Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

Demonstrators protest U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detention in New York City on February 6, 2021.

Demonstrators protest U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detention in New York City on February 6, 2021. (Photo: Erik McGregor/LightRocket via Getty Images)

There Is Nothing 'Civil' or Humane About the Detention of Noncitizens

The system itself is rotten—plagued by death, abuse, impunity, and violence.

Sarah Sherman-Stokes

 by The Hill

Last week, Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas announced that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) will stop detaining immigrants in two county jails, in Massachusetts and Georgia, currently under federal investigation for abuses ranging from the use of flash-bang grenades and dogs against immigrants in custody to unwanted and unconsented to gynecological procedures. In heralding these closures, Secretary Mayorkas declared, "We have an obligation to make lasting improvements to our civil immigration detention system."

The decision to end the detention of immigrants at the Irwin County Detention Center in Georgia and the Bristol County House of Corrections in Massachusetts presents a tremendous victory.

No, Mr. Secretary, we have an obligation to end it.

Today, immigration detentions are at the lowest number in decades, thanks to a combination of tenacious organizing and advocacy efforts, strategic litigation, and the impact of a global pandemic. But this "low" is still quite high: somewhere around 15,000 to 20,000 persons on any given day. Under the Trump administration, that number reached more than 55,000 in 2019. If left unchecked, we could soon reach that number again. 

The Immigration and Nationality Act was passed in 1952 and, among other things, allowed immigration authorities to exercise their discretion to grant release from detention on bond for certain noncitizens. Two years later, in 1954, the United States announced it would end detention except in extraordinary circumstances. Some targeted, and discriminatory, detentions of mostly Black and Brown noncitizens continued, namely detention of those who arrived with the Mariel boatlift of Cubans, and Haitian and Central American asylum-seekers. But the number of those in custody remained relatively low, hovering just under 7,000 in the early 1990s. 

Over the next 25 years, the number of noncitizens detained by ICE grew dramatically. This was because of changes in immigration law and criminal law that increasingly, and relentlessly, targeted poor communities and communities of color; criminalized crimes of poverty; and made detention and deportation mandatory for minor, nonviolent misdemeanors. In the past 25 years, such mass detention and subsequent deportation has destroyed families and communities, created overwhelming financial hardship, and given rise to significant mental health problems.

There is nothing "civil" about the so-called "civil immigration detention system." Indeed, those held in immigration custody are incarcerated in a network of over 200 jails and prisons across the United States. As Justice Sonia Sotomayor asked during an oral argument in 2018: "You put [immigrant detainees] in orange suits, they are shackled during visitation and court visits, they are subject to surveillance and strip searches, they are referred to by number, not by name. So in which ways is immigration detention different than criminal detention?" The answer, of course, is that there is no difference. The system itself is rotten—plagued by death, abuse, impunity, and violence. In 2020 alone, 21 people died in immigration detention, and staggering patterns of sexual assault in immigration detention came to light. Of 1,224 complaints made regarding sexual abuse in immigration detention between 2010 and 2017, only 43 were investigated.

The decision to end the detention of immigrants at the Irwin County Detention Center in Georgia and the Bristol County House of Corrections in Massachusetts presents a tremendous victory. No one, whether in civil or criminal custody, should be subject to the kinds of physical, sexual, and verbal abuses often inflicted upon immigrants at these facilities. And the bravery of the men and women who spoke out about the horrific treatment they suffered, as well as the tireless work of organizers and advocates on their behalf, cannot be understated.

In 1891, the U.S. government demanded that ships keep passengers aboard until they could determine whether foreign passengers could be legally admitted into the United States. Frustrated that ships were now makeshift hotels and could not be used for business, private steamship companies set up warehouses ashore to hold noncitizen passengers. When inspectors from the Department of Labor visited, they described the warehouses as "death traps."

From the beginning, there has been nothing civil or humane about the detention of noncitizens. As the number of people in immigration detention has soared, reported abuses have multiplied and grown more horrifying. The "death traps" of the 1890s are with us today. Immigration detention cannot be improved, and the closure of Irwin and Bristol should be the first step toward ending immigration detention altogether.


© 2021 The Hill
Sarah Sherman-Stokes

Sarah Sherman-Stokes

Sarah Sherman-Stokes is associate director of the Immigrants’ Rights and Human Trafficking Program at Boston University School of Law. She is part of a team of survivors, organizers, activists and lawyers who have been working to expose abuses at the Irwin County Detention Center.

This is the world we live in. This is the world we cover.

Because of people like you, another world is possible. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. Common Dreams is not your normal news site. We don't survive on clicks. We don't want advertising dollars. We want the world to be a better place. But we can't do it alone. It doesn't work that way. We need you. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do. Without Your Support We Simply Don't Exist.

'Infuriating Disappointment': Biden DHS Ramping Up Deportations to Haiti

"It is unconscionable for the Biden administration to resume deportation flights to Haiti, despite the country's ongoing political, economic, and environmental disasters."

Jessica Corbett ·


Architect of Texas Abortion Ban Takes Aim at LGBTQ+ Rights While Urging Reversal of Roe

"Make no mistake, the goal is to force extreme, outdated, religious-driven values on all of us through the courts."

Jessica Corbett ·


Ahead of Canadian Election, Bernie Sanders and Rashida Tlaib Endorse NDP

"Bernie, you have fought courageously for public healthcare, affordable medication, making the rich pay their fair share, and tackling the climate crisis," said party leader Jagmeet Singh. "We're doing the same here."

Jessica Corbett ·


US Urged to End Drone Strikes After Pentagon Says Killing 10 Afghan Civilians Was 'Horrible Mistake'

"That was not a 'mistake,'" said journalist Anand Giridharadas. "War crimes are not oopsies."

Brett Wilkins ·


40+ NYC Activists Arrested for Protests Against Banks Fueling Climate Emergency

"We're sending a message loud and clear that the little action that politicians and greenwashing CEOs have taken so far does not begin to deal with the magnitude of this crisis."

Jessica Corbett ·

Support our work.

We are independent, non-profit, advertising-free and 100% reader supported.

Subscribe to our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values.
Direct to your inbox.

Subscribe to our Newsletter.


Common Dreams, Inc. Founded 1997. Registered 501(c3) Non-Profit | Privacy Policy
Common Dreams Logo