Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

mansion

Mansion at night surrounded by gardens in Florida. (Photo: Jon Lovette/Getty Images)

Congress Needs to Do More to End Estate Tax Manipulations That Benefit Billionaires

The latest tax proposals in Congress are an okay first step, but don't go far enough to address one of the biggest enablers of dynastic wealth.

Bob LordChuck Collins

 by Inequality.org

Our tax code includes a number of "heads billionaires win, tales other taxpayers lose" provisions. Lawmakers are currently debating new tax rules that could fix these loopholes, but so far the House Ways and Means Committee will leave most of them in place.

How does a billionaire pass on wealth to avoid or reduce estate taxes? Their "wealth defense industry" employees—the tax attorneys and estate planners who are paid millions to sequester trillions—have an alphabet soup of tricks up their sleeve along with trusts. Welcome to the world of GRATS, IDGTs, and valuation discounts.

Congress is finally considering legislation that will put a major crimp in billionaire tax avoidance planning.

Want to become the best investor ever? Imagine if you only had to keep your high-performing investments and could sell back the money-losers at no cost. Imagine that on those high-return investments the person selling to you would continue to pay all the income tax. And, for each investment, imagine you could borrow 100 percent of the purchase price from your seller, at a low interest rate.

Now, what if you were super wealthy and you wanted to sell an investment, but you only got paid if the investment increased in value after the sale? Otherwise, you'd have to take it back, no questions asked. And, either way, the tax on the income from the investment would be on you.

That, my friends, is how America's billionaires avoid estate and gift tax entirely. They sell assets to trusts that benefit their children under the rules described above. And they do it repeatedly. Eventually, those trusts own virtually all the wealth, without any taxable gifts taking place. Just a series of outstanding investments. And no bad ones. Those asset sales, by the way, are not subject to income tax.

Tax avoidance planners call this strategy a zeroed-out GRAT, which stands for grantor retained annuity trust. The mechanics of a zeroed-out GRAT are super-complicated, but look past the complexity and what you have is an asset sale that is reversed if the asset fails to perform. Oh, and that little wrinkle about the seller continuing to pay the income tax.

Is it really that easy? No, it's even easier.

Consider what a breeze investing would be if your seller gave you a 30 percent discount on each investment. That tax avoidance strategy is known as a valuation discount. A wealthy parent takes her investment assets and contributes them to, say, a limited liability company in exchange for all the LLC interests. You'd think all those LLC interests would be worth the same thing as the investment assets, but tax avoidance planners would contend they're worth about 30 percent less. And they've convinced judges they're right.

So, when super-rich parents sell assets to one of those trusts for their children, the kids' trust gets a nice discount. And the parents keep paying the income tax.

These trusts where the trust creator keeps paying the tax, by the way, are known in the estate tax avoidance world as intentionally defective grantor trusts, IDGTs for short.

Often, ultrarich people have assets they're not terribly worried could lose value. They sell those to IDGTs too, but in a different way. First, they make a smallish (for them, that is) cash gift of about $10 million or so to the trust. Then, they sell assets having a value about ten times the amount of the gift to the trust, in exchange for the cash and a promissory note that bears interest at a super low rate. If the assets increase in value, the trust can buy more assets from the ultrarich person who created the trust, paying 100 percent of the purchase price with a promissory note.

Why, you might wonder, would an ultrarich person use this strategy rather than a zeroed-out GRAT? After all, the zeroed-out GRAT doesn't require the gift of any seed money, which can be wasted if the IDGT's assets decline in value. Here's why: If this other strategy, which avoidance planners call sale to an IDGT, works out, and it usually does, the trust winds up being what's known as a dynasty trust.

Once wealth finds its way into a dynasty trust, it escapes all wealth transfer tax (that is, estate and gift tax and a third tax known as the generation-skipping transfer tax, or GST) forever, even in perpetuity. How large can one of these dynasty trusts get? The Northern Trust Company provides an example: A dynasty trust starting at $11.7 million and growing at 5 percent per year would hold $454 million after 75 years. Consider how much a dynasty trust would hold if it started out at $100 million. Or $1 billion. Or if the trst lasted 175 years. Or if it grew at a yearly rate greater than 5 percent.

There is some good news on this front. Congress is finally considering legislation that will put a major crimp in billionaire tax avoidance planning. Legislation being considered by the House Ways and Means Committee would partially address IDGTs and valuations discounts. But it doesn't go nearly far enough. And it fails to rule out the worst abuse, zeroed-out GRATS. Dynasty trusts would still be around as well. There are fixes for GRATs and dynasty trusts, as well as improvement to the proposals to address IDGTs and valuation discounts. Those need to be incorporated into the legislation.

Four years ago, Trump economic adviser Gary Cohn derisively noted that "only morons pay estate tax." Derision aside, Cohn was correct that the estate tax essentially is a voluntary tax. We now have a chance to change that. Let's make it happen.


This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 License.
Bob Lord

Bob Lord

Bob Lord, an Institute for Policy Studies associate fellow, is tax counsel to Americans for Tax Fairness.

Chuck Collins

Chuck Collins

Chuck Collins is a senior scholar at the Institute for Policy Studies where he co-edits Inequality.org, and is author of the new book, "Born on Third Base: A One Percenter Makes the Case for Tackling Inequality, Bringing Wealth Home, and Committing to the Common Good."  He is co-founder of Wealth for the Common Good, recently merged with the Patriotic Millionaires. He is co-author of "99 to 1: The Moral Measure of the Economy" and, with Bill Gates Sr., of "Wealth and Our Commonwealth: Why America Should Tax Accumulated Fortunes."

This is the world we live in. This is the world we cover.

Because of people like you, another world is possible. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. Common Dreams is not your normal news site. We don't survive on clicks. We don't want advertising dollars. We want the world to be a better place. But we can't do it alone. It doesn't work that way. We need you. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do. Without Your Support We Simply Don't Exist.

US Urged to End Drone Strikes After Pentagon Says Killing 10 Afghan Civilians Was 'Horrible Mistake'

"That was not a 'mistake,'" said journalist Anand Giridharadas. "War crimes are not oopsies."

Brett Wilkins ·


40+ NYC Activists Arrested for Protests Against Banks Fueling Climate Emergency

"We're sending a message loud and clear that the little action that politicians and greenwashing CEOs have taken so far does not begin to deal with the magnitude of this crisis."

Jessica Corbett ·


FDA Panel Recommends Pfizer Booster Shots for People 65+ and Especially Vulnerable

The scientific advisory committee voted down a recommendation for other adults.

Common Dreams staff ·


'What Betrayal Looks Like': UN Report Says World on Track for 2.7°C of Warming by 2100

"Whatever our so-called 'leaders' are doing," said Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg, "they are doing it wrong."

Jake Johnson ·


Critics Warn Biden That 30% Methane Reduction by 2030 Not Good Enough

Following the new U.S.-E.U. pledge, climate campaigners called for an urgent end to fossil fuel extraction and major reforms of agricultural practices.

Jessica Corbett ·

Support our work.

We are independent, non-profit, advertising-free and 100% reader supported.

Subscribe to our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values.
Direct to your inbox.

Subscribe to our Newsletter.


Common Dreams, Inc. Founded 1997. Registered 501(c3) Non-Profit | Privacy Policy
Common Dreams Logo