Frances Moore Lappe marching in Democracy Spring from Philadelphia to the Capital steps. April 2016. (Photo: Frances Moore Lappe)
Oct 11, 2018
Trust in democracy is tumbling. In 1995, one in fifteen Americans said they'd approve of military rule. By 2014, the share had swollen to one in six. Note this frightening crash of confidence preceded the compromised 2016 election and a president who seems particularly fond of autocrats.
Whoa. It sure seems like the right time to re-center on one truth: Only democracy can meet essential human needs, even beyond the physical.
That's a huge claim so here's my case.
In addition to our need for water, food and shelter, plenty of evidence suggests that--to fully thrive and for some of us to thrive at all--our species needs three things:
One, a sense of agency: knowing we have a voice--real power in our lives.
After all, we evolved as do-ers and problem solvers. Social philosopher Erich Fromm in his illuminating The Anatomy of Human Destructiveness, calls this trait simply our need to "make a dent."
Autocratic governments, by definition, deny citizens opportunity to make that dent--to create our own futures.
Two, we need meaning--to feel that our lives count for something beyond our own survival.
Autocracy can offer us limited meaning through identifying with a "strong man," but only democracy enables citizens to create their own meaning within communities they choose.
Three, we need to feel connected to others
Without community most of us whither. So, in our deeply compromised democracy the plague of loneliness has become a greater health threat than obesity.
Unlike autocracy, real democracy encourages citizens' coming together in their communities, including for common action to challenge and strengthen their democracy.
Bottom line, only democracy enables us to experience a sense of personal power, meaning, and connection in ways no other system of governance can. Of course, by "democracy" I do not mean a finished state. It is forever a work in progress.
And, here's the really great news:
The very work of furthering democracy enables us to experience these positives as well. That's why I've ditched the notion of democratic engagement as my dull duty, drummed into me as a "you should" in a high school civics class.
No, the work of democracy is a "we can!"
It's not a chore--stuffing down the blah spinach in order to earn my yummy dessert of personal freedoms. No, engaging in quickening the path of real democracy--where we each have a voice--is thrilling. In in every corner of our country a rising Democracy Movement is opening avenues to experience that thrill--advancing voting rights and limiting the power of money in politics.
So, both democracy as a form of governance and democracy as an unending journey toward its realization--even beyond the political--make it possible to experience these human essentials: personal power, meaning, and connection. Together they are the essence of human dignity.
In a word, then, democracy is dignity.
It doesn't surprise me, therefore, that eight of the ten countries ranking highest in electoral integrity, a key measure of democracy, also score highest in happiness.
So, democracy as a choice among options. It is the only pathway to meeting essential human needs, and thus our only choice for creating the world virtually all of us want.
No matter how dark the moment, this truth is for me an ever-shining lodestar.
And don't miss watching the companion video to this article - one of Frances Moore Lappe's Thought Sparks Video Series in which she opens her heart about what fortifies her in this scary time. Each week for nine weeks or more, her Small Planet Institute will release an informal 2-to-5-minute video in which Frances shares her often-surprising, liberating takes on hope, democracy, and courage.
Join Us: News for people demanding a better world
Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place. We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference. Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
Frances Moore Lappé
Frances Moore Lappé is the author of 20 books, beginning with the acclaimed "Diet for a Small Planet." Most recently she is the co-author, with Adam Eichen, of the new book, "Daring Democracy: Igniting Power, Meaning, and Connection for the America We Want." Among her numerous previous books are "EcoMind: Changing the Way We Think to Create the World We Want" (Nation Books) and "Democracy's Edge: Choosing to Save Our Country by Bringing Democracy to Life." She is co-founder of the Cambridge, Mass.-based Small Planet Institute.
Trust in democracy is tumbling. In 1995, one in fifteen Americans said they'd approve of military rule. By 2014, the share had swollen to one in six. Note this frightening crash of confidence preceded the compromised 2016 election and a president who seems particularly fond of autocrats.
Whoa. It sure seems like the right time to re-center on one truth: Only democracy can meet essential human needs, even beyond the physical.
That's a huge claim so here's my case.
In addition to our need for water, food and shelter, plenty of evidence suggests that--to fully thrive and for some of us to thrive at all--our species needs three things:
One, a sense of agency: knowing we have a voice--real power in our lives.
After all, we evolved as do-ers and problem solvers. Social philosopher Erich Fromm in his illuminating The Anatomy of Human Destructiveness, calls this trait simply our need to "make a dent."
Autocratic governments, by definition, deny citizens opportunity to make that dent--to create our own futures.
Two, we need meaning--to feel that our lives count for something beyond our own survival.
Autocracy can offer us limited meaning through identifying with a "strong man," but only democracy enables citizens to create their own meaning within communities they choose.
Three, we need to feel connected to others
Without community most of us whither. So, in our deeply compromised democracy the plague of loneliness has become a greater health threat than obesity.
Unlike autocracy, real democracy encourages citizens' coming together in their communities, including for common action to challenge and strengthen their democracy.
Bottom line, only democracy enables us to experience a sense of personal power, meaning, and connection in ways no other system of governance can. Of course, by "democracy" I do not mean a finished state. It is forever a work in progress.
And, here's the really great news:
The very work of furthering democracy enables us to experience these positives as well. That's why I've ditched the notion of democratic engagement as my dull duty, drummed into me as a "you should" in a high school civics class.
No, the work of democracy is a "we can!"
It's not a chore--stuffing down the blah spinach in order to earn my yummy dessert of personal freedoms. No, engaging in quickening the path of real democracy--where we each have a voice--is thrilling. In in every corner of our country a rising Democracy Movement is opening avenues to experience that thrill--advancing voting rights and limiting the power of money in politics.
So, both democracy as a form of governance and democracy as an unending journey toward its realization--even beyond the political--make it possible to experience these human essentials: personal power, meaning, and connection. Together they are the essence of human dignity.
In a word, then, democracy is dignity.
It doesn't surprise me, therefore, that eight of the ten countries ranking highest in electoral integrity, a key measure of democracy, also score highest in happiness.
So, democracy as a choice among options. It is the only pathway to meeting essential human needs, and thus our only choice for creating the world virtually all of us want.
No matter how dark the moment, this truth is for me an ever-shining lodestar.
And don't miss watching the companion video to this article - one of Frances Moore Lappe's Thought Sparks Video Series in which she opens her heart about what fortifies her in this scary time. Each week for nine weeks or more, her Small Planet Institute will release an informal 2-to-5-minute video in which Frances shares her often-surprising, liberating takes on hope, democracy, and courage.
Frances Moore Lappé
Frances Moore Lappé is the author of 20 books, beginning with the acclaimed "Diet for a Small Planet." Most recently she is the co-author, with Adam Eichen, of the new book, "Daring Democracy: Igniting Power, Meaning, and Connection for the America We Want." Among her numerous previous books are "EcoMind: Changing the Way We Think to Create the World We Want" (Nation Books) and "Democracy's Edge: Choosing to Save Our Country by Bringing Democracy to Life." She is co-founder of the Cambridge, Mass.-based Small Planet Institute.
Trust in democracy is tumbling. In 1995, one in fifteen Americans said they'd approve of military rule. By 2014, the share had swollen to one in six. Note this frightening crash of confidence preceded the compromised 2016 election and a president who seems particularly fond of autocrats.
Whoa. It sure seems like the right time to re-center on one truth: Only democracy can meet essential human needs, even beyond the physical.
That's a huge claim so here's my case.
In addition to our need for water, food and shelter, plenty of evidence suggests that--to fully thrive and for some of us to thrive at all--our species needs three things:
One, a sense of agency: knowing we have a voice--real power in our lives.
After all, we evolved as do-ers and problem solvers. Social philosopher Erich Fromm in his illuminating The Anatomy of Human Destructiveness, calls this trait simply our need to "make a dent."
Autocratic governments, by definition, deny citizens opportunity to make that dent--to create our own futures.
Two, we need meaning--to feel that our lives count for something beyond our own survival.
Autocracy can offer us limited meaning through identifying with a "strong man," but only democracy enables citizens to create their own meaning within communities they choose.
Three, we need to feel connected to others
Without community most of us whither. So, in our deeply compromised democracy the plague of loneliness has become a greater health threat than obesity.
Unlike autocracy, real democracy encourages citizens' coming together in their communities, including for common action to challenge and strengthen their democracy.
Bottom line, only democracy enables us to experience a sense of personal power, meaning, and connection in ways no other system of governance can. Of course, by "democracy" I do not mean a finished state. It is forever a work in progress.
And, here's the really great news:
The very work of furthering democracy enables us to experience these positives as well. That's why I've ditched the notion of democratic engagement as my dull duty, drummed into me as a "you should" in a high school civics class.
No, the work of democracy is a "we can!"
It's not a chore--stuffing down the blah spinach in order to earn my yummy dessert of personal freedoms. No, engaging in quickening the path of real democracy--where we each have a voice--is thrilling. In in every corner of our country a rising Democracy Movement is opening avenues to experience that thrill--advancing voting rights and limiting the power of money in politics.
So, both democracy as a form of governance and democracy as an unending journey toward its realization--even beyond the political--make it possible to experience these human essentials: personal power, meaning, and connection. Together they are the essence of human dignity.
In a word, then, democracy is dignity.
It doesn't surprise me, therefore, that eight of the ten countries ranking highest in electoral integrity, a key measure of democracy, also score highest in happiness.
So, democracy as a choice among options. It is the only pathway to meeting essential human needs, and thus our only choice for creating the world virtually all of us want.
No matter how dark the moment, this truth is for me an ever-shining lodestar.
And don't miss watching the companion video to this article - one of Frances Moore Lappe's Thought Sparks Video Series in which she opens her heart about what fortifies her in this scary time. Each week for nine weeks or more, her Small Planet Institute will release an informal 2-to-5-minute video in which Frances shares her often-surprising, liberating takes on hope, democracy, and courage.
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.