Guatemalan deportee Eric Perez embraces his daughter after he arrived on an ICE deportation flight on February 9, 2017 to Guatemala City, Guatemala.(Photo by John Moore/Getty Images)
Jul 12, 2018
"Don't come to our country illegally," President Trump blasted in a recent tweet, his solution to the current immigrant crisis - one in which thousands of immigrants are fleeing violence in Central America and attempting to cross into the United States. He went on to emphasize the importance of borders, national sovereignty, and "rule of law."
"Don't invade our country," Central Americans might well have tweeted back.
"Don't invade our country," Central Americans might well have tweeted back. What goes 'round, comes around, and whether you believe in laws of kharma and the spiritual interconnectedness of life on this planet or not, there is plenty of evidence that the "crises" we see today were initiated long ago by actions that our country took. And the actions we take today will have profound effects on the future.
In most of the reports I have read about the "immigrant crisis," there is some recognition that there are reasons families take the tremendous risks they do to cross the border into the United States - a migration that costs thousands of dollars and potentially their lives, with no guarantee of success. These reports usually mention the rampant gang violence in Central America, and sometimes domestic violence as well.
But there is scant mention of the role of the United States played in begetting that violence, through "interventions" we took over the last century. Interventions, by their very name, involve a disrespecting of national sovereignty, borders, and the rule of law. They are achieved militarily - i.e. through violence.
But there is scant mention of the role of the United States played in begetting that violence, through "interventions" we took over the last century. Take the case of Guatemala. In 1954, the CIA engineered a coup that overthrew the democratically-elected presidency of Jacobo Arbenz, because Arbenz had instituted land reform that threatened the U.S.-based United Fruit Company, which was owned by Allen Dulles, brother to CIA director John Foster Dulles. (For details on this history see Steve Kinzer's book, The Brothers: John Foster Dulles, Allen Dulles, and their Secret World War.) This ushered in fifty years of military dictatorships that were supported and funded by the United States, leading to the "disappearance" or murder of some 200,000 civilians and a legacy of violence that now reverberates in everyday life.
My point is simple: violence begets violence; for every action there is a reaction; and what we do today will have profound effects on tomorrow.
The United States' recent decision to separate young children from their families at the border, regardless of their requests for asylum (asylum from violence that we are implicated in), will have repercussions far into the future: trauma layered on historical trauma. Recognizing our own role in creating these conditions would offer us an opportunity to right the historical record, to repair, restore, and set in place a different legacy.
Let me end on a more uplifting note. Last week's international efforts to rescue the soccer team from the cave in Thailand shows the good that can happen when people come together to support life, not thwart it. While some psychologists have warned that the boys may be traumatized by their experience, all reports thus far are that the boys are happy and at peace. This is likely due to the great efforts their coach took to care for them during their time in the cave, and to ensure that they cared for each other. And now, the mothers of the boys are promising to help "heal the heart" of the young coach who is suffering from his feelings of responsibility - such a different response than the press seemed to expect.
A situation that could have been tragic, traumatic, and full of blame or shame, has become an opportunity to see the power of interconnectedness, the good that can happen when we work together, and the healing power of care. We can choose how we respond to any situation in the world, and how we choose matters for what we set in play. There seem to be many forces that perpetuate violence and negativity, but perhaps we could tip the balance toward positivity and love.
Join Us: News for people demanding a better world
Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place. We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference. Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. Join with us today! |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
Marjorie Orellana
Marjorie Orellana is a UCLA education professor is a Fellow of the Sudikoff Family Institute for Education & New Media, an initiative that supports the public engagement of faculty at UCLA's Graduate School of Education & Information Studies.
"Don't come to our country illegally," President Trump blasted in a recent tweet, his solution to the current immigrant crisis - one in which thousands of immigrants are fleeing violence in Central America and attempting to cross into the United States. He went on to emphasize the importance of borders, national sovereignty, and "rule of law."
"Don't invade our country," Central Americans might well have tweeted back.
"Don't invade our country," Central Americans might well have tweeted back. What goes 'round, comes around, and whether you believe in laws of kharma and the spiritual interconnectedness of life on this planet or not, there is plenty of evidence that the "crises" we see today were initiated long ago by actions that our country took. And the actions we take today will have profound effects on the future.
In most of the reports I have read about the "immigrant crisis," there is some recognition that there are reasons families take the tremendous risks they do to cross the border into the United States - a migration that costs thousands of dollars and potentially their lives, with no guarantee of success. These reports usually mention the rampant gang violence in Central America, and sometimes domestic violence as well.
But there is scant mention of the role of the United States played in begetting that violence, through "interventions" we took over the last century. Interventions, by their very name, involve a disrespecting of national sovereignty, borders, and the rule of law. They are achieved militarily - i.e. through violence.
But there is scant mention of the role of the United States played in begetting that violence, through "interventions" we took over the last century. Take the case of Guatemala. In 1954, the CIA engineered a coup that overthrew the democratically-elected presidency of Jacobo Arbenz, because Arbenz had instituted land reform that threatened the U.S.-based United Fruit Company, which was owned by Allen Dulles, brother to CIA director John Foster Dulles. (For details on this history see Steve Kinzer's book, The Brothers: John Foster Dulles, Allen Dulles, and their Secret World War.) This ushered in fifty years of military dictatorships that were supported and funded by the United States, leading to the "disappearance" or murder of some 200,000 civilians and a legacy of violence that now reverberates in everyday life.
My point is simple: violence begets violence; for every action there is a reaction; and what we do today will have profound effects on tomorrow.
The United States' recent decision to separate young children from their families at the border, regardless of their requests for asylum (asylum from violence that we are implicated in), will have repercussions far into the future: trauma layered on historical trauma. Recognizing our own role in creating these conditions would offer us an opportunity to right the historical record, to repair, restore, and set in place a different legacy.
Let me end on a more uplifting note. Last week's international efforts to rescue the soccer team from the cave in Thailand shows the good that can happen when people come together to support life, not thwart it. While some psychologists have warned that the boys may be traumatized by their experience, all reports thus far are that the boys are happy and at peace. This is likely due to the great efforts their coach took to care for them during their time in the cave, and to ensure that they cared for each other. And now, the mothers of the boys are promising to help "heal the heart" of the young coach who is suffering from his feelings of responsibility - such a different response than the press seemed to expect.
A situation that could have been tragic, traumatic, and full of blame or shame, has become an opportunity to see the power of interconnectedness, the good that can happen when we work together, and the healing power of care. We can choose how we respond to any situation in the world, and how we choose matters for what we set in play. There seem to be many forces that perpetuate violence and negativity, but perhaps we could tip the balance toward positivity and love.
Marjorie Orellana
Marjorie Orellana is a UCLA education professor is a Fellow of the Sudikoff Family Institute for Education & New Media, an initiative that supports the public engagement of faculty at UCLA's Graduate School of Education & Information Studies.
"Don't come to our country illegally," President Trump blasted in a recent tweet, his solution to the current immigrant crisis - one in which thousands of immigrants are fleeing violence in Central America and attempting to cross into the United States. He went on to emphasize the importance of borders, national sovereignty, and "rule of law."
"Don't invade our country," Central Americans might well have tweeted back.
"Don't invade our country," Central Americans might well have tweeted back. What goes 'round, comes around, and whether you believe in laws of kharma and the spiritual interconnectedness of life on this planet or not, there is plenty of evidence that the "crises" we see today were initiated long ago by actions that our country took. And the actions we take today will have profound effects on the future.
In most of the reports I have read about the "immigrant crisis," there is some recognition that there are reasons families take the tremendous risks they do to cross the border into the United States - a migration that costs thousands of dollars and potentially their lives, with no guarantee of success. These reports usually mention the rampant gang violence in Central America, and sometimes domestic violence as well.
But there is scant mention of the role of the United States played in begetting that violence, through "interventions" we took over the last century. Interventions, by their very name, involve a disrespecting of national sovereignty, borders, and the rule of law. They are achieved militarily - i.e. through violence.
But there is scant mention of the role of the United States played in begetting that violence, through "interventions" we took over the last century. Take the case of Guatemala. In 1954, the CIA engineered a coup that overthrew the democratically-elected presidency of Jacobo Arbenz, because Arbenz had instituted land reform that threatened the U.S.-based United Fruit Company, which was owned by Allen Dulles, brother to CIA director John Foster Dulles. (For details on this history see Steve Kinzer's book, The Brothers: John Foster Dulles, Allen Dulles, and their Secret World War.) This ushered in fifty years of military dictatorships that were supported and funded by the United States, leading to the "disappearance" or murder of some 200,000 civilians and a legacy of violence that now reverberates in everyday life.
My point is simple: violence begets violence; for every action there is a reaction; and what we do today will have profound effects on tomorrow.
The United States' recent decision to separate young children from their families at the border, regardless of their requests for asylum (asylum from violence that we are implicated in), will have repercussions far into the future: trauma layered on historical trauma. Recognizing our own role in creating these conditions would offer us an opportunity to right the historical record, to repair, restore, and set in place a different legacy.
Let me end on a more uplifting note. Last week's international efforts to rescue the soccer team from the cave in Thailand shows the good that can happen when people come together to support life, not thwart it. While some psychologists have warned that the boys may be traumatized by their experience, all reports thus far are that the boys are happy and at peace. This is likely due to the great efforts their coach took to care for them during their time in the cave, and to ensure that they cared for each other. And now, the mothers of the boys are promising to help "heal the heart" of the young coach who is suffering from his feelings of responsibility - such a different response than the press seemed to expect.
A situation that could have been tragic, traumatic, and full of blame or shame, has become an opportunity to see the power of interconnectedness, the good that can happen when we work together, and the healing power of care. We can choose how we respond to any situation in the world, and how we choose matters for what we set in play. There seem to be many forces that perpetuate violence and negativity, but perhaps we could tip the balance toward positivity and love.
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.