SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE NEWSLETTER
Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
U.S. President Donald Trump speaks as he arrives at Naval Air Station Joint Reserve Base Fort Worth in Texas on Oct. 17. (Photo: Nicholas Kamm/AFP/Getty Images)
'Nothing Could Be Done': Trump Lawyer Argues President Could Shoot Someone on 5th Avenue and Avoid Consequences While in Office
"There is no such thing as presidential immunity for tax returns... they're making this up."
Oct 23, 2019
Lawyers for President Donald Trump Wednesday argued in a Manhattan courtroom that were the president to shoot someone on 5th Avenue in New York City, he could not be prosecuted while in office because of presidential immunity.
"Trump's lawyers openly declared that Trump is above all laws, including murder," tweeted Rep. Bill Pascrale (D-N.J.) in response to the news.
The exchange came during a hearing on the president's tax returns, which Manhattan D.A. Cyrus Vance Jr. is attempting to obtain to see if Trump illegally paid to silence people with damaging information to his presidential campaign in 2016. Judge Denny Chin used Trump shooting someone in broad daylight on 5th Avenue--an invocation of a Trump brag on the campaign trail in 2016--as an example of the limits of presidential immunity from prosecution.
But Trump lawyer William S. Consovoy told the court that, in fact, the president would escape prosecution as long as he were in office.
\u201cHere's Donald Trump's lawyer claiming the president cannot even be investigated, let alone prosecuted, for committing a crime while in office, even if he murdered someone in public.\u201d— Timothy Burke (@Timothy Burke) 1571843048
Chin: What's your view on the Fifth Avenue example? Local authorities couldn't investigate? They couldn't do anything about it?
Consovoy: Once the president is removed from office, any local authority, this is not a permanent immunity.
Chin: Well I'm talking about while in office.
Consovoy: No.
Chin: Nothing could be done? That's your position?
Consovoy: That is correct.
The D.A.'s office was not amused, according to The Washington Post:
Carey Dunne, general counsel from the Manhattan District Attorney's office, told the court "there is no such thing as presidential immunity for tax returns" and "they're making this up."
"[President Trump] may view them as embarrassing or sensitive but tax returns do in fact get subpoenaed all the time in financial investigations," Dunne said.
Legally, Vox's Ian Millhiser pointed out, Consovoy's assertion is incorrect:
To be clear, Consovoy is not correct about the law. As the Supreme Court explained in Clinton v. Jones (1997), "it is settled law that the separation-of-powers doctrine does not bar every exercise of jurisdiction over the President of the United States. Moreover, the Court added that "we have never suggested that the President, or any other official, has an immunity that extends beyond the scope of any action taken in an official capacity."
Thus, because murdering people on Fifth Avenue is not part of the president's official duties, Trump's immunity argument would likely fail. Similarly, because the financial information sought by prosecutors also does not relate to Trump's official duties, Trump's claim of immunity in Vance is weak.
A number of observers expressed concern that the president believes he is above the law, whatever the legal reality.
"This is not a joke," said journalist Judd Legum. "This is real life."
An Urgent Message From Our Co-Founder
Dear Common Dreams reader, The U.S. is on a fast track to authoritarianism like nothing I've ever seen. Meanwhile, corporate news outlets are utterly capitulating to Trump, twisting their coverage to avoid drawing his ire while lining up to stuff cash in his pockets. That's why I believe that Common Dreams is doing the best and most consequential reporting that we've ever done. Our small but mighty team is a progressive reporting powerhouse, covering the news every day that the corporate media never will. Our mission has always been simple: To inform. To inspire. And to ignite change for the common good. Now here's the key piece that I want all our readers to understand: None of this would be possible without your financial support. That's not just some fundraising cliche. It's the absolute and literal truth. We don't accept corporate advertising and never will. We don't have a paywall because we don't think people should be blocked from critical news based on their ability to pay. Everything we do is funded by the donations of readers like you. Will you donate now to help power the nonprofit, independent reporting of Common Dreams? Thank you for being a vital member of our community. Together, we can keep independent journalism alive when it’s needed most. - Craig Brown, Co-founder |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
Lawyers for President Donald Trump Wednesday argued in a Manhattan courtroom that were the president to shoot someone on 5th Avenue in New York City, he could not be prosecuted while in office because of presidential immunity.
"Trump's lawyers openly declared that Trump is above all laws, including murder," tweeted Rep. Bill Pascrale (D-N.J.) in response to the news.
The exchange came during a hearing on the president's tax returns, which Manhattan D.A. Cyrus Vance Jr. is attempting to obtain to see if Trump illegally paid to silence people with damaging information to his presidential campaign in 2016. Judge Denny Chin used Trump shooting someone in broad daylight on 5th Avenue--an invocation of a Trump brag on the campaign trail in 2016--as an example of the limits of presidential immunity from prosecution.
But Trump lawyer William S. Consovoy told the court that, in fact, the president would escape prosecution as long as he were in office.
\u201cHere's Donald Trump's lawyer claiming the president cannot even be investigated, let alone prosecuted, for committing a crime while in office, even if he murdered someone in public.\u201d— Timothy Burke (@Timothy Burke) 1571843048
Chin: What's your view on the Fifth Avenue example? Local authorities couldn't investigate? They couldn't do anything about it?
Consovoy: Once the president is removed from office, any local authority, this is not a permanent immunity.
Chin: Well I'm talking about while in office.
Consovoy: No.
Chin: Nothing could be done? That's your position?
Consovoy: That is correct.
The D.A.'s office was not amused, according to The Washington Post:
Carey Dunne, general counsel from the Manhattan District Attorney's office, told the court "there is no such thing as presidential immunity for tax returns" and "they're making this up."
"[President Trump] may view them as embarrassing or sensitive but tax returns do in fact get subpoenaed all the time in financial investigations," Dunne said.
Legally, Vox's Ian Millhiser pointed out, Consovoy's assertion is incorrect:
To be clear, Consovoy is not correct about the law. As the Supreme Court explained in Clinton v. Jones (1997), "it is settled law that the separation-of-powers doctrine does not bar every exercise of jurisdiction over the President of the United States. Moreover, the Court added that "we have never suggested that the President, or any other official, has an immunity that extends beyond the scope of any action taken in an official capacity."
Thus, because murdering people on Fifth Avenue is not part of the president's official duties, Trump's immunity argument would likely fail. Similarly, because the financial information sought by prosecutors also does not relate to Trump's official duties, Trump's claim of immunity in Vance is weak.
A number of observers expressed concern that the president believes he is above the law, whatever the legal reality.
"This is not a joke," said journalist Judd Legum. "This is real life."
Lawyers for President Donald Trump Wednesday argued in a Manhattan courtroom that were the president to shoot someone on 5th Avenue in New York City, he could not be prosecuted while in office because of presidential immunity.
"Trump's lawyers openly declared that Trump is above all laws, including murder," tweeted Rep. Bill Pascrale (D-N.J.) in response to the news.
The exchange came during a hearing on the president's tax returns, which Manhattan D.A. Cyrus Vance Jr. is attempting to obtain to see if Trump illegally paid to silence people with damaging information to his presidential campaign in 2016. Judge Denny Chin used Trump shooting someone in broad daylight on 5th Avenue--an invocation of a Trump brag on the campaign trail in 2016--as an example of the limits of presidential immunity from prosecution.
But Trump lawyer William S. Consovoy told the court that, in fact, the president would escape prosecution as long as he were in office.
\u201cHere's Donald Trump's lawyer claiming the president cannot even be investigated, let alone prosecuted, for committing a crime while in office, even if he murdered someone in public.\u201d— Timothy Burke (@Timothy Burke) 1571843048
Chin: What's your view on the Fifth Avenue example? Local authorities couldn't investigate? They couldn't do anything about it?
Consovoy: Once the president is removed from office, any local authority, this is not a permanent immunity.
Chin: Well I'm talking about while in office.
Consovoy: No.
Chin: Nothing could be done? That's your position?
Consovoy: That is correct.
The D.A.'s office was not amused, according to The Washington Post:
Carey Dunne, general counsel from the Manhattan District Attorney's office, told the court "there is no such thing as presidential immunity for tax returns" and "they're making this up."
"[President Trump] may view them as embarrassing or sensitive but tax returns do in fact get subpoenaed all the time in financial investigations," Dunne said.
Legally, Vox's Ian Millhiser pointed out, Consovoy's assertion is incorrect:
To be clear, Consovoy is not correct about the law. As the Supreme Court explained in Clinton v. Jones (1997), "it is settled law that the separation-of-powers doctrine does not bar every exercise of jurisdiction over the President of the United States. Moreover, the Court added that "we have never suggested that the President, or any other official, has an immunity that extends beyond the scope of any action taken in an official capacity."
Thus, because murdering people on Fifth Avenue is not part of the president's official duties, Trump's immunity argument would likely fail. Similarly, because the financial information sought by prosecutors also does not relate to Trump's official duties, Trump's claim of immunity in Vance is weak.
A number of observers expressed concern that the president believes he is above the law, whatever the legal reality.
"This is not a joke," said journalist Judd Legum. "This is real life."
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.