Jun 23, 2011
As Interior Secretary Ken Salazar joined Havasupai tribal elders and Congressman Raul Grijalva for a historic announcement at the Grand Canyon National Park on Monday, Republicans across Arizona scurried to create their own roadside attraction.
And relying on information from a widely denounced anti-immigrant extremist, FOX News and other media outlets have been right behind them to fan the flames of Arizona's right-wing discontent this summer.
First the good news: Thanks to the long-time work of numerous Arizona groups and public officials, Salazar upheld a moratorium on a million-acre zone of uranium mining claims, assuring federal protection for Arizona's singular natural heritage: The Grand Canyon state.
"The announcement today begins to reverse the poisonous legacy of uranium mining and its devastating contamination to our region's people, water, and land," said Roger Clark, the Air and Energy Director for the Grand Canyon Trust.
While this should have been a moment to celebrate statewide, among the scandal-ridden and soon-to-be-recalled ranks of the Republicans, state leaders were falling over themselves to trump Alabama's new immigration crackdown and reclaim Arizona's reputation as the xenophobic stalwarts of the nation.
Last Wednesday, making good on his campaign promise to "stop la raza" or Mexican Americans, Arizona Superintendent of Public Instruction John Huppenthal blatantly misrepresented the audit results of Tucson's Ethnic Studies/Mexican American Studies Program and declared the acclaimed program out of compliance with the state's ban. Huppenthal's lack of complete veracity has placed him under investigation, including a filing by the ACLU for full disclosure of the education chief's records.
Then Sen. John McCain started the next firestorm with his blunder last Saturday, when he declared he had "substantial evidence" that undocumented immigrants or smugglers were responsible for some of Arizona's numerous fires. While McCain tried to clarify his statement as a general overview on border security, he didn't seem to notice that forest rangers had already dismissed these types of rumors weeks ago. Quoted in the New York Times, one ranger "cited four other southern Arizona fires, all of them in known smuggling areas, that were found to have been caused by American citizens."
Not to be outdone, FOX News took the rumors one step further today with an interview with Cochise County Sheriff Larry Dever, with the headline: Arizona Sheriff: Wildfires Likely Started by Mexican Drug Traffickers, Smugglers. Without any hard evidence, though, Dever had to admit toward the end of his interview, "there's no way to know" who is responsible.
Amazingly, FOX News published and relied on data collected by Glenn Spencer, an infamous anti-immigrant extremist and militia activist. To back up Dever's claims and their screaming headlines, FOX News featured, "an aerial photograph purportedly taken on June 12 of the area by American Border Patrol, an independent organization that monitors the border, claims the blaze actually started in Mexico and traveled upwind into the United States. Dever said that was an "accurate picture" of what occurred."
Wow, so now the news media and law enforcement are relying on known anti-extremist groups for "accurate" data about Mexicans?
As Rep. Grijalva remarked on McCain's first comments, "This level of intolerance has reached a new low."
A year ago this month, Governor Jan Brewer conjured her own visions of "beheadings" by Mexican immigrants in the Arizona deserts, only to admit she was wrong. Will McCain, Dever and Huppenthal be next?
In the meantime, as the Arizona Gone Wild episodes turn, this is turning out to be a week of Mexicans, Lies and Videotape:
Here's Dever's interview on FOX News:
And popular Tucson blog Three Sonorans also questions Huppenthal's own misrepresentation of the facts about the Mexican American Studies program and its educational achievement in the growing Ethnic Studies audit scandal in this videotape:
Join Us: News for people demanding a better world
Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place. We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference. Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. Join with us today! |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
Jeff Biggers
Jeff Biggers is the author of numerous books, including his latest: "Resistance: Reclaiming an American Tradition?" His previous works include: "State Out of the Union: Arizona and the Final Showdown Over the American Dream;" "The United States of Appalachia;" and "Reckoning at Eagle Creek: The Secret Legacy of Coal in the Heartland."
As Interior Secretary Ken Salazar joined Havasupai tribal elders and Congressman Raul Grijalva for a historic announcement at the Grand Canyon National Park on Monday, Republicans across Arizona scurried to create their own roadside attraction.
And relying on information from a widely denounced anti-immigrant extremist, FOX News and other media outlets have been right behind them to fan the flames of Arizona's right-wing discontent this summer.
First the good news: Thanks to the long-time work of numerous Arizona groups and public officials, Salazar upheld a moratorium on a million-acre zone of uranium mining claims, assuring federal protection for Arizona's singular natural heritage: The Grand Canyon state.
"The announcement today begins to reverse the poisonous legacy of uranium mining and its devastating contamination to our region's people, water, and land," said Roger Clark, the Air and Energy Director for the Grand Canyon Trust.
While this should have been a moment to celebrate statewide, among the scandal-ridden and soon-to-be-recalled ranks of the Republicans, state leaders were falling over themselves to trump Alabama's new immigration crackdown and reclaim Arizona's reputation as the xenophobic stalwarts of the nation.
Last Wednesday, making good on his campaign promise to "stop la raza" or Mexican Americans, Arizona Superintendent of Public Instruction John Huppenthal blatantly misrepresented the audit results of Tucson's Ethnic Studies/Mexican American Studies Program and declared the acclaimed program out of compliance with the state's ban. Huppenthal's lack of complete veracity has placed him under investigation, including a filing by the ACLU for full disclosure of the education chief's records.
Then Sen. John McCain started the next firestorm with his blunder last Saturday, when he declared he had "substantial evidence" that undocumented immigrants or smugglers were responsible for some of Arizona's numerous fires. While McCain tried to clarify his statement as a general overview on border security, he didn't seem to notice that forest rangers had already dismissed these types of rumors weeks ago. Quoted in the New York Times, one ranger "cited four other southern Arizona fires, all of them in known smuggling areas, that were found to have been caused by American citizens."
Not to be outdone, FOX News took the rumors one step further today with an interview with Cochise County Sheriff Larry Dever, with the headline: Arizona Sheriff: Wildfires Likely Started by Mexican Drug Traffickers, Smugglers. Without any hard evidence, though, Dever had to admit toward the end of his interview, "there's no way to know" who is responsible.
Amazingly, FOX News published and relied on data collected by Glenn Spencer, an infamous anti-immigrant extremist and militia activist. To back up Dever's claims and their screaming headlines, FOX News featured, "an aerial photograph purportedly taken on June 12 of the area by American Border Patrol, an independent organization that monitors the border, claims the blaze actually started in Mexico and traveled upwind into the United States. Dever said that was an "accurate picture" of what occurred."
Wow, so now the news media and law enforcement are relying on known anti-extremist groups for "accurate" data about Mexicans?
As Rep. Grijalva remarked on McCain's first comments, "This level of intolerance has reached a new low."
A year ago this month, Governor Jan Brewer conjured her own visions of "beheadings" by Mexican immigrants in the Arizona deserts, only to admit she was wrong. Will McCain, Dever and Huppenthal be next?
In the meantime, as the Arizona Gone Wild episodes turn, this is turning out to be a week of Mexicans, Lies and Videotape:
Here's Dever's interview on FOX News:
And popular Tucson blog Three Sonorans also questions Huppenthal's own misrepresentation of the facts about the Mexican American Studies program and its educational achievement in the growing Ethnic Studies audit scandal in this videotape:
Jeff Biggers
Jeff Biggers is the author of numerous books, including his latest: "Resistance: Reclaiming an American Tradition?" His previous works include: "State Out of the Union: Arizona and the Final Showdown Over the American Dream;" "The United States of Appalachia;" and "Reckoning at Eagle Creek: The Secret Legacy of Coal in the Heartland."
As Interior Secretary Ken Salazar joined Havasupai tribal elders and Congressman Raul Grijalva for a historic announcement at the Grand Canyon National Park on Monday, Republicans across Arizona scurried to create their own roadside attraction.
And relying on information from a widely denounced anti-immigrant extremist, FOX News and other media outlets have been right behind them to fan the flames of Arizona's right-wing discontent this summer.
First the good news: Thanks to the long-time work of numerous Arizona groups and public officials, Salazar upheld a moratorium on a million-acre zone of uranium mining claims, assuring federal protection for Arizona's singular natural heritage: The Grand Canyon state.
"The announcement today begins to reverse the poisonous legacy of uranium mining and its devastating contamination to our region's people, water, and land," said Roger Clark, the Air and Energy Director for the Grand Canyon Trust.
While this should have been a moment to celebrate statewide, among the scandal-ridden and soon-to-be-recalled ranks of the Republicans, state leaders were falling over themselves to trump Alabama's new immigration crackdown and reclaim Arizona's reputation as the xenophobic stalwarts of the nation.
Last Wednesday, making good on his campaign promise to "stop la raza" or Mexican Americans, Arizona Superintendent of Public Instruction John Huppenthal blatantly misrepresented the audit results of Tucson's Ethnic Studies/Mexican American Studies Program and declared the acclaimed program out of compliance with the state's ban. Huppenthal's lack of complete veracity has placed him under investigation, including a filing by the ACLU for full disclosure of the education chief's records.
Then Sen. John McCain started the next firestorm with his blunder last Saturday, when he declared he had "substantial evidence" that undocumented immigrants or smugglers were responsible for some of Arizona's numerous fires. While McCain tried to clarify his statement as a general overview on border security, he didn't seem to notice that forest rangers had already dismissed these types of rumors weeks ago. Quoted in the New York Times, one ranger "cited four other southern Arizona fires, all of them in known smuggling areas, that were found to have been caused by American citizens."
Not to be outdone, FOX News took the rumors one step further today with an interview with Cochise County Sheriff Larry Dever, with the headline: Arizona Sheriff: Wildfires Likely Started by Mexican Drug Traffickers, Smugglers. Without any hard evidence, though, Dever had to admit toward the end of his interview, "there's no way to know" who is responsible.
Amazingly, FOX News published and relied on data collected by Glenn Spencer, an infamous anti-immigrant extremist and militia activist. To back up Dever's claims and their screaming headlines, FOX News featured, "an aerial photograph purportedly taken on June 12 of the area by American Border Patrol, an independent organization that monitors the border, claims the blaze actually started in Mexico and traveled upwind into the United States. Dever said that was an "accurate picture" of what occurred."
Wow, so now the news media and law enforcement are relying on known anti-extremist groups for "accurate" data about Mexicans?
As Rep. Grijalva remarked on McCain's first comments, "This level of intolerance has reached a new low."
A year ago this month, Governor Jan Brewer conjured her own visions of "beheadings" by Mexican immigrants in the Arizona deserts, only to admit she was wrong. Will McCain, Dever and Huppenthal be next?
In the meantime, as the Arizona Gone Wild episodes turn, this is turning out to be a week of Mexicans, Lies and Videotape:
Here's Dever's interview on FOX News:
And popular Tucson blog Three Sonorans also questions Huppenthal's own misrepresentation of the facts about the Mexican American Studies program and its educational achievement in the growing Ethnic Studies audit scandal in this videotape:
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.