Jul 09, 2021
Defenders of local media expressed concern Friday following new reporting highlighting how Pennsylvania's recently signed state budget fully eliminates funding for state broadcasters.
The budget decision was "precisely the opposite of what we should be doing," tweeted Victor Pickard, professor of media molicy and political economy at the University of Pennsylvania's Annenberg School for Communication, where he co-directs the Media, Inequality and Change Center (MIC).
The PennsylvaniaCapital-Starreported Friday that seven public TV and radio stations, "such as WHYY in Philadelphia, WQED in Pittsburgh, and WITF in Harrisburg, saw their funding eliminated" when Gov. Tom Wolf, a Democrat, signed the state budget at the end of June.
\u201cwow, this sucks, and is a huge blow to my strong @WHYYunion pals currently fighting for *adequate* wages\n\n"...even with a multi-billion dollar surplus, seven public TV and radio stations \u2014 such as WHYY in Philadelphia ... saw their funding eliminated."\n\nhttps://t.co/4YC6GXyuAO\u201d— Jon Ehrens (@Jon Ehrens) 1625831484
The stations had been allotted a combined $750,000 annually since 2019.
Bill Marrazzo, CEO of WHYY, toldCurrent earlier this year that the state funding was critical. "These sorts of unrestricted funds are the hardest kinds of dollars to come by these days," he said.
The Capital-Star noted that the "dollars at stake are a small slice--just under 1%--of the seven broadcasters' revenues." Still, Pickard, who framed public broadcasters as "public goods," told the outlet the zeroing out of funding was a move in the absolute wrong direction. "It's glaringly obvious the market cannot support the levels of news and information that democracy requires," said Pickard.
Another media expert drew attention to a possible connection between the funding and an editorial decision by one of the impacted stations, Harrisburg's WITF, regarding how it treats federal and state lawmakers who backed former President Donald Trump's lie the 2020 election was "stolen."
"WITF believes elected officials who supported the election-fraud lie through their actions should be held accountable, and we believe consistently presenting the facts that reveal the lie will play a part in diminishing its power over those who believed and supported it," WITF announced in January. "In stories on-air and online we will identify those U.S. representatives or state legislators to hold them accountable for their actions."
The decision, and the fact that the state Legislature is controlled by Republicans, may have been a factor in the funding decision, said Tim Karr, senior director of strategy and communications at advocacy group Free Press.
In a Friday Twitter thread responding to the Capital-Star's reporting, Karr wrote that "the reasons behind PA defunding appear to be highly controversial."
"The zeroing out of state funds comes as WITF's NPR-affliliated journalists pursue a lengthy investigation to hold Pennsylvania's Republican legislators accountable for undermining the 2020 election," he wrote.
"The defunding of WITF seems not to be a coincidence," Karr wrote. "Rather GOP legislators are seeking to punish a reliable local outlet for doing its job of exposing their part in the 'Big Lie.'"
In an op-ed last month at Columbia Journalism Review, Pickard and Timothy Neff, a postdoctoral research fellow at Annenberg's MIC, discussed how the U.S. stands out from other democratic nations in its low funding of public media and argued that boosted, long-term funding is needed to counter the crisis driving "local journalism into the ground" and to strengthen the nation's democracy.
"Despite being the wealthiest nation on the planet," the pair wrote, "the U.S. impoverishes its public media infrastructures, forcing public radio and television (NPR and PBS) to rely on additional tax-based outlays at the state and local level while receiving the bulk of their funding in the form of private capital from individual contributors, foundations, and corporations."
"While no silver bullet can solve the journalism crisis or heal the many ailments facing society," Pickard and Neff said "one part of the solution must be a robust public media system that ensures all Americans--especially those long excluded from news and information systems such as BIPOC communities and poor households--are able to fully participate in our democratic society."
"If we're serious about strengthening our democratic institutions, one place to start is by rebuilding local journalism," they continued. "It's past time to finally fund our public media in accordance with global democratic norms."
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.