Oct 05, 2009
This week marks 8 years of war in Afghanistan. There appears to be, for
the first time, a glimmer of a genuine debate about how this country
should move forward. Those who are clamoring for a new and speedy
infusion of troops are ratcheting up the pressure in an attempt to cut
off this badly needed debate. If they are not countered powerfully
enough, their arm-twisting could mean we end up doubling down on a
failing strategy. Here are a few things to keep in mind.
1. 1,425 soldiers have died in Afghanistan so far, including 853 Americans.
For those who are lucky enough to return alive, the trauma of serving
in combat can often still lead to tragic consequences. The federal
government estimates that 5,000 veterans commit suicide every year, and
the Army reported a record 140 active duty suicides last year.
2. While it is difficult to know exactly how many civilians have
been killed in Afghanistan, estimates range from 12,000 to 32,000
deaths directly and indirectly caused by war. The real tragedy is
behind the numbers, because each death has meant the loss of a child, a
family breadwinner, a caretaker, or a community leader. Each death has
contributed to the unraveling of the fabric of Afghan society, and has
been one more step away from peace and stability.
3. Nearly one in five veterans returning from Iraq and Afghanistan
suffer from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, and they are forced to
grapple with the stigma of mental illness as they return to a nation
that shamefully fails to treat their physical and mental injuries.
4. More troops are not the answer. Afghanistan expert Gilles Dorronsoro writes,
"The mere presence of foreign soldiers fighting a war in Afghanistan is
probably the single most important factor in the resurgence of the
Taliban." Military occupation, with its attendant civilian death and
displacement, creates greater instability. A recent RAND Corporation report
declares that there is "no battlefield solution to defeating Al Qaeda,"
noting that in the past 40 years, only 7% of terrorist groups that
ceased to exist were defeated through military force.
5. While members of Congress argue that they can't find the funds to insure the 45,000 uninsured Americans who die
every year, our government has spent $228 billion on a war that has
done nothing to protect us from Al Qaeda, and is about to pass another
$68 billion for Afghanistan for 2010. With President Obama's shift to
focusing on Afghanistan, the cost of the war is skyrocketing, and would
grow even more if he sent additional troops.
6. There are real alternatives
that emphasize civilian tools like diplomacy, development and political
reconciliation over our current failing strategy. A wide variety of
people agree that we need a real "civilian surge" and a lighter
military footprint, from Afghanistan and regional experts, to military personnel and policymakers.
7. The majority of Americans oppose sending more troops to Afghanistan. However the political pressure on the president to agree to an additional 45,000 troops is already enormous, and it's building. That's why people who oppose the war need to come out loud and strong this anniversary.
8. You can honor those who've died or been hurt in the war by
calling for its end. We need to show President Obama, Congress, and the
media that the majority of Americans who oppose escalation in
Afghanistan will not be silent. Join us in our Facebook Vigil at the White House here.
Join Us: News for people demanding a better world
Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place. We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference. Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
This week marks 8 years of war in Afghanistan. There appears to be, for
the first time, a glimmer of a genuine debate about how this country
should move forward. Those who are clamoring for a new and speedy
infusion of troops are ratcheting up the pressure in an attempt to cut
off this badly needed debate. If they are not countered powerfully
enough, their arm-twisting could mean we end up doubling down on a
failing strategy. Here are a few things to keep in mind.
1. 1,425 soldiers have died in Afghanistan so far, including 853 Americans.
For those who are lucky enough to return alive, the trauma of serving
in combat can often still lead to tragic consequences. The federal
government estimates that 5,000 veterans commit suicide every year, and
the Army reported a record 140 active duty suicides last year.
2. While it is difficult to know exactly how many civilians have
been killed in Afghanistan, estimates range from 12,000 to 32,000
deaths directly and indirectly caused by war. The real tragedy is
behind the numbers, because each death has meant the loss of a child, a
family breadwinner, a caretaker, or a community leader. Each death has
contributed to the unraveling of the fabric of Afghan society, and has
been one more step away from peace and stability.
3. Nearly one in five veterans returning from Iraq and Afghanistan
suffer from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, and they are forced to
grapple with the stigma of mental illness as they return to a nation
that shamefully fails to treat their physical and mental injuries.
4. More troops are not the answer. Afghanistan expert Gilles Dorronsoro writes,
"The mere presence of foreign soldiers fighting a war in Afghanistan is
probably the single most important factor in the resurgence of the
Taliban." Military occupation, with its attendant civilian death and
displacement, creates greater instability. A recent RAND Corporation report
declares that there is "no battlefield solution to defeating Al Qaeda,"
noting that in the past 40 years, only 7% of terrorist groups that
ceased to exist were defeated through military force.
5. While members of Congress argue that they can't find the funds to insure the 45,000 uninsured Americans who die
every year, our government has spent $228 billion on a war that has
done nothing to protect us from Al Qaeda, and is about to pass another
$68 billion for Afghanistan for 2010. With President Obama's shift to
focusing on Afghanistan, the cost of the war is skyrocketing, and would
grow even more if he sent additional troops.
6. There are real alternatives
that emphasize civilian tools like diplomacy, development and political
reconciliation over our current failing strategy. A wide variety of
people agree that we need a real "civilian surge" and a lighter
military footprint, from Afghanistan and regional experts, to military personnel and policymakers.
7. The majority of Americans oppose sending more troops to Afghanistan. However the political pressure on the president to agree to an additional 45,000 troops is already enormous, and it's building. That's why people who oppose the war need to come out loud and strong this anniversary.
8. You can honor those who've died or been hurt in the war by
calling for its end. We need to show President Obama, Congress, and the
media that the majority of Americans who oppose escalation in
Afghanistan will not be silent. Join us in our Facebook Vigil at the White House here.
This week marks 8 years of war in Afghanistan. There appears to be, for
the first time, a glimmer of a genuine debate about how this country
should move forward. Those who are clamoring for a new and speedy
infusion of troops are ratcheting up the pressure in an attempt to cut
off this badly needed debate. If they are not countered powerfully
enough, their arm-twisting could mean we end up doubling down on a
failing strategy. Here are a few things to keep in mind.
1. 1,425 soldiers have died in Afghanistan so far, including 853 Americans.
For those who are lucky enough to return alive, the trauma of serving
in combat can often still lead to tragic consequences. The federal
government estimates that 5,000 veterans commit suicide every year, and
the Army reported a record 140 active duty suicides last year.
2. While it is difficult to know exactly how many civilians have
been killed in Afghanistan, estimates range from 12,000 to 32,000
deaths directly and indirectly caused by war. The real tragedy is
behind the numbers, because each death has meant the loss of a child, a
family breadwinner, a caretaker, or a community leader. Each death has
contributed to the unraveling of the fabric of Afghan society, and has
been one more step away from peace and stability.
3. Nearly one in five veterans returning from Iraq and Afghanistan
suffer from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, and they are forced to
grapple with the stigma of mental illness as they return to a nation
that shamefully fails to treat their physical and mental injuries.
4. More troops are not the answer. Afghanistan expert Gilles Dorronsoro writes,
"The mere presence of foreign soldiers fighting a war in Afghanistan is
probably the single most important factor in the resurgence of the
Taliban." Military occupation, with its attendant civilian death and
displacement, creates greater instability. A recent RAND Corporation report
declares that there is "no battlefield solution to defeating Al Qaeda,"
noting that in the past 40 years, only 7% of terrorist groups that
ceased to exist were defeated through military force.
5. While members of Congress argue that they can't find the funds to insure the 45,000 uninsured Americans who die
every year, our government has spent $228 billion on a war that has
done nothing to protect us from Al Qaeda, and is about to pass another
$68 billion for Afghanistan for 2010. With President Obama's shift to
focusing on Afghanistan, the cost of the war is skyrocketing, and would
grow even more if he sent additional troops.
6. There are real alternatives
that emphasize civilian tools like diplomacy, development and political
reconciliation over our current failing strategy. A wide variety of
people agree that we need a real "civilian surge" and a lighter
military footprint, from Afghanistan and regional experts, to military personnel and policymakers.
7. The majority of Americans oppose sending more troops to Afghanistan. However the political pressure on the president to agree to an additional 45,000 troops is already enormous, and it's building. That's why people who oppose the war need to come out loud and strong this anniversary.
8. You can honor those who've died or been hurt in the war by
calling for its end. We need to show President Obama, Congress, and the
media that the majority of Americans who oppose escalation in
Afghanistan will not be silent. Join us in our Facebook Vigil at the White House here.
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.