12-year-old Tamir Rice was shot and killed by police in Cleveland, Ohio on November 22, 2014. (Photo: AP)
Mar 02, 2015
Tamir Rice, the 12-year-old killed by police in Cleveland, Ohio last November, was "directly and proximately" responsible for his own shooting death, argue the city's laywers in response to a civil lawsuit filed by the boy's family.
Rice was killed while playing in a park with a toy gun, which Cleveland police officer Timothy Loehmann claimed he mistook as a real weapon when he shot the boy.
The lawsuit--filed in December and amended in January--charges that the city of Cleveland--including Loehmann and his partner, officer Frank Garmback--as well as 100 other unnamed 911 operators, police officers, and city employees violated the family's civil rights in the November 22 shooting.
The city's defense, filed in U.S. district court on Friday, lists (pdf) 20 defenses in total, including a claim that Rice failed to "exercise due care to avoid injury" in the incident and that some of Rice's family members, particularly his mother and 14-year-old sister, Tajai, are responsible for any damages done to themselves during the incident.
Rice's shooting death fueled ongoing protests in the U.S. against police militarization and racial profiling in the wake of the police killings of Michael Brown, Eric Garner, and other unarmed black men and women around the country.
Video footage of Rice's shooting in Cuddell Recreational Center shows Loehmann firing at Tamir within seconds of arriving at the scene. Following the shooting, the footage shows that neither Loehmann nor Garmback move to administer first aid to the boy as he lies bleeding in the snow.
Rice's family, as well as civil rights advocates, say the video evidence shows Rice was not given any time to respond to any orders. They also dispute the city's claim that Tamir's sister Tajai caused her own injuries after both Loehmann and his partner tackled and handcuffed her as she attempted to reach her brother, screaming, "My baby brother, they killed my baby brother!"
According to the suit, when Rice's mother Samaria arrived, officers gave her the option of going to the hospital with Tamir or staying with her handcuffed daughter in the squad car.
The lawsuit also refers to the Justice Department's separate report on the Cleveland Police Department's history of using excessive force against suspects, as well as revelations that Loehmann was hired by the city after failing necessary tests to join other forces in Akron, Euclid, and Parma Heights. Loehmann's personnel file from November 2012 described that the officer "could not follow simple directions, could not communicate clear thoughts nor recollections, and his handgun performance was dismal."
"I do believe that a 12-year-old child died unnecessarily at the hands of Cleveland police officers and I do believe that certain officers shouldn't have been entitled to wear the uniform," Walter Madison, one of the attorneys representing the Rice family, said last week.
The lawsuit also accuses the city of using a current investigation by the Cuyahoga County Sheriff's Office into the shooting as an excuse to withhold evidence.
In its defense document, the city maintained--as it has in the past--that the force did not know of Loehmann's background when he was hired. It also said it could not respond to the suit in full because of the Cuyahoga County probe and denied that it was using that investigation to cover up information about the shooting.
Madison added to NBC News that Rice was "shot and killed unnecessarily... at the hands of an unfit police officer(s) and a division of police that continues to endorse their behavior."
Join Us: News for people demanding a better world
Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place. We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference. Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
Nadia Prupis
Nadia Prupis is a former Common Dreams staff writer. She wrote on media policy for Truthout.org and has been published in New America Media and AlterNet. She graduated from UC Santa Barbara with a BA in English in 2008.
Tamir Rice, the 12-year-old killed by police in Cleveland, Ohio last November, was "directly and proximately" responsible for his own shooting death, argue the city's laywers in response to a civil lawsuit filed by the boy's family.
Rice was killed while playing in a park with a toy gun, which Cleveland police officer Timothy Loehmann claimed he mistook as a real weapon when he shot the boy.
The lawsuit--filed in December and amended in January--charges that the city of Cleveland--including Loehmann and his partner, officer Frank Garmback--as well as 100 other unnamed 911 operators, police officers, and city employees violated the family's civil rights in the November 22 shooting.
The city's defense, filed in U.S. district court on Friday, lists (pdf) 20 defenses in total, including a claim that Rice failed to "exercise due care to avoid injury" in the incident and that some of Rice's family members, particularly his mother and 14-year-old sister, Tajai, are responsible for any damages done to themselves during the incident.
Rice's shooting death fueled ongoing protests in the U.S. against police militarization and racial profiling in the wake of the police killings of Michael Brown, Eric Garner, and other unarmed black men and women around the country.
Video footage of Rice's shooting in Cuddell Recreational Center shows Loehmann firing at Tamir within seconds of arriving at the scene. Following the shooting, the footage shows that neither Loehmann nor Garmback move to administer first aid to the boy as he lies bleeding in the snow.
Rice's family, as well as civil rights advocates, say the video evidence shows Rice was not given any time to respond to any orders. They also dispute the city's claim that Tamir's sister Tajai caused her own injuries after both Loehmann and his partner tackled and handcuffed her as she attempted to reach her brother, screaming, "My baby brother, they killed my baby brother!"
According to the suit, when Rice's mother Samaria arrived, officers gave her the option of going to the hospital with Tamir or staying with her handcuffed daughter in the squad car.
The lawsuit also refers to the Justice Department's separate report on the Cleveland Police Department's history of using excessive force against suspects, as well as revelations that Loehmann was hired by the city after failing necessary tests to join other forces in Akron, Euclid, and Parma Heights. Loehmann's personnel file from November 2012 described that the officer "could not follow simple directions, could not communicate clear thoughts nor recollections, and his handgun performance was dismal."
"I do believe that a 12-year-old child died unnecessarily at the hands of Cleveland police officers and I do believe that certain officers shouldn't have been entitled to wear the uniform," Walter Madison, one of the attorneys representing the Rice family, said last week.
The lawsuit also accuses the city of using a current investigation by the Cuyahoga County Sheriff's Office into the shooting as an excuse to withhold evidence.
In its defense document, the city maintained--as it has in the past--that the force did not know of Loehmann's background when he was hired. It also said it could not respond to the suit in full because of the Cuyahoga County probe and denied that it was using that investigation to cover up information about the shooting.
Madison added to NBC News that Rice was "shot and killed unnecessarily... at the hands of an unfit police officer(s) and a division of police that continues to endorse their behavior."
Nadia Prupis
Nadia Prupis is a former Common Dreams staff writer. She wrote on media policy for Truthout.org and has been published in New America Media and AlterNet. She graduated from UC Santa Barbara with a BA in English in 2008.
Tamir Rice, the 12-year-old killed by police in Cleveland, Ohio last November, was "directly and proximately" responsible for his own shooting death, argue the city's laywers in response to a civil lawsuit filed by the boy's family.
Rice was killed while playing in a park with a toy gun, which Cleveland police officer Timothy Loehmann claimed he mistook as a real weapon when he shot the boy.
The lawsuit--filed in December and amended in January--charges that the city of Cleveland--including Loehmann and his partner, officer Frank Garmback--as well as 100 other unnamed 911 operators, police officers, and city employees violated the family's civil rights in the November 22 shooting.
The city's defense, filed in U.S. district court on Friday, lists (pdf) 20 defenses in total, including a claim that Rice failed to "exercise due care to avoid injury" in the incident and that some of Rice's family members, particularly his mother and 14-year-old sister, Tajai, are responsible for any damages done to themselves during the incident.
Rice's shooting death fueled ongoing protests in the U.S. against police militarization and racial profiling in the wake of the police killings of Michael Brown, Eric Garner, and other unarmed black men and women around the country.
Video footage of Rice's shooting in Cuddell Recreational Center shows Loehmann firing at Tamir within seconds of arriving at the scene. Following the shooting, the footage shows that neither Loehmann nor Garmback move to administer first aid to the boy as he lies bleeding in the snow.
Rice's family, as well as civil rights advocates, say the video evidence shows Rice was not given any time to respond to any orders. They also dispute the city's claim that Tamir's sister Tajai caused her own injuries after both Loehmann and his partner tackled and handcuffed her as she attempted to reach her brother, screaming, "My baby brother, they killed my baby brother!"
According to the suit, when Rice's mother Samaria arrived, officers gave her the option of going to the hospital with Tamir or staying with her handcuffed daughter in the squad car.
The lawsuit also refers to the Justice Department's separate report on the Cleveland Police Department's history of using excessive force against suspects, as well as revelations that Loehmann was hired by the city after failing necessary tests to join other forces in Akron, Euclid, and Parma Heights. Loehmann's personnel file from November 2012 described that the officer "could not follow simple directions, could not communicate clear thoughts nor recollections, and his handgun performance was dismal."
"I do believe that a 12-year-old child died unnecessarily at the hands of Cleveland police officers and I do believe that certain officers shouldn't have been entitled to wear the uniform," Walter Madison, one of the attorneys representing the Rice family, said last week.
The lawsuit also accuses the city of using a current investigation by the Cuyahoga County Sheriff's Office into the shooting as an excuse to withhold evidence.
In its defense document, the city maintained--as it has in the past--that the force did not know of Loehmann's background when he was hired. It also said it could not respond to the suit in full because of the Cuyahoga County probe and denied that it was using that investigation to cover up information about the shooting.
Madison added to NBC News that Rice was "shot and killed unnecessarily... at the hands of an unfit police officer(s) and a division of police that continues to endorse their behavior."
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.