Class Action Lawsuit Hovers Over 'Draconian Nature' of Solitary Confinement
Federal judge gives status to suit filed on behalf of prisoners at Pelican Bay
A federal judge on Monday gave class action status to lawsuit brought forth by men at a notorious California prison who are challenging their prolonged solitary confinement.
The inmates, who have spent over a decade in Pelican Bay State Prison's Security Housing Unit (SHU), charge that the treatment violates their Eighth Amendment rights against cruel and unusual punishment, and, because their SHU placement is not subject to meaningful review, their rights to due process are violated as well. The lawsuit was filed by the Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR).
SHU inmates are locked in windowless, 11'7" x 7'7" cells for 22 1/2 to 24 hours a day. They are allowed no phone calls nor contact visits. They may be denied medical care.
Gabriel Reyes described his SHU confinement as "a living tomb":
Unless you have lived it, you cannot imagine what it feels like to be by yourself, between four cold walls, with little concept of time, no one to confide in, and only a pillow for comfort -- for years on end. It is a living tomb.
Over 500 men have in solitary at Pelican Bay for over a decade, and nearly 80 have spent over two decades there.
A Mother Jones series included "Pelican Bay, the state's first and most notorious supermax," as among the nation's 10 worst prisons, and a 2012 investigation for the magazine by Shane Bauer -- who was held in solitary in an Iranian prison -- detailed how evidence that could be used to send inmates into solitary at the prison has included possession of Machiavelli's The Prince or "[a]ppearing in a group picture with one validated gang associate. . . even if that person wasn't validated at the time."
"Since their 2011 hunger strikes, hundreds of prisoners at the Pelican Bay SHU - and across California - have stood together in solidarity to protest inhumane conditions and broken policies they've been subjected to for decades," CCR Staff Attorney Alexis Agathocleous said in a statement. "This case has always been about the constitutional violations suffered by all prisoners at the SHU, so it is only appropriate that it proceed as a class action."
The class action status allows the suit to cover hundreds of inmates at the prison who have been in solitary for over 10 years, and could have broader implications.
"This would really be the first case about whether the confinement itself is cruel and unusual punishment and about who can be legitimately confined in this way, given the draconian nature of the confinement," Jules Lobel, a constitutional law professor at the University of Pittsburgh and the president of CCR, told the New York Times.
Amidst last year's California-wide prisoner hunger strike against the cruelty of solitary, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on torture, Juan E. Mendez, decried the practice as torture.
"Even if solitary confinement is applied for short periods of time, it often causes mental and physical suffering or humiliation, amounting to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, and if the resulting pain or sufferings are severe, solitary confinement even amounts to torture," Mendez stated.
"I urge the U.S. Government to adopt concrete measures to eliminate the use of prolonged or indefinite solitary confinement under all circumstances," Mendez added.
__________________________________
We are at a crossroads
This country and this world are at a monumental crossroads. In a few short weeks, US voters will have an opportunity to beat back the forces of fascism and confront the billionaires who are rigging the economy, our media system, and our democracy, making it increasingly impossible for ordinary people to get by. We’re not just talking about the election. We’re talking about what must be done once these fascist elements are vanquished from power. We need a bolder set of solutions than what either major party has so far been willing to offer and a working-class movement ready to fight like hell for it. Trump didn't emerge from nowhere. The conditions that fueled MAGA authoritarianism were created by decades of radical neoliberal economic policies and a corrupt political system dominated by corporate interests. They slashed taxes on the super-rich, promising that the benefits would trickle down. They said giveaways to the corporate titans would make life more affordable for the rest of us. It was all bullshit. And when a bitter, betrayed populace searches for someone to blame, right-wing demagogues have little trouble finding scapegoats. People know when they're being lied to, but you won't hear any of this from the corporate media. Only independent journalism—powered and funded by people who believe in building a better world—can deliver truly trustworthy daily news. Our Fall Campaign is underway, and we need your help. To power our newsroom through the rest of the year, we need to raise $125,000 by midnight on October 31. So if you share our vision, please contribute whatever you can to sustain our work. |
A federal judge on Monday gave class action status to lawsuit brought forth by men at a notorious California prison who are challenging their prolonged solitary confinement.
The inmates, who have spent over a decade in Pelican Bay State Prison's Security Housing Unit (SHU), charge that the treatment violates their Eighth Amendment rights against cruel and unusual punishment, and, because their SHU placement is not subject to meaningful review, their rights to due process are violated as well. The lawsuit was filed by the Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR).
SHU inmates are locked in windowless, 11'7" x 7'7" cells for 22 1/2 to 24 hours a day. They are allowed no phone calls nor contact visits. They may be denied medical care.
Gabriel Reyes described his SHU confinement as "a living tomb":
Unless you have lived it, you cannot imagine what it feels like to be by yourself, between four cold walls, with little concept of time, no one to confide in, and only a pillow for comfort -- for years on end. It is a living tomb.
Over 500 men have in solitary at Pelican Bay for over a decade, and nearly 80 have spent over two decades there.
A Mother Jones series included "Pelican Bay, the state's first and most notorious supermax," as among the nation's 10 worst prisons, and a 2012 investigation for the magazine by Shane Bauer -- who was held in solitary in an Iranian prison -- detailed how evidence that could be used to send inmates into solitary at the prison has included possession of Machiavelli's The Prince or "[a]ppearing in a group picture with one validated gang associate. . . even if that person wasn't validated at the time."
"Since their 2011 hunger strikes, hundreds of prisoners at the Pelican Bay SHU - and across California - have stood together in solidarity to protest inhumane conditions and broken policies they've been subjected to for decades," CCR Staff Attorney Alexis Agathocleous said in a statement. "This case has always been about the constitutional violations suffered by all prisoners at the SHU, so it is only appropriate that it proceed as a class action."
The class action status allows the suit to cover hundreds of inmates at the prison who have been in solitary for over 10 years, and could have broader implications.
"This would really be the first case about whether the confinement itself is cruel and unusual punishment and about who can be legitimately confined in this way, given the draconian nature of the confinement," Jules Lobel, a constitutional law professor at the University of Pittsburgh and the president of CCR, told the New York Times.
Amidst last year's California-wide prisoner hunger strike against the cruelty of solitary, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on torture, Juan E. Mendez, decried the practice as torture.
"Even if solitary confinement is applied for short periods of time, it often causes mental and physical suffering or humiliation, amounting to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, and if the resulting pain or sufferings are severe, solitary confinement even amounts to torture," Mendez stated.
"I urge the U.S. Government to adopt concrete measures to eliminate the use of prolonged or indefinite solitary confinement under all circumstances," Mendez added.
__________________________________
A federal judge on Monday gave class action status to lawsuit brought forth by men at a notorious California prison who are challenging their prolonged solitary confinement.
The inmates, who have spent over a decade in Pelican Bay State Prison's Security Housing Unit (SHU), charge that the treatment violates their Eighth Amendment rights against cruel and unusual punishment, and, because their SHU placement is not subject to meaningful review, their rights to due process are violated as well. The lawsuit was filed by the Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR).
SHU inmates are locked in windowless, 11'7" x 7'7" cells for 22 1/2 to 24 hours a day. They are allowed no phone calls nor contact visits. They may be denied medical care.
Gabriel Reyes described his SHU confinement as "a living tomb":
Unless you have lived it, you cannot imagine what it feels like to be by yourself, between four cold walls, with little concept of time, no one to confide in, and only a pillow for comfort -- for years on end. It is a living tomb.
Over 500 men have in solitary at Pelican Bay for over a decade, and nearly 80 have spent over two decades there.
A Mother Jones series included "Pelican Bay, the state's first and most notorious supermax," as among the nation's 10 worst prisons, and a 2012 investigation for the magazine by Shane Bauer -- who was held in solitary in an Iranian prison -- detailed how evidence that could be used to send inmates into solitary at the prison has included possession of Machiavelli's The Prince or "[a]ppearing in a group picture with one validated gang associate. . . even if that person wasn't validated at the time."
"Since their 2011 hunger strikes, hundreds of prisoners at the Pelican Bay SHU - and across California - have stood together in solidarity to protest inhumane conditions and broken policies they've been subjected to for decades," CCR Staff Attorney Alexis Agathocleous said in a statement. "This case has always been about the constitutional violations suffered by all prisoners at the SHU, so it is only appropriate that it proceed as a class action."
The class action status allows the suit to cover hundreds of inmates at the prison who have been in solitary for over 10 years, and could have broader implications.
"This would really be the first case about whether the confinement itself is cruel and unusual punishment and about who can be legitimately confined in this way, given the draconian nature of the confinement," Jules Lobel, a constitutional law professor at the University of Pittsburgh and the president of CCR, told the New York Times.
Amidst last year's California-wide prisoner hunger strike against the cruelty of solitary, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on torture, Juan E. Mendez, decried the practice as torture.
"Even if solitary confinement is applied for short periods of time, it often causes mental and physical suffering or humiliation, amounting to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, and if the resulting pain or sufferings are severe, solitary confinement even amounts to torture," Mendez stated.
"I urge the U.S. Government to adopt concrete measures to eliminate the use of prolonged or indefinite solitary confinement under all circumstances," Mendez added.
__________________________________