Published on
Common Dreams

For Our Health or Your Wealth, That is the Question

Patients find it very difficult to tell in our dysfunctional healthcare system in the U.S. whether we are being cared for as people or being worked over for profit potential.  It’s frustrating and painful to hear ourselves referred to as consumers or customers rather than patients.   Rest assured that when someone labels us as things rather than human beings, it’s more than a difference in terminology; it’s a big, bold statement on exactly where and how we fit.

Watching our nurses’ work in Maine to oppose the for-profit takeover of kidney dialysis services illustrates just one area in which human beings who are dependent for their lives are at the mercy of those who are dependent on profit.  Wealth over health.

As I have worked with the advocates who support a progressively financed, single standard of high quality care for all under a Medicare for all for life model, I have sometimes noticed that it can be difficult to discern the ultimate motivations of some providers who were tortured not so much by the inhumanity of the system but by their own inability to break through that inhumanity and make money to meet their own obligations.    I suspect even when we get to a truly universal model, those kinds of providers will work to protect themselves and their revenue streams more than they will work to make sure patients are treated as human beings.  Wealth over health.

We’re continuing our Medicare for all for life bus tour in California this week, and we look forward to seeing patients – human beings—come to our screenings and our town halls meetings in Glendale tonight, South Los Angeles on Tuesday, Santa Monica on Wednesday, and West Covina on Thursday.  Hilda Sarkisyan (the late Nataline Sarkisyan’s mom) will be with us in Glendale, and three of the subjects of Michael Moore’s 2007 documentary film, SiCKO, will join us on Thursday – Reggie Cervantes, Dawnelle Keys and me.  Health over wealth.

But back home in Maryland, my hubby, went to the neurologist who has been treating him for issues that trouble him, including diminished memory and headaches.  He forgot an appointment last week, so the very first thing he was asked as he checked in was if he had the $25 they wanted to collect from him for forgetting that appointment.  He said no he didn’t.  The secretary went away for a moment.  Then when he was called into the office to see the doctor, the doctor’s first question was not to ask him how he was.  The doctor said, “I understand you refused to pay the $25 you owe me.”

My husband explained that he did not refuse to do so, then asked, “Is this supposed to be about your wealth or my health?”  The doctor grew angrier and advised my husband, after having him perform a couple of assessments of his neurological status -- undoubtedly so he could bill Medicare and Humana for the visit today -- that he no longer wished to treat him.  My husband was fired as a patient.  Wealth over health. 

Are we patients?  Are we consumers?  Are we human beings?  Are we customers?  If we are to heal this system, we’ll have to define ourselves clearly.  I, for one, am a patient.  What say you?

Mid-Year Campaign: Your Support is Needed Now.

Common Dreams is a small non-profit - Over 90% of the Common Dreams budget comes from reader support. No advertising; no paywalls: our content is free. But our costs are real. Common Dreams needs your help today! If you're a regular reader—or maybe a new one—and you haven't yet pitched in, could you make a contribution today? Because this is the truth: Readers, like you, keep us alive. Please make a donation now so we can continue to work for you.

Donna Smith

Donna Smith
Donna Smith is the executive director of Progressive Democrats of America.  PDA's mission is to strengthen the voice of progressive ideas inside and outside the Democratic Party by using "inside/outside" and "grassroots fusion" models of working both in the Democratic Party as well as working with other progressive organizations both inside and outside the Party.

Share This Article

More in: