Chronology: Which Side Violated the Israel-Gaza Ceasefire?

The Bush Administration and The New York Times v. Amnesty International


June 18, 2008

has approved a ceasefire to end months of bitter clashes with the
Palestinian Islamist movement Hamas in Gaza, Israeli officials have
confirmed. Under the terms of the truce, which is set to begin Thursday (June 19), Israel will ease its blockade on the Gaza Strip.At the same time, talks to release an Israeli soldier [Gilad Shalit] held by Hamas would intensify, an Israeli official said. Hamas, which controls Gaza, says it is confident that all militants will abide by
the truce [by not firing rockets into southern Israel].
The agreement is supposed to last six months. (Emphasis added) ("Israel Agrees to Gaza Ceasefire," BBC, June 18, 2008)

December 28, 2008

United States strongly condemns the repeated rocket and mortar attacks
against Israel and holds Hamas responsible for breaking the cease-fire
and for the renewal of violence in Gaza." U.S. Secretary of State
Condoleezza Rice. ("White House Puts Onus on Hamas to End Escalation of
Violence," New York Times, December 28, 2008)

December 30, 2008

must defend itself. And Hamas must bear responsibility for ending a
six-month cease-fire this month with a barrage of rocket attacks into
Israeli territory." ("War Over Gaza," New York Times editorial, December 30, 2008)

Ceasefire Chronology: (See November 5 and December 28 Entries Below For Direct References to Breaking the Ceasefire)

July 4, 2008

humanitarian crisis is engulfing Gaza-not the result of a natural
disaster but entirely man-made and avoidable. The tightening of the
Israeli blockade since June 2007 has left the population, 1.5 million
Palestinians, trapped and with few resources. They are surviving, but
only just. Some 80 per cent depend on the trickle of international aid
that the Israeli government allows in.

the first five months of 2008 some 380 Palestinians, more than a third
of them unarmed civilians and including more than 60 children, were
killed by the Israeli army, almost all of them in the Gaza Strip. In
the same period 25 Israelis, 16 of them civilians, were killed by
Palestinian armed groups.

ceasefire between Israeli forces and Palestinian armed groups came into
force on 19 June and at the time of writing it looked uncertain.
Israeli officials however, insisted that Gaza's border remains sealed
so long as Hamas does not release the Israeli soldier they are holding.
Some 8,500 Palestinians are detained in Israeli jails. Of these, 900
are from the Gaza Strip, all of whom have been denied visits by their
families since June 2007.

Palestinian armed groups in Gaza continue to hold an Israeli soldier, who was captured in June 2006, and to deny him access to the International Committee of the Red Cross. ("Gaza Blockage: Collective Punishment," Amnesty International, July 4, 2008)

August 14, 2008

400 Palestinian students may lose their university places and
scholarships unless the Israeli authorities allow them to leave the
Gaza Strip before the new academic year, which starts in the next few
weeks. The students have enrolled to study subjects including law,
sciences, business and medicine.

least 37 of the students have university places and scholarships in
Europe and North America, while hundreds of others are due to travel to
universities in countries in the Middle East and elsewhere. Several of
these students have been denied permission to leave Gaza since last
year. ("Freedom of Movement, Right to Education Denied," Amnesty
International, August 14, 2008)

August 15, 2008

International has described as scandalous the Israeli army's account of
firing a tank shell that killed Reuters cameraman Fadel Shana as a
"sound" decision. The army reached the conclusion as part of a
so-called investigation into the killing of the journalist and three
other unarmed civilians, including 2 children, on 16 April 2008.

army's so-called investigation lacked any semblance of impartiality and
Amnesty International called for an independent and impartial
investigation into the killing. The organization said that the army's
conclusion can only reinforce the culture of impunity that has led to
so many reckless and disproportionate killings of children and other
unarmed civilians by Israeli forces in Gaza.

Fadel Shana worked
for Reuters press agency and was in a car clearly marked as Press. He
and his colleague left the car, wearing visible Press flak-jackets and
he was killed by an Israeli tank he was filming. The tank fired a shell
at Shana, which also hit the civilians, including children, and injured
his colleague and others around him. ("Army's So-Called Inquiry into
Cameraman's Killing in Gaza a Scandal," Amnesty International, August
15, 2008)

August 22, 2008

the exception of Karima Abu Dalal (who was finally able to leave Gaza
through an exceptional arrangement via the border with Egypt after many
months' delay to her treatment for Hodgkin's lymphoma) all the
critically ill patients named above are still being denied permission
to leave Gaza for treatment abroad.

Israeli authorities are refusing to allow these and hundreds of other
patients to leave Gaza to obtain specialized treatment unavailable in
Gaza, for undisclosed and unsubstantiated security reasons. Dozens of
patients have died in recent months following delays to, or denials of,
permits to leave Gaza. ("Further Information on Medical Concern,"
Amnesty International, August 22, 2008)

August 27, 2008

Gaza locked down and cut off from the outside world by a stifling
Israeli blockade, 46 peace activists from the world over set sail for
Gaza on 22 August to, in their words, "break the siege that Israel has
imposed on the civilian population of Gaza..., to express our solidarity
with the suffering people of Gaza, and to create a free and regular
channel between Gaza and the outside world."

The blockade
imposed by Israel on the Gaza Strip over a year ago has left the entire
population of 1.5 million Palestinians trapped with dwindling resources
and an economy in ruins. Some 80 per cent of the population now depend
on the trickle of international aid that the Israeli army allows in.
This humanitarian crisis is man-made and entirely avoidable.

Israeli authorities argue that the blockade on Gaza is in response to
Palestinian attacks, especially the indiscriminate rockets fired from
Gaza at the nearby Israeli town of Sderot. These and other Palestinian
attacks killed 25 Israelis in the first half of this year; in the same
period Israeli forces killed 400 Palestinians.

However, the
Israeli blockade does not target the Palestinian armed groups
responsible for attacks-it collectively punishes the entire population
of Gaza.

a ceasefire between Israeli forces and Palestinian armed groups has
held in Gaza since 19 June 2008, the Israeli blockade remains in place.

has banned exports from Gaza altogether and has reduced entry of fuel
and goods to a trickle-mostly humanitarian aid, foodstuff and medical
supplies. Basic necessities are in short supply or not available at all
in Gaza. The shortages have pushed up food prices at a time when people
can least afford to pay more. A growing number of Gazans have been
pushed into extreme poverty and suffer from malnutrition.

With the ceasefire holding, the suffering in Gaza has fallen off the
international news agenda. However, Amnesty International members continue to campaign, calling:

the Israeli authorities to immediately lift the blockade, allow
unhindered passage into Gaza of sufficient quantities of fuel,
electricity and other necessities; and allow those who want to leave
Gaza to do so, notably patients in need of medical treatment not
available in Gaza and students enrolled in universities abroad, and
also to allow them later to return; on Palestinian armed groups not to
resume rocket and other attacks on Israeli civilians. ("Trapped:
Collective Punishment in Gaza," Amnesty International, August 27, 2008)

August 29, 2008

Israeli authorities are still denying scores of critically ill patients
the authorization they need to leave Gaza for medical treatment that is
unavailable in Gaza. Hospitals in Gaza continue to lack vital medical
equipment and trained personnel to carry out advanced medical
treatment, including many surgical operations and the provision of
chemotherapy for cancer patients. Even those patients who are given
permission to leave Gaza for treatment are often suffering as a result
of delays in receiving exit permits, which contribute to a decline in
patient's health and emotional well-being.

Interrogation by the General Security Service

the past year, the denial of permits to seriously ill patients has
primarily been based on undisclosed security reasons. Some patients
from Gaza testified to Amnesty International that they were openly told
in interviews with the Israeli General Security Service (GSS) [Israel's
counterintelligence and internal security service, also known as Shin
Bet] at the Erez Crossing point at the northern border with Israel that
they would not receive treatment in Israel unless they become
informants for the GSS. As Physicians for Human Rights-Israel
(PHR-Israel) describes in a recent report, "patients are detained for
interrogation at Erez Crossing, and requested either to provide
information or to act as collaborators on a regular basis as a
condition for permission to exit Gaza for medical treatment."

report provides testimonies that PHR-Israel has received from a number
of patients that demonstrate this practice. According to PHR-Israel,
rejection or approval of a patient's request to leave Gaza for
treatment almost entirely depends on the GSS who are taking advantage
of the vulnerability of patients who have no other means of accessing
medical care.

patients who already have an exit permit from the authorities to cross
into Israel at Erez are being denied permission to leave Gaza after an
"unsatisfactory" interrogation. This policy by the GSS of questioning
patients in exchange for entry into Israel appears to have become a
formal part of the exit procedure for patients and is reportedly
discouraging some patients from attempting to leave Gaza in the first
place. ("Health Professional Action: Patients From Gaza Are Still
Denied Access to Medical Treatment in Israel," Amnesty International,
August 29, 2008)

October 16, 2008

children named above [ages 5 months, 1.2 years, 1.2 years, 1.5 years, 5
years, and 6 years] suffer from serious heart conditions including
congenital heart defects commonly known as holes in the heart. All the
children need urgent surgery that cannot be provided in Gaza, which
lacks both the necessary medical facilities and specialists. The
children were due to be operated on by a team of British heart
specialists at Makassad Hospital in East Jerusalem during the week
beginning 4 October 2008. They were not able to leave the Gaza Strip
because the Israeli authorities refused permissions to their
mothers/grandmothers to leave Gaza to accompany them. Soheb Wael
Alqasas has already missed six appointments for his surgery in recent
months because his mother and grandmother were repeatedly refused
permits to accompany him to the hospital in Jerusalem.

team of Italian heart specialists will be conducting a week of
paediatric cardiac surgery at the Makassad Hospital from 6 November. It
is imperative that the six children are able to attend the Makassad
Hospital in time to undergo surgery by the visiting team of
specialists. For this to be possible their relatives must be allowed to
travel with them to the hospital in Jerusalem. ("Medical Concern,"
Amnesty International, October 16, 2008)

November 5, 2008

spate of Israeli and Palestinian attacks and counter-attacks in the
past 24 hours could spell the end of a five-and-a-half-month ceasefire.
This would once again put the civilian populations of Gaza and southern
Israel in the line of fire.

The killing of six Palestinian
militants in Gaza by Israeli forces in a ground incursion and air
strikes on 4 November was followed by a barrage of dozens of
Palestinian rockets on nearby towns and villages in the south of
The Palestinian attacks caused no casualties or
damage, but there is a real risk that any further armed actions by
either side would risk igniting another deadly campaign.

ceasefire was agreed between Israel and Hamas last June and has been in
force since then. It has been the single most important factor in
reducing civilian casualties and attacks on civilians to the lowest
level since the outbreak of the uprising (intifada) more than eight
years ago.

The ceasefire has brought enormous improvements
in the quality of life in Sderot and other Israeli villages near Gaza,
where before the ceasefire residents lived in fear of the next
Palestinian rocket strike. However, nearby in the Gaza Strip the
Israeli blockade remains in place and the population has so far seen
few dividends from the ceasefire.

Since June 2007, the entire population of 1.5 million Palestinians has
been trapped in Gaza, with dwindling resources and an economy in ruins.
Some 80 percent of the population now depend on the trickle of
international aid that the Israeli army allows in. (Emphasis added)
("Gaza Ceasefire at Risk," Amnesty International, November 5, 2008)

November 14, 2008

Israeli army has completely blocked the delivery of urgently needed
humanitarian aid and medical supplies to the Gaza Strip for more than a
week. Very little fuel has been allowed in. Amnesty International urged
the Israeli authorities on Friday to allow their immediate passage.

latest tightening of the Israeli blockade has made an already dire
humanitarian situation markedly worse. It is nothing short of
collective punishment on Gaza's civilian population and it must stop
immediately," said Philip Luther, Deputy Director of Amnesty
International's Middle East and North Africa Programme.

per cent of the population of Gaza has been dependent on the trickle of
humanitarian aid previously allowed into Gaza until Wednesday, 5
November. Industrial fuel, which is donated by the European Union and
needed to power Gaza's power plant, has also been blocked, causing a
blackout in large parts of Gaza. The United Nations Relief and Work Agency (UNRWA),
the main UN aid agency, which provides humanitarian assistance to close
to one million Palestinian refugees in Gaza, announced on Thursday that
its supplies had run out. At the same time, the Israeli
authorities have been denying access to Gaza to foreign journalists for
a week and a convoy of European diplomats were likewise refused entry
on Thursday. "Gaza is cut off from the outside world and Israel is
seemingly not keen for the world to see the suffering that its blockade
is causing the one and a half million Palestinians who are virtually
trapped there," said Philip Luther. The breakdown last week of a
five-and-a-half-month ceasefire between Israeli forces and Palestinian
militants in Gaza has generated a renewed wave of violence. The killing
of six Palestinian militants in Israeli air strikes and ground attacks
on 4 November prompted a barrage of Palestinian rockets on nearby
Israeli towns and villages.

Five other Palestinian militants have been killed by Israeli forces in recent days. Palestinian rocket attacks have continued. No
Israeli casualties had been reported until earlier today, when one
Israeli was lightly wounded by shrapnel in an attack on the Israeli
city of Sderot. ("Israeli Army Blocks Deliveries to Gaza," Amnesty
International, November 14, 2008)

November 17, 2008

impediments faced by Palestinians in Gaza in obtaining access to health
care continue to be a cause for serious concern. The Israeli blockade
of the Gaza Strip has caused a further deterioration in the
humanitarian situation, health and sanitation problems, as well as
extreme poverty and malnutrition.

only a few exceptions, the entire population of 1.5 million people are
trapped in Gaza. Students are unable to attend university studies and
jobs abroad and critically ill patients in need of medical care that is
unavailable in local hospitals are often prevented from leaving Gaza.
("Health Professional Action: Crushing the Right to Health," Amnesty
International, November 17, 2008)

November 17, 2008

Israeli army allowed a limited number of trucks carrying humanitarian
assistance into Gaza for the first time in two weeks on Monday.
However, the long-term nature of the blockade and restrictions on the
flow of goods into Gaza has led to a situation where reserves have long
been depleted.

is necessary, at a minimum, is for Israel to allow regular and
unhindered flow of humanitarian aid, medical supplies and other basic
necessities into Gaza," said Donatella Rovera, Amnesty International
researcher on Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories.
("Israeli Army Relaxes Restrictions on Humanitarian Aid to Gaza,"
Amnesty International, November 17, 2008)

December 5, 2008

Israeli blockade of the Gaza Strip is having ever more serious
consequences on its population. In the past month the supply of
humanitarian aid and basic necessities to Gaza has been reduced from a
trickle to an intermittent drip. The blockade has become tighter than
ever since the breakdown of a five-and-a-half-month ceasefire between
Israeli forces and Palestinian militants on 5 November.

Israeli authorities might be allowing through enough for the survival
of Gaza's population, but this is nowhere near enough for the 1.5
million inhabitants of Gaza to live with dignity," said Donatella
Rovera, Amnesty International's researcher on Israel and the Occupied
Palestinian Territories.

As supplies are being further
withheld, most mills have shut down because they have little or no
grain. People who have long been deprived of many food items now cannot
even find bread at times. Reserves of food have long been depleted and
the meagre quantities allowed into Gaza are not even enough to meet the
immediate needs. Families never know if they will have food for their
children the following day.

When people do have food, they
generally have no cooking gas or electricity with which to cook it.
Last week, less than 10 per cent of the weekly requirement of cooking
gas was allowed into Gaza. ("Gaza Reduced to Bare Survival," Amnesty
International, December 5, 2008)

December 28, 2008

International has called on Israeli forces and Palestinian armed groups
to immediately halt the unlawful attacks carried out as part of the
escalation of violence which has caused the death of some 280
Palestinians and one Israeli civilian since December 27.

is the highest level of Palestinian fatalities and casualties in four
decades of Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip. Scores
of unarmed civilians, as well as police personnel who were not directly
participating in the hostilities, are among the Palestinian victims of
the Israeli bombardment in the Gaza Strip.

disproportionate use of force by Israel is unlawful and risks igniting
further violence in the whole region," said Amnesty International. "The
escalation of violence comes at a time when the civilian population
already faces a daily struggle for survival due to the Israeli blockade
which has prevented even food and medicines from entering Gaza."

and other Palestinian armed groups, for their part, share
responsibility for the escalation. Their continuous rocket attacks on
towns and villages in southern Israel are unlawful and can never be
justified," Amnesty International said.

This latest Israeli
onslaught brings the number of Palestinians killed by Israeli forces
this year to some 650, at least a third of whom are unarmed civilians,
including 70 children. In the same period, Palestinian armed groups
have killed 25 Israelis, 16 of them civilians, including four children.

ceasefire effectively ended after six Palestinian militants were killed
by Israeli forces in Gaza force on 4 November and a barrage of
Palestinians rockets were launched on nearby towns and villages in the
south of Israel.
(Emphasis added) ("Civilians Must Be Protected in Gaza and Israel," Amnesty International, December 28, 2008)

Join Us: News for people demanding a better world

Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place.

We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference.

Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. Join with us today!

Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.