SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE NEWSLETTER
Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
Axios' Jonathan Swan (l) and Jim VandeHei interview Donald Trump in the White House for their upcoming show on HBO. (Screenshot: Axios/YouTube)
A Blatant Lie and 'Obvious Stunt': Trump Claims He Can End 14th Amendment Guarantee of Birthright Citizenship by Presidential Fiat
"To respond as if he's ending birthright citizenship because he told an outlet he is ending birthright citizenship is to allow him to be our assignment editor," said journalist Sam Stein of the Axios interview. "It's an obvious stunt."
Oct 30, 2018
Denouncing the U.S. right to birthright citizenship--guaranteed by the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution--as "ridiculous," President Donald Trump has falsely claimed that he has the power to subvert that guarantee by presidential fiat - his latest effort to mainstream a noxious lie and xenophobic trope while also furthering what critics call his authoritarian approach to governance by once more exploiting certain members of the White House press corps willing to carry his water for him.
"[Axios'] Jonathan Swan is an operative of the Trump White House and all his 'scoops' are really just messaging that this fascist administration wants disseminated to the public." --Sam Sacks, DC SentinelInjected into a White House interview by Axios' Jonathan Swan, a reporter who prides himself on receiving inside information from anonymous top-level Trump officials, the president appeared surprised (or feigned surprise) that anybody knew his internal desire and plan to end birthright citizenship but said "it will happen" and that "now they're saying I can do it just with an executive order."
It's not clear who Trump is referring to when he says "they," but it's reasonable to assume--given that Trump says he didn't think anybody else knew about it--that it's the very same staff person or people who told Swan to ask him the question in the first place.
Watch:
But pushing back against the idea that Swan had somehow scooped a new White House proposal, other journalists warned that Swan was playing--wittingly or not--right into Trump's hands by letting the president and his White House staff put out into the world another piece of red meat for Trump's racist, xenophobic base.
\u201cGuys. Trump can\u2019t terminate amendments via executive order. To respond as if he\u2019s ending birthright citizenship because he told an outlet he is ending birthright citizenship is to allow him to be our assignment editor. It\u2019s an obvious stunt\u201d— Sam Stein (@Sam Stein) 1540894798
\u201cNews organizations shouldn\u2019t tweet quotes that are lies without labeling them lies. Many other countries, including Canada and Mexico, have birthright citizenship.\u201d— James Surowiecki (@James Surowiecki) 1540901241
\u201c30 countries offer birthright citizenship. https://t.co/J76DwMIige\u201d— Dan Froomkin/PressWatchers.org (@Dan Froomkin/PressWatchers.org) 1540901381
Sam Sacks, reporter and co-founder of the DC Sentinel, minced no words. "Jonathan Swan is an operative of the Trump White House and all his 'scoops' are really just messaging that this fascist administration wants disseminated to the public," Sacks said in a tweeted response to the report. "Much like Fox News, except Axios caters to beltway elites that have long enabled this extremism."
\u201cAxios enabling fascism. Notice how Jonathan Swan does a lot of the heavy lifting for Trump\u2019s racist and unconstitutional proposal by prefacing question with: \u201cSome legal scholars believe you can get rid of birthright citizenship without changing the constitution.\u201d\u201d— Sam Sacks (@Sam Sacks) 1540899182
And that wasn't the end of fellow journalists criticizing both the nature and implication of the reporting. Matthew Yglesia of Vox was among those pointing out how Trump's false legal claims went unchallenged by both Swan and VandeHei. The legal practice of birthright citizenship, also known by the Latin Jus Soli (or right of the soil), explained Yglesias, "is standard procedure in most Western Hemisphere countries and the rule Trump says nobody follows can be found in such exotic locales as Canada and Mexico." Also a very clear mistruth, he added, "The President cannot change the Constitution by executive order."
An Urgent Message From Our Co-Founder
Dear Common Dreams reader, The U.S. is on a fast track to authoritarianism like nothing I've ever seen. Meanwhile, corporate news outlets are utterly capitulating to Trump, twisting their coverage to avoid drawing his ire while lining up to stuff cash in his pockets. That's why I believe that Common Dreams is doing the best and most consequential reporting that we've ever done. Our small but mighty team is a progressive reporting powerhouse, covering the news every day that the corporate media never will. Our mission has always been simple: To inform. To inspire. And to ignite change for the common good. Now here's the key piece that I want all our readers to understand: None of this would be possible without your financial support. That's not just some fundraising cliche. It's the absolute and literal truth. We don't accept corporate advertising and never will. We don't have a paywall because we don't think people should be blocked from critical news based on their ability to pay. Everything we do is funded by the donations of readers like you. Will you donate now to help power the nonprofit, independent reporting of Common Dreams? Thank you for being a vital member of our community. Together, we can keep independent journalism alive when it’s needed most. - Craig Brown, Co-founder |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
Denouncing the U.S. right to birthright citizenship--guaranteed by the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution--as "ridiculous," President Donald Trump has falsely claimed that he has the power to subvert that guarantee by presidential fiat - his latest effort to mainstream a noxious lie and xenophobic trope while also furthering what critics call his authoritarian approach to governance by once more exploiting certain members of the White House press corps willing to carry his water for him.
"[Axios'] Jonathan Swan is an operative of the Trump White House and all his 'scoops' are really just messaging that this fascist administration wants disseminated to the public." --Sam Sacks, DC SentinelInjected into a White House interview by Axios' Jonathan Swan, a reporter who prides himself on receiving inside information from anonymous top-level Trump officials, the president appeared surprised (or feigned surprise) that anybody knew his internal desire and plan to end birthright citizenship but said "it will happen" and that "now they're saying I can do it just with an executive order."
It's not clear who Trump is referring to when he says "they," but it's reasonable to assume--given that Trump says he didn't think anybody else knew about it--that it's the very same staff person or people who told Swan to ask him the question in the first place.
Watch:
But pushing back against the idea that Swan had somehow scooped a new White House proposal, other journalists warned that Swan was playing--wittingly or not--right into Trump's hands by letting the president and his White House staff put out into the world another piece of red meat for Trump's racist, xenophobic base.
\u201cGuys. Trump can\u2019t terminate amendments via executive order. To respond as if he\u2019s ending birthright citizenship because he told an outlet he is ending birthright citizenship is to allow him to be our assignment editor. It\u2019s an obvious stunt\u201d— Sam Stein (@Sam Stein) 1540894798
\u201cNews organizations shouldn\u2019t tweet quotes that are lies without labeling them lies. Many other countries, including Canada and Mexico, have birthright citizenship.\u201d— James Surowiecki (@James Surowiecki) 1540901241
\u201c30 countries offer birthright citizenship. https://t.co/J76DwMIige\u201d— Dan Froomkin/PressWatchers.org (@Dan Froomkin/PressWatchers.org) 1540901381
Sam Sacks, reporter and co-founder of the DC Sentinel, minced no words. "Jonathan Swan is an operative of the Trump White House and all his 'scoops' are really just messaging that this fascist administration wants disseminated to the public," Sacks said in a tweeted response to the report. "Much like Fox News, except Axios caters to beltway elites that have long enabled this extremism."
\u201cAxios enabling fascism. Notice how Jonathan Swan does a lot of the heavy lifting for Trump\u2019s racist and unconstitutional proposal by prefacing question with: \u201cSome legal scholars believe you can get rid of birthright citizenship without changing the constitution.\u201d\u201d— Sam Sacks (@Sam Sacks) 1540899182
And that wasn't the end of fellow journalists criticizing both the nature and implication of the reporting. Matthew Yglesia of Vox was among those pointing out how Trump's false legal claims went unchallenged by both Swan and VandeHei. The legal practice of birthright citizenship, also known by the Latin Jus Soli (or right of the soil), explained Yglesias, "is standard procedure in most Western Hemisphere countries and the rule Trump says nobody follows can be found in such exotic locales as Canada and Mexico." Also a very clear mistruth, he added, "The President cannot change the Constitution by executive order."
Denouncing the U.S. right to birthright citizenship--guaranteed by the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution--as "ridiculous," President Donald Trump has falsely claimed that he has the power to subvert that guarantee by presidential fiat - his latest effort to mainstream a noxious lie and xenophobic trope while also furthering what critics call his authoritarian approach to governance by once more exploiting certain members of the White House press corps willing to carry his water for him.
"[Axios'] Jonathan Swan is an operative of the Trump White House and all his 'scoops' are really just messaging that this fascist administration wants disseminated to the public." --Sam Sacks, DC SentinelInjected into a White House interview by Axios' Jonathan Swan, a reporter who prides himself on receiving inside information from anonymous top-level Trump officials, the president appeared surprised (or feigned surprise) that anybody knew his internal desire and plan to end birthright citizenship but said "it will happen" and that "now they're saying I can do it just with an executive order."
It's not clear who Trump is referring to when he says "they," but it's reasonable to assume--given that Trump says he didn't think anybody else knew about it--that it's the very same staff person or people who told Swan to ask him the question in the first place.
Watch:
But pushing back against the idea that Swan had somehow scooped a new White House proposal, other journalists warned that Swan was playing--wittingly or not--right into Trump's hands by letting the president and his White House staff put out into the world another piece of red meat for Trump's racist, xenophobic base.
\u201cGuys. Trump can\u2019t terminate amendments via executive order. To respond as if he\u2019s ending birthright citizenship because he told an outlet he is ending birthright citizenship is to allow him to be our assignment editor. It\u2019s an obvious stunt\u201d— Sam Stein (@Sam Stein) 1540894798
\u201cNews organizations shouldn\u2019t tweet quotes that are lies without labeling them lies. Many other countries, including Canada and Mexico, have birthright citizenship.\u201d— James Surowiecki (@James Surowiecki) 1540901241
\u201c30 countries offer birthright citizenship. https://t.co/J76DwMIige\u201d— Dan Froomkin/PressWatchers.org (@Dan Froomkin/PressWatchers.org) 1540901381
Sam Sacks, reporter and co-founder of the DC Sentinel, minced no words. "Jonathan Swan is an operative of the Trump White House and all his 'scoops' are really just messaging that this fascist administration wants disseminated to the public," Sacks said in a tweeted response to the report. "Much like Fox News, except Axios caters to beltway elites that have long enabled this extremism."
\u201cAxios enabling fascism. Notice how Jonathan Swan does a lot of the heavy lifting for Trump\u2019s racist and unconstitutional proposal by prefacing question with: \u201cSome legal scholars believe you can get rid of birthright citizenship without changing the constitution.\u201d\u201d— Sam Sacks (@Sam Sacks) 1540899182
And that wasn't the end of fellow journalists criticizing both the nature and implication of the reporting. Matthew Yglesia of Vox was among those pointing out how Trump's false legal claims went unchallenged by both Swan and VandeHei. The legal practice of birthright citizenship, also known by the Latin Jus Soli (or right of the soil), explained Yglesias, "is standard procedure in most Western Hemisphere countries and the rule Trump says nobody follows can be found in such exotic locales as Canada and Mexico." Also a very clear mistruth, he added, "The President cannot change the Constitution by executive order."
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.