Published on
Common Dreams

A Lesson from Pope Francis’s Visit to Brazil

During his visit to Brazil, Pope Francis’ visit to Varginha, a favela in Rio de Janeiro drew crowds of thousands of people, most of them young. It was a good opportunity for him to preach social justice and to demand an end to social inequalities. His visit to Brazil came at a time of great social protests against those issues, and for an end to corruption among venal politicians.

Favelas-like neighborhoods exist throughout Latin America. Similar places are known as ranchitos in Venezuela, pueblos jóvenes in Peru or villas miseria in Argentina. As a consequence of poverty, huge waves of migrants move to the countries’ main cities and end up living in these ramshackle settlements, which usually lack basic health and sanitation services.

At a meeting in New York I met a young Brazilian physician—Dr. Paulo as everybody knows him—and we became friends. He told me repeatedly that if I ever was in Rio de Janeiro I should visit him. He said that he would take me to the best places in Rio de Janeiro where he has an active practice that puts him in touch with all segments of Brazilian society.

Soon after our meeting I went to Rio de Janeiro for a medical congress and called him up. He came promptly to my hotel and asked me, since the weekend was coming, what I wanted to see in Río. I told him that I wanted to visit a favela. He looked at me quizzically and said, “I want to take you to the best places in Rio and you ask me to take you to a favela? I don’t understand you.”

I explained to him that in New York I already have access to very fancy places but, although I have visited slums in Argentina and in other Latin American countries, I had never been to a favela. “OK,” he said, clearly disappointed, “if that is what you want to do…one of my patients lives in Rocinha, Rio’s largest favela, so I’ll come for you tomorrow morning and we’ll go.”

Unlike many ghettos in the United States, the population in the favelas is racially mixed, although blacks make up the majority of the population. Increasing poverty drives many people to live in the favelas, which are sometimes built on several levels on hillsides, crowded with poor-quality housing and besieged by the drug trade.


Never Miss a Beat.

Get our best delivered to your inbox.

Because the favelas built on hillsides are very close to rich neighborhoods below them, there is active drug traffic from the favelas to the wealthy neighborhoods. The police are normally unable to enter the favelas and, when they do it, they go in powerful armored vehicles called caveirôes (literally, big skulls).

There are some social codes in the favelas which prohibit those living there to engage in criminal activities inside their own favela. However, because favelas house many people involved in drug trade and other kinds of crime, a visit there could be dangerous. Frequent shoot-outs between traffickers and the police, and other illegal activities, such as prostitution and gambling, lead to murder rates higher than in the rest of the city.

Perhaps my friend was thinking about all these issues when I asked him to visit a favela. He was a good sport, however, and took me there. As soon as we reached the lower level we saw a small group of men talking on the side of the steps. My friend went directly to them and said, “I am Dr. Paulo, this is my friend César and we are visiting one of my patients called Mercedes who lives in the upper level.”

Without waiting for a response we continued climbing the steps to the following level where we also found a similar group of men. My friend repeated what he had said before and we continued climbing, at each level following the same script.

I was surprised and a bit irritated by his behavior so I told him, “Why do you have to tell everybody who we are and why we came here?” My friend looked at me and said, “Because if I don’t we won’t reach the upper level. These men constitute the most efficient communication system you can imagine, so we have to clear our presence here at every level to remain safe.”

Finally, after a steep climb we reached the upper level and knocked at the door of my friend’s patient. Mercedes, a woman of around 80 came out and was totally taken aback when she saw us. “Dr. Paulo,” she said, “what a surprise seeing you here!” as she opened her arms and embraced him. Then, in a conspiratorial manner she asked my friend, “Dr. Paulo, I want to be first one to know it, are you running for office?”

César Chelala

César Chelala

Dr. César Chelala is an international public health consultant, co-winner of an Overseas Press Club of America award and two national journalism awards from Argentina.

This is the world we live in. This is the world we cover.

Because of people like you, another world is possible. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. Common Dreams is not your normal news site. We don't survive on clicks. We don't want advertising dollars. We want the world to be a better place. But we can't do it alone. It doesn't work that way. We need you. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do. Without Your Support We Simply Don't Exist.

Please select a donation method:

Share This Article