The Missing Exit Strategy for Afghanistan

President Obama said it best when he talked about U.S. policy in
Afghanistan on the CBS news program 60 Minutes last month: "There's got
to be an exit strategy".

Well, there isn't one. There is an escalation of 21,000 US forces and there is a wartime spending bill requesting $94.2 billion more for Iraq and Afghanistan. But, as of today, there isn't even a hint of what the President believes we need-an exit strategy.
The Appropriations Committee is expected to dutifully vote out their
bill Thursday and send it to the floor of the House for a vote next

I realize how hard it would be for Congressional Democrats to
require the Obama administration to develop an exit strategy as a
condition for continued war funding. After all, this is our
guy, right? The last thing our guy needs is a Democratic Congress
second guessing, making demands, and putting conditions on the war

But this is exactly what we and the administration need precisely because he is our guy.

Unlike Mr. Limbaugh, we want and need President Obama to succeed.
The very real prospect of the United States embedded in an endless war
in Afghanistan would undermine everything this administration is trying
to do while imperiling the very Congressional Democrats President Obama
needs to move his agenda. This is exactly the right time to
engage the administration in a respectful but critical discussion about
where this military escalation is leading us.

Sending tens of thousands of more U.S. troops into Afghanistan-without a plan to get them out-is a bad idea for many reasons.

First off, the ink on the President's plan to send an additional
21,000 troops into Afghanistan wasn't even dry before the Pentagon
acknowledged that it already has a request in to the administration for
an additional 10,000 troops. What's worse, there are indications the
Pentagon has even more requests waiting in the wings.

The fact is, there are simply not enough U.S. soldiers to secure Afghanistan.
Estimates as to what would be required range for 200,000 to 600,000
troops. And, don't look to our NATO allies to be of any help. The
leader of Canada's Liberal Party told me last week that the only way
Canada citizens would support sending any troops was if there was a
clear exit strategy with a date certain for their withdrawal. As a
result, all Canadian soldiers will be on their way home by 2011.

Those of us who live on this side of the border should be demanding the same from our political leaders.

The lack of an exit strategy is already making things worse in Afghanistan.
Failing to say when and how we will remove our forces is playing into
the hands of Taliban leaders who are using the presence of our troops
on Afghanistan soil-and the announced escalation-as their most powerful
recruitment tool. The New York Times reports that the
escalation has mended fences between the otherwise fractious leadership
of the Pakistani and Afghan Taliban who announced that they are joining
forces to fight the new troops as they arrive.

A BBC/ABC public opinion poll of Afghans reveals that fully 80% of
the population is opposed to an escalation of American troops. Many of
those who are shooting at our soldiers are not jihadists; they are
proud Afghans who are famously sensitive to the presence of foreign
forces on their soil.

The lack of an exit strategy also works against President Obama's regional strategy-outreach
to the neighboring nations who have zero interest in a Taliban
dominated Afghanistan because it would threaten their national security
as much, if not more, than our own. How likely will China, Russia and
particularly Iran be to join the U.S. if the outcome might be tens of
thousands of U.S. troops on their border?

We need Congress to step up now and help prevent what has now become
"Obama's War" from turning into a quagmire that undermines, if not
destroys, the critically important agenda the President is fighting to
pass here at home.

We need to step up too. We can start by contacting
Members of Congress and urging them not to succumb to a vote-now, ask
questions later approach to war funding even if it is our guy who is
asking for it. We need a critical check-and-balance before it is too
late to stop an endless war in Afghanistan.

The war spending bill is on the floor of the House of Representatives next week.

Join Us: News for people demanding a better world

Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place.

We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference.

Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. Join with us today!

Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.