Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-MN) (3rd L) listens during a news conference at the U.S. Capitol January 4, 2019 in Washington, DC. (Photo: Alex Wong/Getty Images)

U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-MN) (3rd L) listens during a news conference at the U.S. Capitol January 4, 2019 in Washington, DC. (Photo:  Alex Wong/Getty Images)

Rep. Ilhan Omar Asks Judge to 'Show Compassion' for Hateful Man Who Threatened to Put Bullet in Her Head

"Who are we as a nation if we respond to threats of political retribution with retribution ourselves?"

After a man accused of threatening her life pled guilty to the crime in a U.S. District Court, Rep. Ilhan Omar on Tuesday released publicly a letter she wrote asking the federal judge presiding over the case to "show compassion" in his sentencing.

Patrick W. Carlineo Jr., a 55-year-old man from upstate New York, pled guilty on Monday on gun charges and for threatening to murder Omar in phone calls he made to her congressional office in March of this year. But in her letter to Judge Frank P. Geraci Jr., Omar said that while the charges were quite serious she did not think that an overly punitive sentence was the answer.

"The answer to hate is not more hate; it is compassion," Omar wrote.

"Who are we as a nation," her letter asks, "if we respond to threats of political retribution with retribution ourselves?"

The Minnesota Democrat posted the letter in its entirety on social media:

The formal complaint against Carlineo Jr. charged that he cited Omar being a Muslim before calling her a "terrorist" and threatening to "put a bullet in her [expletive] skull" when he called her office.

In her letter, Omar argues that punishing Carlineo "with a lengthy prison sentence or a burdensome financial fine would not rehabilitate him" or repair the harm he caused. Likely, Omar said, such a sentence "would only increase his anger and resentment."

Omar has been a vocal critic of mass incarceration during her first term in Congress, calling the system which locks up more than two million people "a scourge on this country."

In her letter, Omar said the U.S. must address the "systemic alienation" that victimizes people who often go on to commit acts of violence "through community reintegration and social services."

Carlineo's crime, Omar pointed out, is just a single example of the hate speech and political violence which "are an increasing feature in our public sphere."

"We will not defeat it with anger and exclusion," Omar wrote. "We will defeat it with compassion."

The congresswoman's letter garnered applause from progressives and critics of the U.S. prison system including Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.).

"I'm amazed at this letter from Ilhan Omar, asking for mercy for the man who was just convicted of threatening to assassinate her," tweeted Slate writer and podcast host Aymann Ismail.

Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
We need your help.

Support progressive journalism.

Common Dreams is not your average news site. We don't survive on clicks or advertising dollars. We rely entirely on your support. And without it, our independent progressive journalism simply wouldn’t exist. Every gift of every amount matters.

Join the fight and support our common dreams today.

Ocasio-Cortez Says 'Elephant in the Room' Is Senate Democrats Blocking Their Own Party's Agenda

"The argument that we need to make here," the New York Democrat said of bipartisanship's dead end, "is that it's worth going it alone if we can do more for working people in this country."

Jon Queally, staff writer ·

On Climate and Covid-19 Emergencies, G7 Judged a 'Colossal Failure' for All the World to See

"Never in the history of the G7 has there been a bigger gap between their actions and the needs of the world. In the face of these challenges the G7 have chosen to cook the books on vaccines and continue to cook the planet."

Jon Queally, staff writer ·

NYC Mayoral Candidate Eric Adams Rebuked for 'Dangerous' 400-Students-to-1-Teacher Theory

"Defunding schools to the point that we have a 400:1 student-to-teacher ratio so we can bankroll another huge expansion in an already-multibillion dollar police budget," said Rep. Ocasio-Cortez, "is how you build a school-to-prison pipeline."

Jon Queally, staff writer ·

Lack of Patent Waiver Would Add Over $70 Billion to Cost of Vaccinating World: Oxfam

Most of that money, said a spokesperson for the group, "will go directly into the pockets" of Big Pharma shareholders.

Jon Queally, staff writer ·

Darnella Frazier Receives Pulitzer Special Citation 'for Courageously Recording the Murder of George Floyd'

"Without Darnella, Derek Chauvin never would have been tried and George Floyd would have been blamed by the state for his own death."

Brett Wilkins, staff writer ·