Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

Evict BNY Mellon, not Occupy Pittsburgh

Evidence supporting the protesters' claim that major banks have engaged in illegal activities is mounting.

On Dec. 13, BNY Mellon filed a court action seeking to evict the Occupy Pittsburgh encampment from Mellon Green, where occupiers have been peacefully protesting without complaints from the public or the city. This action is an attempt to squelch the vital public dialogue that the Occupy Wall Street movement has been advocating.

Occupy Pittsburgh participants reciprocated. Not only did they vow to stay on Mellon Green (which they renamed "People's Park"), they served BNY Mellon with an eviction notice, as well. This was not aimed at BNY Mellon staff members, who, Occupy Pittsburgh said, are "almost entirely part of the 99 percent [since they are] not millionaires," but rather the corporation and its officials, which they call "a criminal enterprise masquerading as a respectable institution in the community."

Evidence supporting the protesters' claim that major banks have engaged in illegal activities is mounting.

BNY Mellon is being sued by three states for allegedly generating $2 billion in profit through fraudulent charges on public and private pension funds. In another case, the company is charged with causing $1 billion in losses to firefighters, police and other workers in Detroit's pension system by keeping investments in Lehman Brothers well after it was clear that Lehman Brothers was in trouble. BNY Mellon is even being sued by some of its former employees, who raise similar complaints about its management of its workers' 401(k) plans.

Occupy Pittsburgh also charges the company with failing to pay some of its workers a living wage -- while generating huge profits by violating both the law and the trust of clients from among the 99 percent.

Despite such behavior, BNY Mellon and other banks are seen as respectable institutions deserving favorable governmental treatment. Mellon's ability to remain solvent and generate profits may even be deemed a virtue. Its right to occupy several Downtown city blocks is unquestioned. This is because over the last three decades, the United States has led the world in building a globalized market where the goal of making profits supersedes all other aims and values.

Herein lies the crux of the Occupy Wall Street movement's claims. Policies favoring wealth generation over all else have reinforced the power of those with large amounts of capital over those with little. The wealth of most Americans has been transferred to the 1 percent in the form of corporate profits.

Much of this wealth transfer has occurred through technically legal means, such as by suppressing the wages of the 99 percent, most of whose incomes have remained stagnant since the 1970s.

But a good deal of it results from illegal and deceptive business practices.

These violations are often ignored or even made legal through corporate-friendly policies because corporate money has corrupted our political system and given corporations more voice than citizens. Corporate influence in politics has prevented politicians from recognizing and responding to the enormous risks imposed by corporate practices on our national economy and the entire world.

Protesters occupy physical public spaces to open more figurative space for the public to look critically at how and by whom our economy is being run. Until the Occupy movement came along, public dialogue narrowly centered on policies designed to favor the banks and corporate elite -- how much to cut government services, whether to increase taxes on the top several percent of taxpayers, whether to have a little more government regulation of industry and banks. Neither major political party has questioned the moral legitimacy of the economic structure.

The verb "to occupy" means "to engage." Occupy Wall Street has engaged the public and enlarged public debate beyond a narrow range of so-called "realistic" policy choices. Occupy camps are both symbolic and instrumental in their demands that we shift the emphasis of public policy and debate away from the single-minded pursuit of profit.

By evicting BNY Mellon, Occupy Pittsburgh employs a strategy used by marginalized groups throughout history struggling for a moral economy organized to serve human beings against the dictatorship of markets. A moral economy requires that people come together to determine what sort of economy and society we desire.

Occupy Wall Street's presence creates the kinds of spaces -- not only in downtown encampments but also in coffee shops, living rooms and public gatherings such as Occupy Pittsburgh's Human Rights Day rally -- needed for the democratic dialogue that has been denied by the increasing privatization of public spaces and corporate control over our mass media.

The public should support Occupy's right to stay in Mellon Green. People's Park is a space designated for public use but which BNY Mellon now wants to close to the public. More importantly, we must evict BNY Mellon and other corporations from their occupation of the public discourse. It is that occupation which really threatens both the public good and our democracy, not Occupy Pittsburgh's encampment in a tiny Downtown square.

Jackie Smith

Jackie Smith

Jackie Smith is professor of sociology at the University of Pittsburgh and editor of the Journal of World-Systems Research. She is author or editor of numerous books and articles on global organizing and social change, including "Social Movements and World-System Transformation," "Social Movements in the World-System: the Politics of Crisis and Transformation," and "Social Movements for Global Democracy." She helps coordinate Pittsburgh’s Human Rights City Alliance and is a member of the steering committee of the US Human Rights Network’s Human Rights Cities Alliance.

Jules Lobel

Jules Lobel is a Professor of Law and the Bessie McKee Wathour Endowed Chair at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law and former president of the Center for Constitutional Rights (2011- 2016).

We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.

Top Economists Hail Chilean Constitution as 'New Global Standard' on Climate, Inequality

"The world has much to learn from the exemplary process of the convention and the visionary product on which Chile will vote in its September plebiscite."

Jake Johnson ·

Ilhan Omar Fends Off Primary Challenger Boosted by Right-Wing PAC Money

"Ilhan Omar has faced some of the ugliest attacks of any elected official and had hundreds of thousands of dollars spent against her," said Sen. Bernie Sanders. "Despite this, she won her primary once again."

Jake Johnson ·

'Let's Send Ron Johnson Packing': Mandela Barnes Wins Wisconsin Senate Primary

"We're going to the Senate to rebuild the middle class," said Barnes. "We're going to protect the right to choose. We're going to fight to make the American Dream an American reality."

Jake Johnson ·

Global Allies Stand With Walden Bello as Social Justice Champion Posts Bail in the Philippines

"Walden Bello's arrest is a violation of his fundamental rights, an affront to the institutions of Philippine democracy, and a threat to free expression everywhere," said the Progressive International council.

Jessica Corbett ·

Team Trump Reportedly 'Bullish' About Exploiting FBI Raid to Win Reelection

One former Trump aide-turned-"Big Lie" detractor said that the Justice Department may have "just handed Trump" the 2024 GOP nomination "or potentially the presidency."

Brett Wilkins ·

Common Dreams Logo