Iraqi government will push to appeal a US court ruling dismissing
charges of murder against five security guards of the private
Blackwater firm, an official has told Al Jazeera.
Saad al-Muttalibi, an adviser to the Iraqi council of ministers,
said on Friday that if the guards did not receive a just sentence for
the killing of 14 Iraqis in 2007, the issue would complicate relations
between Iraq and the United States.
matter will be appealed in the American court and if not resolved
correctly, this will definitely add another strain on the relationship
between Iraq and the United States," he said.
"The legality or the procedures of the court case should not stop
the criminals from facing justice and receiving a just sentence.
is very bad ... for the overall look of the United States outside its
borders. It's very important for the Americans to realise that this
will work against their interests in Iraq and other places."
Ali al-Dabbagh, the Iraqi government spokesman, said in a statement:
"The Iraqi government will follow up on this issue in strength and
resolution to bring those murderers of Blackwater to accountability in
order to return the rights of iraqi people who are the victims of this
crime." He said "the investigations carried out by the
specialised Iraqi authorities confirmed with no doubt that the guards
of Blackwater company have committed a criminal murder act and they
have violated the combat environment rule to use force while there was
no threat against them".
Promise of immunity
Ricardo Urbina, a district judge, dismissed the charges against the
five men on Thursday, saying US justice department prosecutors
improperly built their case on sworn statements that had been given
under a promise of immunity.
Urbina said the government's explanations were "contradictory, unbelievable and lacking in credibility".
The September 2007 shooting in Baghdad's busy Nisour Square left at
least 14 Iraqis dead and inflamed anti-American sentiment abroad.
The Iraqi government wanted the guards to stand trial in Iraq and
officials there said they would closely watch how the US judicial
system handled the case.
Dean Boyd, a spokesman for the US justice department, said the department was "obviously disappointed by the decision". Prosecutors
can appeal the 90-page ruling and Boyd said the department was "still
in the process of reviewing the opinion and considering our options".
Al Jazeera's Rosiland Jordan explained that the judge did say that
the case can be brought back to court without prejudice but it was
going to be difficult for the justice department to build the case from
scratch without using the defendants' statements.
Blackwater Worldwide, which had been hired to guard US diplomats in
Iraq at the time, has since changed its management and name to Xe
Despite a string of investigations following the deadly shooting and
in spite of an Iraqi government ban on the company, the US state
department extended a contract with a subsidiary of the firm in
September to continue providing security to US diplomats in the country.
The five guards, Donald Ball, Dustin
Heard, Evan Liberty, Nick Slatten and Paul Slough, all formerly in the
US military, had been charged with manslaughter and weapons charges,
which carried mandatory 30-year prison terms.
It was unclear what the ruling means for a sixth Blackwater guard,
Jeremy Ridgeway, who had pleaded guilty to killing one Iraqi and
Defence lawyers said the guards were thrilled by the ruling after more than two years of scrutiny.
"It's tremendously gratifying to see the court allow us to celebrate
the New Year the way it has," said lawyer Bill Coffield, who represents
"It really invigorates your belief in our court system."
Ball's lawyer, Steven McCool, said "it feels like the weight of the world has been lifted off" his client's shoulders".
"Here's a guy that's a decorated war hero who we maintain should never have been charged in the first place," he added.
Urbina's ruling does not say whether the shooting was proper, only
that the government improperly used evidence to build the case.
The guards claimed to have acted in self-defence after a convoy they were protecting near Nisour Square came under attack.
Witnesses, however, said the men unleashed an unprovoked attack on civilians using machine guns and grenades.
After the shooting, the US state department had ordered the guards to explain what happened.
Investigators promised the men that their statements were to be used
only for the internal inquiry and would not be used in a criminal case.
Such limited immunity deals are common in police departments so
officers involved in shootings cannot hold up internal investigations
by refusing to co-operate.
The deal meant that prosecutors had to build their case without
using those statements, something Urbina said the justice department
failed to do.
Prosecutors read those statements, reviewed them in the investigation and used them to get search warrants, Urbina said.
Al Jazeera and agencies