Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

Seema Verma, then-administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, speaks to the press on November 20, 2020 in Washington, D.C.

Seema Verma, then-administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, speaks to the press on November 20, 2020 in Washington, D.C. (Photo: Tasos Katopodis/Getty Images)

Advocates Sound Alarm Over Quiet Trump Era Move That Could Further Privatize Medicare

"The Biden administration should immediately kill this toxic legacy of the former president."

Jake Johnson

A little-noticed scheme hatched in the late stages of the Trump presidency has consumer advocates and universal healthcare proponents warning about a creeping attempt to further privatize Medicare—an effort the Biden administration is being urged to stop in its tracks.

On December 3, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS)—then under the leadership of Seema Verma—unveiled an innocuous-sounding proposal titled the Geographic Direct Contracting Model (Geo) with the purported goal of delivering "Medicare beneficiaries value through better care and improved quality."

"The Biden administration needs to halt this experiment before millions of older and disabled Americans lose their right to choose traditional Medicare."
—Diane Archer, Just Care USA

But a look beyond the plan's technocratic exterior reveals what Center for Health Journalism reporter and editor Trudy Lieberman described earlier this week as a privatization model that could "take root and potentially turn every senior into a customer of a privately-run managed care organization."

"Perhaps due to the wonky nature of the discussion," Lieberman added, "the proposed change has generated almost no media coverage although it would upend the health insurance for millions of Americans."

Diane Archer of Just Care USA, in a Monday op-ed for Common Dreams, similarly characterized Geo as "an experiment... that could fully turn Medicare over to private health insurers."

"The Biden administration needs to halt this experiment before millions of older and disabled Americans lose their right to choose traditional Medicare," Archer wrote.

As the Commonwealth Fund explained in a December article on the CMS proposal, the Geo model would "have the effect of enrolling Medicare beneficiaries into a managed care–like plan; it is one of the most significant changes to the way Medicare beneficiaries receive healthcare since managed care was introduced into Medicare in the 1970s."

Commonwealth went on to break down some of the specifics of the proposed Medicare experiment:

The Geo model creates direct contracting entities (DCEs), which will be responsible for quality and costs of care for beneficiaries in traditional fee-for-service (FFS) Medicare in designated regions. DCEs can be [Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs)], health systems, healthcare provider groups, or health plans.

CMS has identified 15 regions as potential sites and will select between four and 10. All are large urban areas, many in counties with the highest per capita Medicare spending in the country. In demonstration regions, virtually all beneficiaries in traditional Medicare will be required to enroll in a DCE, including people dually eligible for Medicare and Medicaid. Guidance from CMS emphasizes that beneficiaries' out-of-pocket costs will not increase, and that cost-sharing or premiums could decrease if they use in-network providers. DCEs also may offer additional benefits, similar to Medicare Advantage plans.

The extent to which the Geo program resembles privately run Medicare Advantage plans was cause for alarm for Archer, who said that "overall, [MA] enrollees have less access to high quality hospitals and nursing homes than people in traditional Medicare and are subject to widespread and inappropriate delays and denials of care."

"Like Medicare Advantage," Archer continued, "the Trump experiment on traditional Medicare rewards insurers financially if they spend less on care, and each delay and denial contributes to larger corporate profits and jeopardizes access to care for the older and disabled Americans who need it most."

Other critics of the plan—including the National Association of ACOs—have also questioned whether it would deliver on its promise of lower costs and high-quality care for Medicare beneficiaries or merely add another layer of complexity on top of America's already-fragmented healthcare system, leading to confusion among patients and worse outcomes.

"The vast majority of beneficiaries will have no idea what a Geographic DCE is and what mandatory beneficiary participation will mean for their care and existing provider relationships," the association warned in a letter to CMS in December. "This could disrupt existing care relationships and potentially create waste in the healthcare system at a time when resources are already stretched thin as we recover from the Covid-19 pandemic."

Thankfully for Geo's opponents, the experiment is not set to begin until January 2022—meaning the Biden administration has time to alter or scrap the plan. As Lieberman pointed out, Biden's CMS recently announced that the Geo model is "currently under review."

Archer, founder of the nonprofit Medicare Rights Center, argued that if the Biden administration lets the program proceed, Geo would "make traditional Medicare a gold-mine for for-profit companies, who will make money for executives and shareholders by establishing complex administrative rules that undermine access to care and by imposing high out-of-pocket costs that discourage care."

"Allowing for-profit insurers to restrict access to care in traditional Medicare is a dangerous social experiment with the health and lives of the most vulnerable older and disabled Americans," wrote Archer. "It's bad policy, a government giveaway to Wall Street, and a betrayal of the most basic principles of Medicare."

"Congress has given every older and disabled American the right to choose traditional Medicare," Archer added. "The Biden administration should immediately kill this toxic legacy of the former president."

Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.

We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.

Ro Khanna Lays Out New Vision for American Manufacturing and Economic Progress

"Embracing a New Economic Patriotism plan isn't just about jobs. It's about unifying Americans—from the coasts to the heartland—with a shared purpose."

Brett Wilkins ·

Peace Groups Push US to Use 'All Points of Leverage' to End Saudi Blockade of Yemen

"The Biden administration must take urgent action to compel Saudi Arabia to completely lift this blockade as a humanitarian act, for the sake of millions of Yemenis in desperate need."

Jessica Corbett ·

Freelance Photographer Says He Was Fired by NYT Over Support for Palestinian Resistance

"What is taking place is a systematic effort to distort the image of Palestinian journalists as being incapable of trustworthiness and integrity, simply because we cover the human rights violations that the Palestinian people undergo on a daily basis at hands of the Israeli army."

Kenny Stancil ·

'Cruel Disregard for Life': Rights Groups Condemn Iran's Deadly Attacks on Protesters

Human Rights Watch documented lethal repression by government forces against protesters "in largely peaceful and often crowded settings, altogether killing and injuring hundreds."

Brett Wilkins ·

Permian Basin Leaking 14 Times More Methane Than EPA Estimates: Study

"Applying this estimate to all gas gathering pipelines nationwide for illustrative purposes would increase the EPA inventory estimate for the entire natural gas system by 27%," noted co-authors of a new study.

Julia Conley ·

Common Dreams Logo