Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

People participate in a Tax Day protest on April 15, 2017 in New York City. Activists in cities across the nation are marching today to call on President Donald Trump to release his tax returns. (Photo: Stephanie Keith/Getty Images)

People participate in a Tax Day protest on April 15, 2017 in New York City. (Photo: Stephanie Keith/Getty Images)

Federal Appeals Panel Unanimously Rules Manhattan DA Can Enforce Subpoena for Trump's Tax Returns

"This is a good time to remind everyone that #WePaidMore in taxes than the president, and that Americans deserve to see the full picture of Trump's financial records."

A federal appeals panel unanimously ruled Wednesday that President Donald Trump cannot block Manhattan's district attorney from enforcing a subpoena for his tax returns and other materials, delivering yet another blow to the president's effort to conceal the financial documents and possibly setting off another Supreme Court fight.

The ruling was the latest in a battle that started last year, when Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance Jr. issued a subpoena for eight years of Trump's personal and corporate tax returns and related records to his accounting firm, Mazars USA. Trump's lawyers suggested the subpoena was overly broad and politically motivated.

"We hold that none of the president's allegations, taken together or separately, are sufficient to raise a plausible inference that the subpoena was issued 'out of malice or an intent to harass,'" wrote the three-judge panel from the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan, staying a lower court's decision.

CNN explained that "the appeals court stayed the enforcement of the subpoena based on a joint agreement between the Manhattan district attorney and the president's legal team. Under that arrangement, there is a 12-day briefing schedule for Trump to ask the Supreme Court to stay the enforcement of the subpoena."

In a pair of 7-2 rulings in July, the high court determined that Vance could subpoena Trump's financial records but blocked Congress from seeing the documents. In both decisions, Trump appointees Justices Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh joined the majority while Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito dissented.

Those rulings preceded the death of liberal Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg in mid-September. While the Republican-controlled Senate aims to confirm Trump's nominee to replace her, Judge Amy Coney Barrett, before Election Day, it is unclear how the eight justices currently on the court would rule if Trump's legal team appeals.

The Justice Department is reviewing the panel's ruling, a spokesperson told the Associated Press, which pointed out that Vance's probe partly pertains to hush-money payments that the president's former lawyer Michael Cohen made to adult film actress Stormy Daniels and model Karen McDougal—who say they had affairs with Trump, which he denies—during the 2016 presidential campaign.

Reporting on the Wednesday decision, the New York Times noted that "Vance has not revealed the scope of his office's criminal inquiry, citing grand jury secrecy. But prosecutors have suggested in court papers that they are looking at a range of potential crimes, including tax and insurance fraud and falsification of business records. They have said that the tax records are central to the investigation."

The ruling comes after the Times, in late September, began publishing reports based on over two decades of Trump's closely guarded tax return data. The information obtained by the newspaper contradicted the president's presentation of himself as a self-made billionaire and revealed tax avoidance practices that some critics have speculated could eventually land Trump behind bars.

The campaign of Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden has seized on the explosive Times reporting to contrast the former vice president with Trump and a coalition of progressive groups launched We Paid More, a new effort to highlight an "utterly rigged" tax system that enables the wealthy president to pay less in federal income taxes than nurses, teachers, and many other workers.


Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
We need your help.

Support progressive journalism.

Common Dreams is not your average news site. We don't survive on clicks or advertising dollars. We rely entirely on your support. And without it, our independent progressive journalism simply wouldn’t exist. Every gift of every amount matters.

Join the fight and support our common dreams today.

Sinema Op-Ed Defending Senate Filibuster Slammed as 'Delusional'

Rep. Mondaire Jones said Sinema is effectively arguing that "we should let Republicans destroy democracy now because at some indeterminate time in the future they may try again."

Jake Johnson, staff writer ·


Progressives Say 'Do What the People Want and Tax the Rich' to Pay for Infrastructure

"It is obvious that if we're going to address the needs of working families in this country, we need revenue," says Sen. Bernie Sanders, "and one way that we get that revenue is by demanding that the wealthiest people, the largest corporations are paying their fair share."

Jessica Corbett, staff writer ·


Doctors Without Borders Calls on BioNTech to Share Vaccine Tech With World

"The faster companies share the know-how, the faster we can put an end to this pandemic."

Andrea Germanos, staff writer ·


Over 30,000 US Veterans of Post-9/11 Wars Have Killed Themselves Since 2001

"As we come closer to the twentieth anniversary of the September 11th attacks, we must reflect on the mental health cost of the Global War on Terror."

Julia Conley, staff writer ·


Sunrise Ends 400-Mile Climate March With Arrests at Ted Cruz's House

The Gulf South marchers demand that Congress and the Biden White House pass bold climate jobs legislation, including a bill to create a Civilian Climate Corps.

Jessica Corbett, staff writer ·