Memo to American Left: 'We Have Let Obama Down'
When Obama came into office with a mandate for change, the left sat back and waited. Instead, we should have mobilised
Both Barack Obama and I are Chicago boys,
schooled in the tough-minded, arm-twisting don't-mess-with-me attitude
of crushing rather than compromising with your unforgiving enemies. We
are both products of machine politics, I from the west side's "rotten
borough" 24th ward loyally turning out Democratic party majorities of
almost, and sometimes exceeding, 100% ("Vote early, vote often!"), and
Barack from a south side community-organising operation that got things
done door-to-door, block by block.
In the 2008 election campaign President Obama's most important strategist was the Chicago fixer David Axelrod,
a master of hard-knuckle progressive neighbourhood politics who had
masterminded the re-election campaign of Chicago's first African
American mayor Harold Washington. But after Obama's inauguration the new president appears to have muzzled Axelrod in favour of Rahm Emanuel,
a ferociously combative, rightwing Democratic political assassin. The
enforcer Emanuel has so far failed to enforce much of anything for
Obama by way of decent legislation, and Axelrod is sidelined except as
No wonder that at home on my desk is a manila folder file labelled OBAMA BETRAYALS
OF CAMPAIGN PLEDGES, so full it's bursting apart. I was about to start
a fresh new file of his latest missteps when suddenly I caught myself.
Hey, wait a minute, I'm falling into the same old tired habit of
reflexive negativity honed in the Bush years.
the historian-activist who before his recent death was probably the
wisest mind on the US left, told us he was not disappointed in Obama
because he never expected much in the absence of a national movement to
push him in a good direction. Zinn - a lifelong student of the American
abolitionist, labour, civil rights, feminist and gay rights movements -
preached that real change "will have to work its way from the bottom
up". Alas, we at the "bottom" have not really been there for Obama to
fight for his ear, which currently belongs to Wall Street.
Roosevelt, the president we hoped that Obama would be like, had a huge
advantage over our new president. At FDR's disposal were powerful mass
movements - Huey Long's "Share the Wealth", Father Coughlin's radical racist anti-capitalist broadcasts, the elderly Townsend Clubs,
the veterans' bonus marchers and militant labour unions with their
sit-down strikes - that were an effective threat, a countervailing
force to rich rightwingers eager to destroy the New Deal. FDR's good
angel, his wife Eleanor, constantly reported to him about just how bad
it was in the real world of the Great Depression. But Roosevelt told
Eleanor and anyone else who came to him with demands for progressive
change: "OK, you've convinced me. Now go out and put pressure on me."
where we've let Obama down. We on the American left - in a
dysfunctional marriage with a bought-and-paid-for Democratic party,
tamed by leechlike dependence on "non-profit" liberal foundations
themselves funded by corporations, a women's movement obsessed by the
abortion issue, a gay movement fixed on gay marriage - simply aren't up
to the job. We have not backed up Obama with a serious antiwar movement
(there isn't any), and our Big Labour is too weak to fight for itself,
let alone for the rest of us. Grassroots activism still exists, but
during the 2008 presidential campaign we slipped into the habit of
allowing ourselves to be used purely as fundraising vehicles.
Fundraising is no substitute for hell raising, as the Palin-loving Tea Baggers and Town Hallers are teaching us.
came into office with a mandate for change. That should have been our
signal not to sit back and wait for him to deliver but to mobilise to
make sure he followed through. Instead, we relaxed our "Chicago
muscle", the hard volunteer work that elected him. And I started my
self-satisfying, ultimately pointless OBAMA BETRAYAL file.
Last week in America's northwest, Oregon voters, who are traditionally anti-tax-increase, showed how Chicago muscle works.
Against fierce opposition led by Nike and other big businesses, they
delivered a huge progressive victory by approving tax-raising measures
on the wealthy and corporations. They did it the low-tech way, slogging
door to door, volunteers from an improvised coalition of unions,
community groups and small businesses, working together to overcome a
well-funded rightwing scare campaign.
Sooner or later we on the
American left will rise again and look beyond single-issue obsessions,
sever our dependence on corporate charity, and - as FDR and Howard Zinn
advised - relearn the lesson of how to apply pressure on a president
who needs us more than we need him.
Clancy Sigal, is a screenwriter and novelist in Los Angeles.
Chicago-born, he has worked precincts for Democratic candidates since
his teens. He emigrated to the UK during what David Caute calls the
'Great Fear' and returned to America after the 1984 miners' strike. He
is a reformed Fleet Street journalist