among the Trump critics who weighed in on social media.
\u201cA federal judge just rejected Trump\u2019s latest effort to stop a lawsuit that alleges Trump is violating the Constitution by continuing to do business with foreign governments. Kudos to @CREWcrew and @NormEisen on this extraordinary legal victory. https://t.co/4BA2MRFf1V\u201d— Public Citizen (@Public Citizen) 1532546177
Missette directed the two parties to determine a timeline for the case's discovery phase, in which the attorneys general of Maryland and Washington, D.C. would be able to gather evidence of wrongdoing within Trump's financial records. However, the Justice Department could seek an emergency stay and appeal the decision.
Join Us: News for people demanding a better world
Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place. We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference. Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. Join with us today! |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
A government watchdog claimed its latest victory on Wednesday as a federal judge rejected President Donald Trump's bid to block a lawsuit challenging his continued involvement with his businesses--which ethics groups say amounts to a blatant violation of the U.S. Constitution.
\u201c#BREAKING: Judge allows our #emoluments case to proceed. \n\nWe are one step closer to stopping President Trump from violating the Constitution\u2019s original anti-corruption provisions. \n\nStay tuned\u2014more to come. \n\nThanks to AG @BrianFrosh and co-counsel @CREWcrew.\u201d— AG Karl A. Racine (@AG Karl A. Racine) 1532535153
U.S. District Judge Peter Missette did not accept the Trump administration's argument that a violation of the Constitution's emoluments clause--which states that a president cannot accept gifts or benefits from state officials or foreign governments--must involve a bribe that is explicitly offered to the president.
With Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW) acting as co-counsel, the state of Maryland and the District of Columbia have argued in their lawsuit that the frequent use of the Trump International Hotel in Washington, D.C. by state governors and foreign officials constitutes illegal payments to the president.
"The court determines that plaintiffs have convincingly argued that the term 'emolument' in both the foreign and domestic Emoluments Clauses, with slight refinements that the court will address, means any 'profit,' 'gain,' or 'advantage' and that accordingly they have stated claims to the effect that the president, in certain instances, has violated both theforeign and domestic Clauses," Missette wrote in his ruling.
The Trump International Hotel has rented space "to the embassies of Kuwait and the Philippines and hosted visiting leaders from Malaysia and Romania," since Trump took office, and has reported $150,000 in "foreign profits" in the last year, according to the Washington Post.
Trump has not fully divested from the Trump Organization, which owns the hotel and his other properties. Instead, he handed over control of the business to his two eldest sons, Eric and Donald, Jr., but receives updates on the organization's finances and is able to withdraw funds from it at any time.
Noah Bookbinder, executive director of CREW, lauded Missette's decision as marking "a historic day for the Constitution."
"Americans need to know that their president is acting in their interest and not in the interest of his private businesses," Bookbinder said in a statement. "President Trump has refused again and again to separate himself from his business empire to avoid pervasive conflicts of interest and constitutional violations. A court has now decided that the Emoluments Clauses, put in place by the framers of the Constitution to protect against corruption, are broad and can be enforced in court."
CREW Chair Norm Eisen was among the Trump critics who weighed in on social media.
\u201cA federal judge just rejected Trump\u2019s latest effort to stop a lawsuit that alleges Trump is violating the Constitution by continuing to do business with foreign governments. Kudos to @CREWcrew and @NormEisen on this extraordinary legal victory. https://t.co/4BA2MRFf1V\u201d— Public Citizen (@Public Citizen) 1532546177
Missette directed the two parties to determine a timeline for the case's discovery phase, in which the attorneys general of Maryland and Washington, D.C. would be able to gather evidence of wrongdoing within Trump's financial records. However, the Justice Department could seek an emergency stay and appeal the decision.
A government watchdog claimed its latest victory on Wednesday as a federal judge rejected President Donald Trump's bid to block a lawsuit challenging his continued involvement with his businesses--which ethics groups say amounts to a blatant violation of the U.S. Constitution.
\u201c#BREAKING: Judge allows our #emoluments case to proceed. \n\nWe are one step closer to stopping President Trump from violating the Constitution\u2019s original anti-corruption provisions. \n\nStay tuned\u2014more to come. \n\nThanks to AG @BrianFrosh and co-counsel @CREWcrew.\u201d— AG Karl A. Racine (@AG Karl A. Racine) 1532535153
U.S. District Judge Peter Missette did not accept the Trump administration's argument that a violation of the Constitution's emoluments clause--which states that a president cannot accept gifts or benefits from state officials or foreign governments--must involve a bribe that is explicitly offered to the president.
With Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW) acting as co-counsel, the state of Maryland and the District of Columbia have argued in their lawsuit that the frequent use of the Trump International Hotel in Washington, D.C. by state governors and foreign officials constitutes illegal payments to the president.
"The court determines that plaintiffs have convincingly argued that the term 'emolument' in both the foreign and domestic Emoluments Clauses, with slight refinements that the court will address, means any 'profit,' 'gain,' or 'advantage' and that accordingly they have stated claims to the effect that the president, in certain instances, has violated both theforeign and domestic Clauses," Missette wrote in his ruling.
The Trump International Hotel has rented space "to the embassies of Kuwait and the Philippines and hosted visiting leaders from Malaysia and Romania," since Trump took office, and has reported $150,000 in "foreign profits" in the last year, according to the Washington Post.
Trump has not fully divested from the Trump Organization, which owns the hotel and his other properties. Instead, he handed over control of the business to his two eldest sons, Eric and Donald, Jr., but receives updates on the organization's finances and is able to withdraw funds from it at any time.
Noah Bookbinder, executive director of CREW, lauded Missette's decision as marking "a historic day for the Constitution."
"Americans need to know that their president is acting in their interest and not in the interest of his private businesses," Bookbinder said in a statement. "President Trump has refused again and again to separate himself from his business empire to avoid pervasive conflicts of interest and constitutional violations. A court has now decided that the Emoluments Clauses, put in place by the framers of the Constitution to protect against corruption, are broad and can be enforced in court."
CREW Chair Norm Eisen was among the Trump critics who weighed in on social media.
\u201cA federal judge just rejected Trump\u2019s latest effort to stop a lawsuit that alleges Trump is violating the Constitution by continuing to do business with foreign governments. Kudos to @CREWcrew and @NormEisen on this extraordinary legal victory. https://t.co/4BA2MRFf1V\u201d— Public Citizen (@Public Citizen) 1532546177
Missette directed the two parties to determine a timeline for the case's discovery phase, in which the attorneys general of Maryland and Washington, D.C. would be able to gather evidence of wrongdoing within Trump's financial records. However, the Justice Department could seek an emergency stay and appeal the decision.
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.