Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

Countries that have been successful "have created a coherent system of education within which all policies and practices are designed to lead to high performance," says the report from the National Conference of State Legislatures. (Photo: alkruse24/flickr/cc)

Bipartisan Panel of State Lawmakers Agree: NCLB Has Failed US Kids

No Child Left Behind-driven policies have left the United States 'overwhelmingly underprepared to succeed in the 21st century economy'

Deirdre Fulton

Confirming what many public education advocates have been saying for years, a new report from a bipartisan panel of state lawmakers declares that the United States has little to show for more than a decade of reform efforts inspired by the controversial No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB).

The report released Tuesday from the National Conference of State Legislatures, No Time to Lose: How to Build a World-Class Education System State by State (pdf), charges that "[s]tates have found little success" in developing an effective education system. Indeed, the executive summary reads, "Recent reforms have underperformed because of silver bullet strategies and piecemeal approaches."

Touching on key aspects of NCLB such as high-stakes testing, the report explains:

In an effort to boost achievement for all students, policymakers have tried a number of approaches and passed a number of state and federal laws. These have included increasing funding, reducing class size, enhancing school choice, improving school technology and teacher quality, more testing and tougher test-based accountability. While some policies have had marginal success in some states or districts, success has not been as widespread as policymakers had hoped.

In turn, the summary states, "most state education systems are falling dangerously behind the world in a number of international comparisons and on our own National Assessment of Educational Progress, leaving the United States overwhelmingly underprepared to succeed in the 21st century economy."

The 22 state legislators behind the report—half Democrats, half Republicans—suggest that by studying "high-performing systems" in other countries, the U.S. could regain its footing. 

The "silver bullet" approach employed by U.S. states "is not what the study group found in high-performing countries," the report points out. "They do not look to single policy shifts to improve student outcomes. Instead, they have created a coherent system of education within which all policies and practices are designed to lead to high performance."

As the Washington Post reports:

The group examined 10 nations that fare well on international comparisons, including China, Canada, Singapore, Estonia, Japan, Poland, and Korea, and discovered common elements: strong early childhood education, especially for disadvantaged children; more selective teacher preparation programs; better pay and professional working conditions for teachers; and time to help build curriculum linked to high standards.

It also says that high-performing countries tend not to administer standardized tests annually, as the United States does, but instead at key transition points in a student's career. The assessments emphasize essays over multiple-choice in an effort to gauge students' complex thinking skills, according to the report. And the tests cost more than states are used to paying for standardized tests, but "these countries prioritize this investment as a small fraction of the total cost of their education system, knowing that cheaper, less effective, less rigorous assessments will not lead to world-class teaching or high student achievement."

The Guardian zooms in on another significant finding:

The report focuses, at one point, on the American system of educational funding: in many states, driven by property taxes in individual districts, the system of school funding all but ensures that the children of the wealthy have more resources devoted to their educational achievements, while lower-income students who could significantly benefit from more spending end up in schools asked to do more—subsidized school lunches, remedial education, counseling—with less.

And yet, in other countries where students outpace Americans, the opposite is true. "Providing additional resources to schools serving disadvantaged, struggling students is a priority," the report says. "These countries demonstrate that, with added support, struggling students can meet high expectations."

"Inversely, American students from the wealthiest communities are most likely to get the best teachers and the finest facilities because of the way we structure our finance systems."

Fortunately, the era of NCLB is over, as the law has been replaced by the new Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA). 

ESSA "ends the NCLB requirement that states look almost exclusively at test scores to determine whether and how to reward or sanction schools, and also ends the Race To The Top requirement that states use tests that are linked to the Common Core State Standards in order to evaluate and reward or punish not only students and schools, but also teachers," author and University of San Francisco School of Education dean Kevin Kumashiro wrote in December. 

However, he said at the time, "the bad news is that this new law still presumes that testing is the magic bullet."

With the National Conference of State Legislatures report warning against such bullets—whether silver or magic—Kumashiro's conclusion seems prescient: "The silver lining is that this law is scheduled for reauthorization in four years, not the typical seven," he wrote. "Let's use that time to craft a framework that will truly support every student's success and a public school system that embodies the promises of our nation."

Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.

This is the world we live in. This is the world we cover.

Because of people like you, another world is possible. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. Common Dreams is not your normal news site. We don't survive on clicks. We don't want advertising dollars. We want the world to be a better place. But we can't do it alone. It doesn't work that way. We need you. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do. Without Your Support We Simply Don't Exist.

Trump's CIA Considered Kidnapping or Assassinating Assange: Report

"The Biden administration must drop its charges against Assange immediately."

Jake Johnson ·

'Carrying Water for Big Corporations': Sinema Faces Backlash for Opposing Tax Hikes

"Make no mistake, if she sides with her wealthy donors and kills popular investments to jump-start the economy, everyday families—including across Arizona—will pay the price."

Jake Johnson ·

UN Chief Warns Humanity Is 'Unacceptably Close to Nuclear Annihilation'

"Now is the time to lift the cloud of nuclear conflict for good," United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres said ahead of the International Day for the Total Elimination of Nuclear Weapons.

Jake Johnson ·

Coalition Slams UN Food Summit for Peddling 'Corporate-Led False Solutions' to Hunger

"The U.N. has finally made it clear what 'multilateralism' is all about—paying lip service to the people while skewing priorities for the interests of imperialists and monopoly capitalists."

Jake Johnson ·

'Political Malpractice': House Democrats' Bill Wouldn't Add Dental to Medicare Until 2028

"I don't want to see it drawn out to as far as the House has proposed," Sen. Bernie Sanders said during a recent press call.

Jake Johnson ·

Support our work.

We are independent, non-profit, advertising-free and 100% reader supported.

Subscribe to our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values.
Direct to your inbox.

Subscribe to our Newsletter.

Common Dreams, Inc. Founded 1997. Registered 501(c3) Non-Profit | Privacy Policy
Common Dreams Logo