Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

Defund the Police

Defund the Police.  (Photo: Chandan Khanna/AFP via Getty Images)

Why Defund the Police? A Story

Joan Steinau Lester

On my way down Central Park Drive into Berkeley’s Tilden Park yesterday, I saw a white man of about sixty—twenty years my junior—standing by a black car. I paused to see if he needed help. He made a small hand gesture, which I took as a “drive on” wave, so I continued. But fifty feet later, troubled by something about him, I decided the gesture had been ambiguous. Brought up by parents who always stopped for strangers, I flashed my blinkers and reversed.

Rolling down my window, I asked, “Are you okay?”

“Don’t try to qualify me.” He stared angrily.

“Do you need anything, are you all right?”

“You’re not okay!” He moved toward me. “Leave me alone!”

“Don’t be so hostile. I was just trying to help you.”

“You’re the one who’s not okay!” he screamed, waving his arms, shouting words I was too shocked to take in. “Get out of here!”

“Okay, I will,” I said and rolled down the hill for my morning hike.

But my heart raced. Tears sprouted behind my lids. If he hadn’t wanted assistance, a brief “No, thanks” would have sufficed. The society is really unraveling, I thought. This isn’t how the social compact is supposed to work, where people have compassion and try to help each other.

I considered calling the police, because the man was clearly not well, but imagined how quickly that interaction could devolve. If an officer asked, “Do you need help?” and he reacted as belligerently as he had with me, the cop would likely end up arresting him. Maybe violently. Even with white skin, he wouldn’t be safe. Isn’t there a mental health officer in Berkeley, I wondered?

Too upset to start my usual meditative walk, I slipped on my mask and stopped the first person I saw in the park. “Can I tell you something scary that just happened to me?” She edged away, either from physical distancing concerns or fears that I might be unbalanced, but after I finished she urged me to alert someone. Without my cell phone I couldn’t do it then, so focused on calming myself and savoring the peaceful, tree-filled paths I had come to enjoy.

An hour and a half later, when I drove back up Central Park Drive the black car remained. At first it looked empty, but when I pulled alongside I saw the man slumped in the driver’s seat.

The main city number simply asked for a message, with a promise to call back. I told the story on voicemail, saying I did not want police, but hoped we had a mental health professional who might see about an agitated man. “What if someone else stops to help and he assaults them?” I asked, wondering if simply screaming at a Good Samaritan would be grounds to check on him. And with so much money going for COVID, did we have trained people?

The Black Lives Matter demand to Defund Police already made sense to me because of systemic racism, but this made it crystal clear that in most situations where we reflexively call police—disturbed-appearing man in public; schizophrenic teen terrifying his parents (as my nephew did)—what we need instead is a crisis line that can respond.

I received a response from a city worker and learned that in Berkeley we do have a mental health triage team. “Wonderful,” I said.

“But it only operates on certain days,” he added. “Because we don’t have the funding for more.” Still, he gave me that number and again I left a message, making it clear that I was concerned for the man’s well being and that of others who might encounter him. Once more I received a callback, referring me to the crisis team (not available that day). If only we had the money to support it full time!

Let us use this transformative moment to reduce bloated, militarized police budgets and adequately fund social programs. Let’s stop criminalizing mental illness and poverty by developing a new habit, where we call police less and mental health workers more. That way, we’ll help create true public safety.

Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
Joan Steinau Lester

Joan Steinau Lester

Dr. Joan Steinau Lester is the author of six books, including the novels "Black, White, Other: In Search of Nina Armstrong" (2017) and "Mama's Child" (2013) and, a forthcoming memoir from the University of Wisconsin Press "Loving Before Loving: A Marriage in Black and White" in the spring of 2021. Her website is here:

We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.

Federal Judge Allows 'Untenable' Plan to Send Juvenile Inmates to Angola Prison

"The move defies all common sense and best practices, and it will cause irrevocable damage to our youth and families," said one children's advocate.

Julia Conley ·

'Catastrophic': Arizona Judge Allows 1864 Abortion Ban to Go Into Effect

"No archaic law should dictate our reproductive freedom," said one rights advocate.

Julia Conley ·

US Progressives Express Solidarity With Iranian Protesters After Death of Mahsa Amini

"The right to choose belongs to us all, from hijabs to reproductive care," said Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.

Julia Conley ·

Critics of Louisiana LNG Project 'Hopeful' as Huge Sales Contracts Canceled

"The fight is not over," says one activist, but "from tax breaks to pollution and now to these recent financial downswings, we have all the evidence we need to understand that Driftwood will be a parasite."

Jessica Corbett ·

DHS Officials Urge Biden to End 'Disastrous Leadership' of Embattled IG

In an anonymous letter, the Homeland Security staffers say Inspector General Joseph Cuffari's actions "embarrass the entire agency."

Brett Wilkins ·

Common Dreams Logo