Book: "A Policy of Deliberate Cruelty"
TAMPA, Florida - Perhaps the most
thorough and informative book about the George W. Bush administration's
approval of the use of torture and "extraordinary renditions" of
alleged terrorists to third countries has continued to stay on
First published in July, "The Dark Side:
The Inside Story of How the War on Terror Turned into a War on American
Ideals" (Doubleday) by Jane Mayer is still listed among the top 10
nonfiction best-selling books of 2008 by The New York Times.
In the book, Mayer, a reporter for The New Yorker magazine,
shows in detail how high-level officials of the Bush administration,
particularly in the office of Vice President Dick Cheney, took
advantage of the fear and paranoia that gripped the country after the
terrorist attacks of Sep. 11, 2001 to launch "an ideological trench
war" and "a policy of deliberate cruelty that would've been unthinkable
on Sept. 10".
While Bush supported the overall strategy, he was almost a
minor player, Mayer reports. "President Bush is not typically
interested in fine details. He left those to others in the formation of
the military commissions, and other areas," she told IPS.
Arguably, the two administration officials whose post-9/11
policy decisions are most responsible for leaving the United States'
"reputation as a lead defender of democracy and human rights...in
tatters", in Mayer's words, were Cheney and his Chief of Staff David
Addington, whom Mayer notes the vice president came to rely on heavily
for legal advice in prosecuting the "war on terror".
In June this year, Addington was subpoenaed to testify before
the House Judiciary Committee -- along with former Justice Department
attorney John Yoo -- about detainee treatment, interrogation methods
and the limits of executive authority.
Mayer, who was in the room when Addington testified, said "I...was struck
by his utter contempt for both the Congressional panel that was
quizzing him, and the gathering press."
"He evidently thought that hauteur was the way to win the day,
which was another example of his astoundingly poor political sense...I
think at the moment, it's a stretch to think that there is the
necessary political will to prosecute top administration figures like
Addington, who could argue that they were simply doing what they
thought was necessary to protect the country."
Regarding Cheney, she writes in "The Dark Side" that the vice
president lived in such a state of anxiety after the 9/11 attacks that
"...he was chauffeured in an armoured motorcade that varied its route
to foil possible attackers. On the back seat behind Cheney rested a
duffle bag stocked with a gas mask and a biochemical survival suit."
Mayer asked repeatedly to interview Addington and Cheney and
was refused. A one-paragraph statement by the CIA, regarding the
conduct of its agents in the interrogation of alleged terrorists, is on
the last page of "The Dark Side".
However, she did manage to interview hundreds of sources in
and around the Bush White House, as well as sources from the Red Cross,
compiling a grim picture of interrogation and abuse of prisoners in
Iraq, Guantanamo Bay and elsewhere.
The book describes the use of alleged forms of torture by
members of a little-known U.S. military programme called SERE
(Survival, Evasion, Resistance, and Escape). It also explores the CIA's
hiring of psychologists of questionable abilities and morals, who
proceeded to encourage the use of interrogation methods that were
created decades ago, ironically enough by the former Soviet Union's KGB
secret police agency, and points out how essentially no piece of
relevant information has ever resulted from such interrogations.
Mayer also looks at renditions, the transfer of suspected
terrorists by U.S. authorities, mainly the CIA, to countries known to
employ harsh interrogation techniques and torture. Asked if she
believed that renditions were still being done by U.S. government
agents, even though the practice has now been exposed by the world's
media, Mayer told IPS, "After the bad publicity surrounding them, there
is likely a greater effort to ensure that they (U.S. government
agencies) are not 'rendering' mistaken suspects, or sending them to be
tortured, in contravention of the law, but the programme exists in a
classified realm where this is hard to determine."
Among the many disturbing incidents recounted in the book is the last night of Manadel al-Jamadi.
He was an Iraqi suspect who was detained outside of Baghdad at
approximately four a.m. local time on Nov. 4, 2003. "An hour later, he
was dead. An autopsy performed by military pathologists classified his
death as a homicide," writes Mayer.
She goes on to report that "Jamadi was driven first to an Army
base for debriefing, where the (U.S. Navy special forces unit) SEALs
punched, kicked, and struck him with their rifle muzzles for some 20
minutes." Jamadi was later interrogated by CIA operatives at Abu Ghraib
prison, where he was hung up by his wrists, and subsequently killed.
Eight members of the SEALs platoon received administrative
punishment for abuse of al-Jamadi and other prisoners, but Mark
Swanner, the CIA interrogator, has faced no charges.
"I hope readers (of "The Dark Side") come away with a vivid
sense of how far from American traditions the Bush administration
strayed in choosing to set aside the rule of law, in it's approach to
the war on terror," noted Mayer. "There have been other lapses in the
past, but as Arthur Schlesinger Jr., the late presidential historian
told me 'Nothing has hurt America more (in the world) ever.'."