Dec 24, 2010
Who did we under-appreciate in 2010? In the endless whirr of 24/7 corporate news, the people who actually make a difference are often trampled in the stampede to the next forgettable news-nugget like Lady Gaga's meat-dress. So in the final moments of this year, let's look at a few people who deserved more of our attention.
Under-Appreciated Person One: Bradley Manning. While we were all fixated on
Julian Assange, the story of the young American soldier who actually leaked
the classified documents passed almost unnoticed. If Manning was mentioned
at all, it was to be described as an impetuous, angry kid who downloaded the
documents on to a CD and leaked them as a result of a "grudge" or "tantrum".
Here's what really happened. Manning signed up when he was just 18, believing
he would be protecting and defending his country and the cause of freedom.
He soon found himself sent to Iraq, where he was ordered to round up and
hand over Iraqi civilians to America's new Iraqi allies, who he could see
were then torturing them with electrical drills and other implements.
The only "crime" committed by many of these people was to write "scholarly
critiques" of the occupation or the new people in charge. He knew
torture was a crime under US, Iraqi and international law, so he went to his
military supervisor and explained what was going on. He was told to shut up
and get back to herding up Iraqis.
Manning had to choose between being complicit in these atrocities, or not. At
the age of 21, he made a brave choice: to put human rights before his own
interests. He found the classified military documents revealing that the US
was covering up the deaths of 15,000 Iraqis and had a de facto policy of
allowing the Iraqis they had installed in power to carry out torture - and
he decided he had a moral obligation to show them to the American people.
To prevent the major crime of torturing and murdering innocents, he committed
the minor crime of leaking the evidence. He has spent the last seven months
in solitary confinement - a punishment that causes many prisoners to go mad,
and which the US National Commission on Prisons called "torturous".
He is expected to be sentenced to 80 years in jail at least. The people who
allowed torture have faced no punishment at all. Manning's decision was no "tantrum"
- it was one of the most admirable stands for justice and freedom of 2010.
Under-Appreciated Person Two: Ellen Johnson Sirleaf. The only African leader
who appears with any regularity on our TV screens is the snarling psychopath
Robert Mugabe, spreading his message of dysfunction and despair. We rarely
hear about his polar opposite.
In 2005, the women of Liberia strapped their babies to their backs and moved
en masse to elect Africa's first ever elected female President. Ellen
Johnson-Sirleaf was a 62-year-old grandmother who had been thrown in prison
by the country's dictators simply for demanding democracy. She emerged
blinking into a country trashed by 14 years of civil war and pillaged by
dictators - but she said she would, at last, ensure that the Liberian state
obeyed the will of its people.
In the face of a chorus of cynics, she did it. She restored electricity for
the first time since 1992. She got the number of children in school up by 40
per cent. She introduced prison terms for rapists for the first time. Now
she is running for re-election in a fully open and contested ballot. I look
at her and I think of all the women I have seen by the roadsides of Africa,
carrying impossibly heavy loads on hunched backs - and I know what they will
achieve when they are finally allowed to.
Under-appreciated Person Three: Senator Bernie Sanders. In 2010, the hijacking
of American democracy by corporations and the super-rich became almost
complete. Almost no politician in the US runs for office without begging and
scrounging huge campaign funds from the rich - so when they are elected,
they presumably feel they must serve their interests, not those of ordinary
Americans.
You can see the results everywhere. In the middle of a recession, there was a
massive tax cut for millionaires and billionaires - and a tax rise on the
poorest Americans. Bill Gates pays less; a family living in a cold
trailer-park with no health care pays more - with Obama stitching up the
deal with Republicans.
But one American politician, more than any other, showed that there can still
be a different, democratic way of doing politics in America.
Bernie Sanders was elected as the independent socialist senator for Vermont
with 65 per cent of the vote in 2006, in a fight against the richest man in
the state. He won by turning down Big Money and instead organising amongst
ordinary citizens - by promising to defend their interests against the
people ripping them off.
He won over even very conservative parts of his state to a self-described
socialist agenda by telling them: "Conservative Republicans don't have
healthcare. Conservative Republicans can't afford to send their kids to
college. Conservative Republicans are being thrown out of their jobs as our
good-paying jobs move to China. You need somebody to stand up to protect
your economic well-being. Look, we're not going to agree on every issue,
that's for sure. But don't vote against your own interest. I don't mind
really if millionaires vote against me. They probably should. But for
working people, we've got to come together."
In the place of the fake populism of the Tea Party, he offered real populism.
In office, he kept his word. He has been demanding a real healthcare deal,
trying to end the country's disastrous jihadi-creating wars, and captured
America's imagination by standing for nine hours in the Senate trying to
filibuster Obama's sell-out of his principles and his people. This is what
democracy looks like.
Under-Appreciated People Four: The Saudi Arabian women who are fighting back.
Women like Wajehaal-Huwaider are struggling against a tyranny that bans them
from driving, showing their face in public, or even getting medical
treatment without permission from their male "guardian". The
streets are policed by black-clad men who enforce sharia law and whip women
who express any free will.
Saudi women are being treated just as horrifically as Iranian women - but
because their oppressors are our governments' allies, rather than our
governments' enemies, you hear almost nothing about them. Huwaider points
out that her sisters are fighting back and being beaten and whipped for it,
and asks: "Why isn't the cry of these millions of women heard, and why
isn't it answered by anyone, anywhere in the world?"
Under-Appreciated People Five: The real N'avi. The people of Kalahandi, India,
saw the film Avatar and recognised it as their story. The land they had
lived in peacefully for thousands of years - and considered sacred - was in
their eyes being destroyed and pillaged by a Western bauxite mining
corporation called Vedanta, whose majority owner lives in luxury in Mayfair.
The local protesters didn't give up. They appealed for international
solidarity, so Vedanta meetings in London were besieged by people dressed as
N'avi. The Indian government finally responded to co-ordinated global
democratic pressure and agreed that the corporation had acted "in total
contempt of the law". The real N'avi won. They saved their land.
In 2011 we could all benefit from turning off the tinny, shrill newszak and
hearing more real news about people like this - so we can resolve to be a
little more like them.
Join Us: News for people demanding a better world
Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place. We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference. Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. |
© 2023 The Independent
Johann Hari
Johann Hari is a British-Swiss writer and journalist. He has written for publications including The Independent and The Huffington Post, and has written books on the topics of depression, the war on drugs, and the British monarchy. He reported from Iraq, Israel/Palestine, the Congo, the Central African Republic, Venezuela, Peru and the US, and his journalism has appeared in publications all over the world.
Who did we under-appreciate in 2010? In the endless whirr of 24/7 corporate news, the people who actually make a difference are often trampled in the stampede to the next forgettable news-nugget like Lady Gaga's meat-dress. So in the final moments of this year, let's look at a few people who deserved more of our attention.
Under-Appreciated Person One: Bradley Manning. While we were all fixated on
Julian Assange, the story of the young American soldier who actually leaked
the classified documents passed almost unnoticed. If Manning was mentioned
at all, it was to be described as an impetuous, angry kid who downloaded the
documents on to a CD and leaked them as a result of a "grudge" or "tantrum".
Here's what really happened. Manning signed up when he was just 18, believing
he would be protecting and defending his country and the cause of freedom.
He soon found himself sent to Iraq, where he was ordered to round up and
hand over Iraqi civilians to America's new Iraqi allies, who he could see
were then torturing them with electrical drills and other implements.
The only "crime" committed by many of these people was to write "scholarly
critiques" of the occupation or the new people in charge. He knew
torture was a crime under US, Iraqi and international law, so he went to his
military supervisor and explained what was going on. He was told to shut up
and get back to herding up Iraqis.
Manning had to choose between being complicit in these atrocities, or not. At
the age of 21, he made a brave choice: to put human rights before his own
interests. He found the classified military documents revealing that the US
was covering up the deaths of 15,000 Iraqis and had a de facto policy of
allowing the Iraqis they had installed in power to carry out torture - and
he decided he had a moral obligation to show them to the American people.
To prevent the major crime of torturing and murdering innocents, he committed
the minor crime of leaking the evidence. He has spent the last seven months
in solitary confinement - a punishment that causes many prisoners to go mad,
and which the US National Commission on Prisons called "torturous".
He is expected to be sentenced to 80 years in jail at least. The people who
allowed torture have faced no punishment at all. Manning's decision was no "tantrum"
- it was one of the most admirable stands for justice and freedom of 2010.
Under-Appreciated Person Two: Ellen Johnson Sirleaf. The only African leader
who appears with any regularity on our TV screens is the snarling psychopath
Robert Mugabe, spreading his message of dysfunction and despair. We rarely
hear about his polar opposite.
In 2005, the women of Liberia strapped their babies to their backs and moved
en masse to elect Africa's first ever elected female President. Ellen
Johnson-Sirleaf was a 62-year-old grandmother who had been thrown in prison
by the country's dictators simply for demanding democracy. She emerged
blinking into a country trashed by 14 years of civil war and pillaged by
dictators - but she said she would, at last, ensure that the Liberian state
obeyed the will of its people.
In the face of a chorus of cynics, she did it. She restored electricity for
the first time since 1992. She got the number of children in school up by 40
per cent. She introduced prison terms for rapists for the first time. Now
she is running for re-election in a fully open and contested ballot. I look
at her and I think of all the women I have seen by the roadsides of Africa,
carrying impossibly heavy loads on hunched backs - and I know what they will
achieve when they are finally allowed to.
Under-appreciated Person Three: Senator Bernie Sanders. In 2010, the hijacking
of American democracy by corporations and the super-rich became almost
complete. Almost no politician in the US runs for office without begging and
scrounging huge campaign funds from the rich - so when they are elected,
they presumably feel they must serve their interests, not those of ordinary
Americans.
You can see the results everywhere. In the middle of a recession, there was a
massive tax cut for millionaires and billionaires - and a tax rise on the
poorest Americans. Bill Gates pays less; a family living in a cold
trailer-park with no health care pays more - with Obama stitching up the
deal with Republicans.
But one American politician, more than any other, showed that there can still
be a different, democratic way of doing politics in America.
Bernie Sanders was elected as the independent socialist senator for Vermont
with 65 per cent of the vote in 2006, in a fight against the richest man in
the state. He won by turning down Big Money and instead organising amongst
ordinary citizens - by promising to defend their interests against the
people ripping them off.
He won over even very conservative parts of his state to a self-described
socialist agenda by telling them: "Conservative Republicans don't have
healthcare. Conservative Republicans can't afford to send their kids to
college. Conservative Republicans are being thrown out of their jobs as our
good-paying jobs move to China. You need somebody to stand up to protect
your economic well-being. Look, we're not going to agree on every issue,
that's for sure. But don't vote against your own interest. I don't mind
really if millionaires vote against me. They probably should. But for
working people, we've got to come together."
In the place of the fake populism of the Tea Party, he offered real populism.
In office, he kept his word. He has been demanding a real healthcare deal,
trying to end the country's disastrous jihadi-creating wars, and captured
America's imagination by standing for nine hours in the Senate trying to
filibuster Obama's sell-out of his principles and his people. This is what
democracy looks like.
Under-Appreciated People Four: The Saudi Arabian women who are fighting back.
Women like Wajehaal-Huwaider are struggling against a tyranny that bans them
from driving, showing their face in public, or even getting medical
treatment without permission from their male "guardian". The
streets are policed by black-clad men who enforce sharia law and whip women
who express any free will.
Saudi women are being treated just as horrifically as Iranian women - but
because their oppressors are our governments' allies, rather than our
governments' enemies, you hear almost nothing about them. Huwaider points
out that her sisters are fighting back and being beaten and whipped for it,
and asks: "Why isn't the cry of these millions of women heard, and why
isn't it answered by anyone, anywhere in the world?"
Under-Appreciated People Five: The real N'avi. The people of Kalahandi, India,
saw the film Avatar and recognised it as their story. The land they had
lived in peacefully for thousands of years - and considered sacred - was in
their eyes being destroyed and pillaged by a Western bauxite mining
corporation called Vedanta, whose majority owner lives in luxury in Mayfair.
The local protesters didn't give up. They appealed for international
solidarity, so Vedanta meetings in London were besieged by people dressed as
N'avi. The Indian government finally responded to co-ordinated global
democratic pressure and agreed that the corporation had acted "in total
contempt of the law". The real N'avi won. They saved their land.
In 2011 we could all benefit from turning off the tinny, shrill newszak and
hearing more real news about people like this - so we can resolve to be a
little more like them.
Johann Hari
Johann Hari is a British-Swiss writer and journalist. He has written for publications including The Independent and The Huffington Post, and has written books on the topics of depression, the war on drugs, and the British monarchy. He reported from Iraq, Israel/Palestine, the Congo, the Central African Republic, Venezuela, Peru and the US, and his journalism has appeared in publications all over the world.
Who did we under-appreciate in 2010? In the endless whirr of 24/7 corporate news, the people who actually make a difference are often trampled in the stampede to the next forgettable news-nugget like Lady Gaga's meat-dress. So in the final moments of this year, let's look at a few people who deserved more of our attention.
Under-Appreciated Person One: Bradley Manning. While we were all fixated on
Julian Assange, the story of the young American soldier who actually leaked
the classified documents passed almost unnoticed. If Manning was mentioned
at all, it was to be described as an impetuous, angry kid who downloaded the
documents on to a CD and leaked them as a result of a "grudge" or "tantrum".
Here's what really happened. Manning signed up when he was just 18, believing
he would be protecting and defending his country and the cause of freedom.
He soon found himself sent to Iraq, where he was ordered to round up and
hand over Iraqi civilians to America's new Iraqi allies, who he could see
were then torturing them with electrical drills and other implements.
The only "crime" committed by many of these people was to write "scholarly
critiques" of the occupation or the new people in charge. He knew
torture was a crime under US, Iraqi and international law, so he went to his
military supervisor and explained what was going on. He was told to shut up
and get back to herding up Iraqis.
Manning had to choose between being complicit in these atrocities, or not. At
the age of 21, he made a brave choice: to put human rights before his own
interests. He found the classified military documents revealing that the US
was covering up the deaths of 15,000 Iraqis and had a de facto policy of
allowing the Iraqis they had installed in power to carry out torture - and
he decided he had a moral obligation to show them to the American people.
To prevent the major crime of torturing and murdering innocents, he committed
the minor crime of leaking the evidence. He has spent the last seven months
in solitary confinement - a punishment that causes many prisoners to go mad,
and which the US National Commission on Prisons called "torturous".
He is expected to be sentenced to 80 years in jail at least. The people who
allowed torture have faced no punishment at all. Manning's decision was no "tantrum"
- it was one of the most admirable stands for justice and freedom of 2010.
Under-Appreciated Person Two: Ellen Johnson Sirleaf. The only African leader
who appears with any regularity on our TV screens is the snarling psychopath
Robert Mugabe, spreading his message of dysfunction and despair. We rarely
hear about his polar opposite.
In 2005, the women of Liberia strapped their babies to their backs and moved
en masse to elect Africa's first ever elected female President. Ellen
Johnson-Sirleaf was a 62-year-old grandmother who had been thrown in prison
by the country's dictators simply for demanding democracy. She emerged
blinking into a country trashed by 14 years of civil war and pillaged by
dictators - but she said she would, at last, ensure that the Liberian state
obeyed the will of its people.
In the face of a chorus of cynics, she did it. She restored electricity for
the first time since 1992. She got the number of children in school up by 40
per cent. She introduced prison terms for rapists for the first time. Now
she is running for re-election in a fully open and contested ballot. I look
at her and I think of all the women I have seen by the roadsides of Africa,
carrying impossibly heavy loads on hunched backs - and I know what they will
achieve when they are finally allowed to.
Under-appreciated Person Three: Senator Bernie Sanders. In 2010, the hijacking
of American democracy by corporations and the super-rich became almost
complete. Almost no politician in the US runs for office without begging and
scrounging huge campaign funds from the rich - so when they are elected,
they presumably feel they must serve their interests, not those of ordinary
Americans.
You can see the results everywhere. In the middle of a recession, there was a
massive tax cut for millionaires and billionaires - and a tax rise on the
poorest Americans. Bill Gates pays less; a family living in a cold
trailer-park with no health care pays more - with Obama stitching up the
deal with Republicans.
But one American politician, more than any other, showed that there can still
be a different, democratic way of doing politics in America.
Bernie Sanders was elected as the independent socialist senator for Vermont
with 65 per cent of the vote in 2006, in a fight against the richest man in
the state. He won by turning down Big Money and instead organising amongst
ordinary citizens - by promising to defend their interests against the
people ripping them off.
He won over even very conservative parts of his state to a self-described
socialist agenda by telling them: "Conservative Republicans don't have
healthcare. Conservative Republicans can't afford to send their kids to
college. Conservative Republicans are being thrown out of their jobs as our
good-paying jobs move to China. You need somebody to stand up to protect
your economic well-being. Look, we're not going to agree on every issue,
that's for sure. But don't vote against your own interest. I don't mind
really if millionaires vote against me. They probably should. But for
working people, we've got to come together."
In the place of the fake populism of the Tea Party, he offered real populism.
In office, he kept his word. He has been demanding a real healthcare deal,
trying to end the country's disastrous jihadi-creating wars, and captured
America's imagination by standing for nine hours in the Senate trying to
filibuster Obama's sell-out of his principles and his people. This is what
democracy looks like.
Under-Appreciated People Four: The Saudi Arabian women who are fighting back.
Women like Wajehaal-Huwaider are struggling against a tyranny that bans them
from driving, showing their face in public, or even getting medical
treatment without permission from their male "guardian". The
streets are policed by black-clad men who enforce sharia law and whip women
who express any free will.
Saudi women are being treated just as horrifically as Iranian women - but
because their oppressors are our governments' allies, rather than our
governments' enemies, you hear almost nothing about them. Huwaider points
out that her sisters are fighting back and being beaten and whipped for it,
and asks: "Why isn't the cry of these millions of women heard, and why
isn't it answered by anyone, anywhere in the world?"
Under-Appreciated People Five: The real N'avi. The people of Kalahandi, India,
saw the film Avatar and recognised it as their story. The land they had
lived in peacefully for thousands of years - and considered sacred - was in
their eyes being destroyed and pillaged by a Western bauxite mining
corporation called Vedanta, whose majority owner lives in luxury in Mayfair.
The local protesters didn't give up. They appealed for international
solidarity, so Vedanta meetings in London were besieged by people dressed as
N'avi. The Indian government finally responded to co-ordinated global
democratic pressure and agreed that the corporation had acted "in total
contempt of the law". The real N'avi won. They saved their land.
In 2011 we could all benefit from turning off the tinny, shrill newszak and
hearing more real news about people like this - so we can resolve to be a
little more like them.
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.