SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE NEWSLETTER
Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
To donate by check, phone, or other method, see our More Ways to Give page.
Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
On August 2, George W. Bush fled the clamor of the Capitol and hopped aboard Air Force One for a two-and-a-half-hour flight to his Texas ranch - 1,300 miles from the Oval Office. Bush's five-week vacation has set a new record for the longest presidential hiatus in US history. It also marks a personal best for Bush, who had already established several benchmarks for excessive executive layoffs.
According to the Washington Post's tabulations, by August 2003, Mr. Bush had spent 250 days - 21% of his presidency - on vacation (166 of those days ensconced at his Crawford ranch). This year's jaunt marks Bush's 49th trip to Crawford since he was handed the presidency.
When it comes to jetting off on extended vacations, George W. is simply following in the contrails of his famous father. President George H. W. Bush spent 543 days relaxing at Camp David or Kennebunkport, Maine, all on the taxpayers' dime. Even Ronald Reagan (no stranger to clearing brush on the family ranch) didn't come close to the Bush Family Record. Reagan only spent 335 days at his Santa Barbara ranch during the entire eight years of his presidency.
For taxpayers interested in getting a good return on their investment, Democrats clearly have the better record as conscientious, time-clock-punching government employees. Workaholic Bill Clinton claimed just 152 days of vacation in the first three years of his presidency. In 2000, Clinton clipped his vacation to a mere three days. Jimmy Carter was the real stuck-in-the-saddle champ. Carter only took 79 days off - all at the family home in Georgia.
When it comes to being a laid-back leader, Mr. Bush is no slouch. In his first three years, Bush took more vacation days than Clinton claimed in seven years. Unlike his Democratic predecessor, W. shies away from working nights and weekends. Even on workdays, Bush insists on interrupting affairs-of-state to take a two-hour, mid-day exercise break.
Bush repeatedly declares, through stubbornly clenched jaw, that the US will never retreat from its historic mission to bring freedom and democracy to whatever country the White House chooses to invade. But when it comes to his personal mission, Bush is only too happy to beat a retreat from the Oval Office and escape to Crawford - his "little patch of paradise" - where he can clear brush and pedal a mountain bike to his heart's content.
A week into his vacation, Bush outlined his day's schedule to members of the press corps, He indicated that he planned to putter around the ranch, clear some brush, do some bicycle riding, go fishing, catch a nap, meet with Condi Rice, and work on reading a book before finally hitting the sack for a good night's sleep around 9:30PM.
White House Press Secretary Scott McClellan rushed to justify Bush's escape to Crawford by arguing that "spending time outside of Washington always gives the president a fresh perspective of what's on the minds of the American people." But average Americans aren't allowed to knock on the ranch-house door. Bush only meets with the people he chooses to entertain - in this case, Secretary of State Rice, Defense Secretary Rumsfeld and Colombian President Alvaro Uribe.
Aside from several well-orchestrated off-ranch fundraising forays, the closest Mr. Bush has come to exposing himself to the American people during his long vacation came when he attended a Little League game. But the Secret Service made certain that Mr. Bush's field trip was not disrupted by any "fresh perspectives" and the Chief Executive didn't even hang around to autograph baseballs.
Mr. Bush's best opportunity to cash in on McClellan's rosy goal of gaining "a fresh perspective of what's on the minds of the American people" lies conveniently at-hand just down the road from the gate of the Bush ranch where thousands of average Americans are camped out at Camp Casey. Gold Star Mother Cindy Sheehan has stationed herself at Camp Casey in hopes of asking the commander-in-chief to explain the "noble cause" that claimed the life of her 24-year-old son in an Iraq fire-fight
Every time the presidential motorcade high-tails it past this growing encampment of engaged and passionate pro-life Americans, the commander-in-chief sends a clear message that he has no time for any "fresh perspectives" that would conflict with his oft-stated "resolve" to remain in Iraq until every last terrorist is removed from the face of the Earth.
Pestered by the press to explain his refusal to meet with Sheehan, Bush replied with uncharacteristic diplomacy: "I think it's important for me to be thoughtful and sensitive to those who have got something to say." He then proceeded to put his cowboy-booted foot in his mouth by quickly adding - with a stunning display of thoughtless insensitivity - "But I think it's also important for me to go on with my life."
And, with those words - as US soldiers continued to face death and fall in combat in Iraq and Afghanistan - Mr. Bush trotted off for a two-hour bike ride with Tour de France winner Lance Armstrong.
Clearly, Bush's average day has nothing in common with the experience of the average grunt on the frontlines of Bush's various wars. The worst misadventure Mr. Bush faces in Crawford is a back sprain from chopping mesquite, a skinned arm from toppling off his mountain bike or, God forbid, a near-death experience with a bowl of pretzels.
But for the recruits and reservists facing insurgent snipers, car bombs and IEDs in Baghdad and Kabul, there is no vacation. To the contrary: In many cases, these men and women - the hardest-working government employees on Uncle Sam's payroll - have seen their promised leaves canceled and their tours-of-duty extended time and time-again.
During the time George W. has been focusing on the important business of "getting on with my life," America's young soldiers have been dying at the rate of three-a-day - the highest mortality rate so far this year.
It's time for Mr. Bush to put away the chainsaw, get his head out of the Crawford underbrush and focus on these life-and-death realities. Cindy Sheehan and the other grieving families that have followed George W. to Crawford have a message for the Leader of the Free World. It's the same message that Bush once broadcast to Osama bin Laden: "You can run but you can't hide."
The next time Bush's motorcade speeds down the roadway that links his 1,583-acre bunker to the outside world, he should be forced to look at hundreds of posters bearing the number of young men and women who have died on duty while he was off on vacation.
As of August 26, those numbers were: 76 killed; more than 350 wounded.
For a comprehensive accounting of war deaths and injuries, updated daily, see the Iraq Coalition Casualty Count: www.icasualties.org
Donald Trump’s attacks on democracy, justice, and a free press are escalating — putting everything we stand for at risk. We believe a better world is possible, but we can’t get there without your support. Common Dreams stands apart. We answer only to you — our readers, activists, and changemakers — not to billionaires or corporations. Our independence allows us to cover the vital stories that others won’t, spotlighting movements for peace, equality, and human rights. Right now, our work faces unprecedented challenges. Misinformation is spreading, journalists are under attack, and financial pressures are mounting. As a reader-supported, nonprofit newsroom, your support is crucial to keep this journalism alive. Whatever you can give — $10, $25, or $100 — helps us stay strong and responsive when the world needs us most. Together, we’ll continue to build the independent, courageous journalism our movement relies on. Thank you for being part of this community. |
On August 2, George W. Bush fled the clamor of the Capitol and hopped aboard Air Force One for a two-and-a-half-hour flight to his Texas ranch - 1,300 miles from the Oval Office. Bush's five-week vacation has set a new record for the longest presidential hiatus in US history. It also marks a personal best for Bush, who had already established several benchmarks for excessive executive layoffs.
According to the Washington Post's tabulations, by August 2003, Mr. Bush had spent 250 days - 21% of his presidency - on vacation (166 of those days ensconced at his Crawford ranch). This year's jaunt marks Bush's 49th trip to Crawford since he was handed the presidency.
When it comes to jetting off on extended vacations, George W. is simply following in the contrails of his famous father. President George H. W. Bush spent 543 days relaxing at Camp David or Kennebunkport, Maine, all on the taxpayers' dime. Even Ronald Reagan (no stranger to clearing brush on the family ranch) didn't come close to the Bush Family Record. Reagan only spent 335 days at his Santa Barbara ranch during the entire eight years of his presidency.
For taxpayers interested in getting a good return on their investment, Democrats clearly have the better record as conscientious, time-clock-punching government employees. Workaholic Bill Clinton claimed just 152 days of vacation in the first three years of his presidency. In 2000, Clinton clipped his vacation to a mere three days. Jimmy Carter was the real stuck-in-the-saddle champ. Carter only took 79 days off - all at the family home in Georgia.
When it comes to being a laid-back leader, Mr. Bush is no slouch. In his first three years, Bush took more vacation days than Clinton claimed in seven years. Unlike his Democratic predecessor, W. shies away from working nights and weekends. Even on workdays, Bush insists on interrupting affairs-of-state to take a two-hour, mid-day exercise break.
Bush repeatedly declares, through stubbornly clenched jaw, that the US will never retreat from its historic mission to bring freedom and democracy to whatever country the White House chooses to invade. But when it comes to his personal mission, Bush is only too happy to beat a retreat from the Oval Office and escape to Crawford - his "little patch of paradise" - where he can clear brush and pedal a mountain bike to his heart's content.
A week into his vacation, Bush outlined his day's schedule to members of the press corps, He indicated that he planned to putter around the ranch, clear some brush, do some bicycle riding, go fishing, catch a nap, meet with Condi Rice, and work on reading a book before finally hitting the sack for a good night's sleep around 9:30PM.
White House Press Secretary Scott McClellan rushed to justify Bush's escape to Crawford by arguing that "spending time outside of Washington always gives the president a fresh perspective of what's on the minds of the American people." But average Americans aren't allowed to knock on the ranch-house door. Bush only meets with the people he chooses to entertain - in this case, Secretary of State Rice, Defense Secretary Rumsfeld and Colombian President Alvaro Uribe.
Aside from several well-orchestrated off-ranch fundraising forays, the closest Mr. Bush has come to exposing himself to the American people during his long vacation came when he attended a Little League game. But the Secret Service made certain that Mr. Bush's field trip was not disrupted by any "fresh perspectives" and the Chief Executive didn't even hang around to autograph baseballs.
Mr. Bush's best opportunity to cash in on McClellan's rosy goal of gaining "a fresh perspective of what's on the minds of the American people" lies conveniently at-hand just down the road from the gate of the Bush ranch where thousands of average Americans are camped out at Camp Casey. Gold Star Mother Cindy Sheehan has stationed herself at Camp Casey in hopes of asking the commander-in-chief to explain the "noble cause" that claimed the life of her 24-year-old son in an Iraq fire-fight
Every time the presidential motorcade high-tails it past this growing encampment of engaged and passionate pro-life Americans, the commander-in-chief sends a clear message that he has no time for any "fresh perspectives" that would conflict with his oft-stated "resolve" to remain in Iraq until every last terrorist is removed from the face of the Earth.
Pestered by the press to explain his refusal to meet with Sheehan, Bush replied with uncharacteristic diplomacy: "I think it's important for me to be thoughtful and sensitive to those who have got something to say." He then proceeded to put his cowboy-booted foot in his mouth by quickly adding - with a stunning display of thoughtless insensitivity - "But I think it's also important for me to go on with my life."
And, with those words - as US soldiers continued to face death and fall in combat in Iraq and Afghanistan - Mr. Bush trotted off for a two-hour bike ride with Tour de France winner Lance Armstrong.
Clearly, Bush's average day has nothing in common with the experience of the average grunt on the frontlines of Bush's various wars. The worst misadventure Mr. Bush faces in Crawford is a back sprain from chopping mesquite, a skinned arm from toppling off his mountain bike or, God forbid, a near-death experience with a bowl of pretzels.
But for the recruits and reservists facing insurgent snipers, car bombs and IEDs in Baghdad and Kabul, there is no vacation. To the contrary: In many cases, these men and women - the hardest-working government employees on Uncle Sam's payroll - have seen their promised leaves canceled and their tours-of-duty extended time and time-again.
During the time George W. has been focusing on the important business of "getting on with my life," America's young soldiers have been dying at the rate of three-a-day - the highest mortality rate so far this year.
It's time for Mr. Bush to put away the chainsaw, get his head out of the Crawford underbrush and focus on these life-and-death realities. Cindy Sheehan and the other grieving families that have followed George W. to Crawford have a message for the Leader of the Free World. It's the same message that Bush once broadcast to Osama bin Laden: "You can run but you can't hide."
The next time Bush's motorcade speeds down the roadway that links his 1,583-acre bunker to the outside world, he should be forced to look at hundreds of posters bearing the number of young men and women who have died on duty while he was off on vacation.
As of August 26, those numbers were: 76 killed; more than 350 wounded.
For a comprehensive accounting of war deaths and injuries, updated daily, see the Iraq Coalition Casualty Count: www.icasualties.org
On August 2, George W. Bush fled the clamor of the Capitol and hopped aboard Air Force One for a two-and-a-half-hour flight to his Texas ranch - 1,300 miles from the Oval Office. Bush's five-week vacation has set a new record for the longest presidential hiatus in US history. It also marks a personal best for Bush, who had already established several benchmarks for excessive executive layoffs.
According to the Washington Post's tabulations, by August 2003, Mr. Bush had spent 250 days - 21% of his presidency - on vacation (166 of those days ensconced at his Crawford ranch). This year's jaunt marks Bush's 49th trip to Crawford since he was handed the presidency.
When it comes to jetting off on extended vacations, George W. is simply following in the contrails of his famous father. President George H. W. Bush spent 543 days relaxing at Camp David or Kennebunkport, Maine, all on the taxpayers' dime. Even Ronald Reagan (no stranger to clearing brush on the family ranch) didn't come close to the Bush Family Record. Reagan only spent 335 days at his Santa Barbara ranch during the entire eight years of his presidency.
For taxpayers interested in getting a good return on their investment, Democrats clearly have the better record as conscientious, time-clock-punching government employees. Workaholic Bill Clinton claimed just 152 days of vacation in the first three years of his presidency. In 2000, Clinton clipped his vacation to a mere three days. Jimmy Carter was the real stuck-in-the-saddle champ. Carter only took 79 days off - all at the family home in Georgia.
When it comes to being a laid-back leader, Mr. Bush is no slouch. In his first three years, Bush took more vacation days than Clinton claimed in seven years. Unlike his Democratic predecessor, W. shies away from working nights and weekends. Even on workdays, Bush insists on interrupting affairs-of-state to take a two-hour, mid-day exercise break.
Bush repeatedly declares, through stubbornly clenched jaw, that the US will never retreat from its historic mission to bring freedom and democracy to whatever country the White House chooses to invade. But when it comes to his personal mission, Bush is only too happy to beat a retreat from the Oval Office and escape to Crawford - his "little patch of paradise" - where he can clear brush and pedal a mountain bike to his heart's content.
A week into his vacation, Bush outlined his day's schedule to members of the press corps, He indicated that he planned to putter around the ranch, clear some brush, do some bicycle riding, go fishing, catch a nap, meet with Condi Rice, and work on reading a book before finally hitting the sack for a good night's sleep around 9:30PM.
White House Press Secretary Scott McClellan rushed to justify Bush's escape to Crawford by arguing that "spending time outside of Washington always gives the president a fresh perspective of what's on the minds of the American people." But average Americans aren't allowed to knock on the ranch-house door. Bush only meets with the people he chooses to entertain - in this case, Secretary of State Rice, Defense Secretary Rumsfeld and Colombian President Alvaro Uribe.
Aside from several well-orchestrated off-ranch fundraising forays, the closest Mr. Bush has come to exposing himself to the American people during his long vacation came when he attended a Little League game. But the Secret Service made certain that Mr. Bush's field trip was not disrupted by any "fresh perspectives" and the Chief Executive didn't even hang around to autograph baseballs.
Mr. Bush's best opportunity to cash in on McClellan's rosy goal of gaining "a fresh perspective of what's on the minds of the American people" lies conveniently at-hand just down the road from the gate of the Bush ranch where thousands of average Americans are camped out at Camp Casey. Gold Star Mother Cindy Sheehan has stationed herself at Camp Casey in hopes of asking the commander-in-chief to explain the "noble cause" that claimed the life of her 24-year-old son in an Iraq fire-fight
Every time the presidential motorcade high-tails it past this growing encampment of engaged and passionate pro-life Americans, the commander-in-chief sends a clear message that he has no time for any "fresh perspectives" that would conflict with his oft-stated "resolve" to remain in Iraq until every last terrorist is removed from the face of the Earth.
Pestered by the press to explain his refusal to meet with Sheehan, Bush replied with uncharacteristic diplomacy: "I think it's important for me to be thoughtful and sensitive to those who have got something to say." He then proceeded to put his cowboy-booted foot in his mouth by quickly adding - with a stunning display of thoughtless insensitivity - "But I think it's also important for me to go on with my life."
And, with those words - as US soldiers continued to face death and fall in combat in Iraq and Afghanistan - Mr. Bush trotted off for a two-hour bike ride with Tour de France winner Lance Armstrong.
Clearly, Bush's average day has nothing in common with the experience of the average grunt on the frontlines of Bush's various wars. The worst misadventure Mr. Bush faces in Crawford is a back sprain from chopping mesquite, a skinned arm from toppling off his mountain bike or, God forbid, a near-death experience with a bowl of pretzels.
But for the recruits and reservists facing insurgent snipers, car bombs and IEDs in Baghdad and Kabul, there is no vacation. To the contrary: In many cases, these men and women - the hardest-working government employees on Uncle Sam's payroll - have seen their promised leaves canceled and their tours-of-duty extended time and time-again.
During the time George W. has been focusing on the important business of "getting on with my life," America's young soldiers have been dying at the rate of three-a-day - the highest mortality rate so far this year.
It's time for Mr. Bush to put away the chainsaw, get his head out of the Crawford underbrush and focus on these life-and-death realities. Cindy Sheehan and the other grieving families that have followed George W. to Crawford have a message for the Leader of the Free World. It's the same message that Bush once broadcast to Osama bin Laden: "You can run but you can't hide."
The next time Bush's motorcade speeds down the roadway that links his 1,583-acre bunker to the outside world, he should be forced to look at hundreds of posters bearing the number of young men and women who have died on duty while he was off on vacation.
As of August 26, those numbers were: 76 killed; more than 350 wounded.
For a comprehensive accounting of war deaths and injuries, updated daily, see the Iraq Coalition Casualty Count: www.icasualties.org
"This sends a chilling message that the U.S. is willing to overlook some abuses, signaling that people experiencing human rights violations may be left to fend for themselves," said one Amnesty campaigner.
After leaked drafts exposed the Trump administration's plans to downplay human rights abuses in some allied countries, including Israel, the U.S. Department of State released the final edition of an annual report on Tuesday, sparking fresh condemnation.
"Breaking with precedent, Secretary of State Marco Rubio did not provide a written introduction to the report nor did he make remarks about it," CNN reported. Still, Amanda Klasing, Amnesty International USA's national director of government relations and advocacy, called him out by name in a Tuesday statement.
"With the release of the U.S. State Department's human rights report, it is clear that the Trump administration has engaged in a very selective documentation of human rights abuses in certain countries," Klasing said. "In addition to eliminating entire sections for certain countries—for example discrimination against LGBTQ+ people—there are also arbitrary omissions within existing sections of the report based on the country."
Klasing explained that "we have criticized past reports when warranted, but have never seen reports quite like this. Never before have the reports gone this far in prioritizing an administration's political agenda over a consistent and truthful accounting of human rights violations around the world—softening criticism in some countries while ignoring violations in others. The State Department has said in relation to the reports less is more. However, for the victims and human rights defenders who rely on these reports to shine light on abuses and violations, less is just less."
"Secretary Rubio knows full well from his time in the Senate how vital these reports are in informing policy decisions and shaping diplomatic conversations, yet he has made the dangerous and short-sighted decision to put out a truncated version that doesn't tell the whole story of human rights violations," she continued. "This sends a chilling message that the U.S. is willing to overlook some abuses, signaling that people experiencing human rights violations may be left to fend for themselves."
"Failing to adequately report on human rights violations further damages the credibility of the U.S. on human rights issues," she added. "It's shameful that the Trump administration and Secretary Rubio are putting politics above human lives."
The overarching report—which includes over 100 individual country reports—covers 2024, the last full calendar year of the Biden administration. The appendix says that in March, the report was "streamlined for better utility and accessibility in the field and by partners, and to be more responsive to the underlying legislative mandate and aligned to the administration's executive orders."
As CNN detailed:
The latest report was stripped of many of the specific sections included in past reports, including reporting on alleged abuses based on sexual orientation, violence toward women, corruption in government, systemic racial or ethnic violence, or denial of a fair public trial. Some country reports, including for Afghanistan, do address human rights abuses against women.
"We were asked to edit down the human rights reports to the bare minimum of what was statutorily required," said Michael Honigstein, the former director of African Affairs at the State Department's Bureau of Human Rights, Democracy, and Labor. He and his office helped compile the initial reports.
Over the past week, since the draft country reports leaked to the press, the Trump administration has come under fire for its portrayals of El Salvador, Israel, and Russia.
The report on Israel—and the illegally occupied Palestinian territories, the Gaza Strip and the West Bank—is just nine pages. The brevity even drew the attention of Israeli media. The Times of Israel highlighted that it "is much shorter than last year's edition compiled under the Biden administration and contained no mention of the severe humanitarian crisis in Gaza."
Since the Hamas-led October 7, 2023 attack on Israel, Israeli forces have slaughtered over 60,000 Palestinians in Gaza, according to local officials—though experts warn the true toll is likely far higher. As Israel has restricted humanitarian aid in recent months, over 200 people have starved to death, including 103 children.
The U.S. report on Israel does not mention the genocide case that Israel faces at the International Court of Justice over the assault on Gaza, or the International Criminal Court arrest warrants issued for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant for alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity.
The section on war crimes and genocide only says that "terrorist organizations Hamas and Hezbollah continue to engage in the
indiscriminate targeting of Israeli civilians in violation of the law of armed conflict."
As the world mourns the killing of six more Palestinian media professionals in Gaza this week—which prompted calls for the United Nations Security Council to convene an emergency meeting—the report's section on press freedom is also short and makes no mention of the hundreds of journalists killed in Israel's annihilation of the strip:
The law generally provided for freedom of expression, including for members of the press and other media, and the government generally respected this right for most Israelis. NGOs and journalists reported authorities restricted press coverage and limited certain forms of expression, especially in the context of criticism against the war or sympathy for Palestinians in Gaza.
Noting that "the human rights reports have been among the U.S. government's most-read documents," DAWN senior adviser and 32-year State Department official Charles Blaha said the "significant omissions" in this year's report on Israel, Gaza, and the West Bank render it "functionally useless for Congress and the public as nothing more than a pro-Israel document."
Like Klasing at Amnesty, Sarah Leah Whitson, DAWN's executive director, specifically called out the U.S. secretary of state.
"Secretary Rubio has revamped the State Department reports for one principal purpose: to whitewash Israeli crimes, including its horrific genocide and starvation in Gaza. The report shockingly includes not a word about the overwhelming evidence of genocide, mass starvation, and the deliberate bombardment of civilians in Gaza," she said. "Rubio has defied the letter and intent of U.S. laws requiring the State Department to report truthfully and comprehensively about every country's human rights abuses, instead offering up anodyne cover for his murderous friends in Tel Aviv."
The Tuesday release came after a coalition of LGBTQ+ and human rights organizations on Monday filed a lawsuit against the U.S. State Department over its refusal to release the congressionally mandated report.
This article has been updated with comment from DAWN.
"We will not sit idly by while political leaders manipulate voting maps to entrench their power and subvert our democracy," said the head of Common Cause.
As Republicans try to rig congressional maps in several states and Democrats threaten retaliatory measures, a pro-democracy watchdog on Tuesday unveiled new fairness standards underscoring that "independent redistricting commissions remain the gold standard for ending partisan gerrymandering."
Common Cause will hold an online media briefing Wednesday at noon Eastern time "to walk reporters though the six pieces of criteria the organization will use to evaluate any proposed maps."
The Washington, D.C.-based advocacy group said that "it will closely evaluate, but not automatically condemn, countermeasures" to Republican gerrymandering efforts—especially mid-decade redistricting not based on decennial censuses.
Amid the gerrymandering wars, we just launched 6 fairness criteria to hold all actors to the same principled standard: people first—not parties. Read our criteria here: www.commoncause.org/resources/po...
[image or embed]
— Common Cause (@commoncause.org) August 12, 2025 at 12:01 PM
Common Cause's six fairness criteria for mid-decade redistricting are:
"We will not sit idly by while political leaders manipulate voting maps to entrench their power and subvert our democracy," Common Cause president and CEO Virginia Kase Solomón said in a statement. "But neither will we call for unilateral political disarmament in the face of authoritarian tactics that undermine fair representation."
"We have established a fairness criteria that we will use to evaluate all countermeasures so we can respond to the most urgent threats to fair representation while holding all actors to the same principled standard: people—not parties—first," she added.
Common Cause's fairness criteria come amid the ongoing standoff between Republicans trying to gerrymander Texas' congressional map and Democratic lawmakers who fled the state in a bid to stymie a vote on the measure. Texas state senators on Tuesday approved the proposed map despite a walkout by most of their Democratic colleagues.
Leaders of several Democrat-controlled states, most notably California, have threatened retaliatory redistricting.
"This moment is about more than responding to a single threat—it's about building the movement for lasting reform," Kase Solomón asserted. "This is not an isolated political tactic; it is part of a broader march toward authoritarianism, dismantling people-powered democracy, and stripping away the people's ability to have a political voice and say in how they are governed."
"Texas law is clear: A pregnant person cannot be arrested and prosecuted for getting an abortion. No one is above the law, including officials entrusted with enforcing it," said an ACLU attorney.
When officials in Starr County, Texas arrested Lizelle Gonzalez in 2022 and charged her with murder for having a medication abortion—despite state law clearly prohibiting the prosecution of women for abortion care—she spent three days in jail, away from her children, and the highly publicized arrest was "deeply traumatizing."
Now, said her lawyers at the ACLU in court filings on Tuesday, officials in the county sheriff's and district attorney's offices must be held accountable for knowingly subjecting Gonzalez to wrongful prosecution.
Starr County District Attorney Gocha Ramirez ultimately dismissed the charge against Gonzalez, said the ACLU, but the Texas bar's investigation into Ramirez—which found multiple instances of misconduct related to Gonzalez's homicide charge—resulted in only minor punishment. Ramirez had to pay a small fine of $1,250 and was given one year of probated suspension.
"Without real accountability, Starr County's district attorney—and any other law enforcement actor—will not be deterred from abusing their power to unlawfully target people because of their personal beliefs, rather than the law," said the ACLU.
The state bar found that Ramirez allowed Gonzalez's indictment to go forward despite the fact that her homicide charge was "known not to be supported by probable cause."
Ramirez had denied that he was briefed on the facts of the case before it was prosecuted by his office, but the state bar "determined he was consulted by a prosecutor in his office beforehand and permitted it to go forward."
"Without real accountability, Starr County's district attorney—and any other law enforcement actor—will not be deterred from abusing their power to unlawfully target people because of their personal beliefs, rather than the law."
Sarah Corning, an attorney at the ACLU of Texas, said the prosecutors and law enforcement officers "ignored Texas law when they wrongfully arrested Lizelle Gonzalez for ending her pregnancy."
"They shattered her life in South Texas, violated her rights, and abused the power they swore to uphold," said Corning. "Texas law is clear: A pregnant person cannot be arrested and prosecuted for getting an abortion. No one is above the law, including officials entrusted with enforcing it."
The district attorney's office sought to have the ACLU's case dismissed in July 2024, raising claims of legal immunity.
A court denied Ramirez's motion, and the ACLU's discovery process that followed revealed "a coordinated effort between the Starr County sheriff's office and district attorney's office to violate Ms. Gonzalez's rights."
The officials' "wanton disregard for the rule of law and erroneous belief of their own invincibility is a frightening deviation from the offices' purposes: to seek justice," said Cecilia Garza, a partner at the law firm Garza Martinez, who is joining the ACLU in representing Gonzalez. "I am proud to represent Ms. Gonzalez in her fight for justice and redemption, and our team will not allow these abuses to continue in Starr County or any other county in the state of Texas."
Gonzalez's fight for justice comes as a wrongful death case in Texas—filed by an "anti-abortion legal terrorist" on behalf of a man whose girlfriend use medication from another state to end her pregnancy—moves forward, potentially jeopardizing access to abortion pills across the country.