

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE NEWSLETTER
Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
To donate by check, phone, or other method, see our More Ways to Give page.


Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
Fast-food CEO Andy Puzder, President Donald Trump's pick to head the Labor Department, withdrew his nomination Wednesday afternoon.
"While I won't be serving in the administration, I fully support the President and his highly qualified team," Puzder said in a statement.
An unnamed source close to Puzder said to CBS News ahead of his formal statement that it was unlikely he would sit for his Senate confirmation hearing scheduled for Thursday because "I think he's very tired of the abuse."
RoseAnn DeMoro, executive director of National Nurses United, welcomed the news on Twitter, writing, "Puzder felt abused? Try working for him!"
His nomination drew fierce opposition, as fast food workers have said the stores he oversees, including Hardee's and Carl's Jr., have engaged in wage theft, discrimination, and sexual harassment. Current and former Labor Department employees also charged in a letter that Puzder has made "derisive public comments about his restaurants' employees and other low-wage workers."
Given his opposition to worker protections, said Food & Water Watch executive director Wenonah Hauter, "Installing him as Labor Secretary would have had extremely negative consequences for the safety of poultry workers and USDA inspectors who have had to endure intolerable conditions in plants that have been under investigation by OSHA."
Christine Owens, executive director of the National Employment Law Project, added Wednesday: "Americans support raising the minimum wage, expanding eligibility for overtime pay, ensuring safe and healthy workplaces, extending affordable healthcare, protecting workers' retirement savings, safeguarding the right to organize and bargain collectively, and creating good, family-sustaining jobs."
"On all of these issues," Owens said, "Mr. Puzder's record was the exact opposite of where most Americans stand. His loss of support in the Senate mirrors his lack of support in the public."
Indeed, Senate Democrats had called for him to withdraw his name, and Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) described him as "one of the most anti-worker nominees to any cabinet position, and probably the most anti-worker to the Department of Labor ever."
The development "is welcome news for working people," said Heidi Shierholz, senior economist and director of policy at Economic Policy Institute.
"It was abundantly clear from Mr. Puzder's rhetoric opposing basic labor laws and regulations that protect workers' rights and wages, as well as his record of violating those laws as an employer, that he was ill-suited for the role of chief advocate for working people. Americans need a labor secretary who respects the rule of law, who will work to raise wages and uphold basic labor protections like the minimum wage, paid leave, safe workplaces, and overtime pay. President Trump should nominate someone who will look out for working people, not the profits of big business or the incomes of the one percent," she continued.
Echoing that sentiment, Darin Brooks, a Hardee's worker and a member of Raise Up $15, the Fight for $15 chapter in Durham, N.C., declared that "we can't and won't back down until the Trump Administration gives us a real Labor Secretary who will put working people over corporate profits."
Seven Republican U.S. senators were reportedly withholding support for Puzder. He would have needed 50 votes to pass with a tie-breaking vote from Vice President Mike Pence.
* * *
To find out more about Puzder's views on worker pay, women, and the industry's reliance on undocumented workers, watch this Feb. 13 Democracy Now! interview with Saru Jayaraman of the Restaurant Opportunities Centers United:
For the third time since anti-worker fast food CEO Andy Puzder's nomination for Labor Secretary was announced, fast food workers are flooding the streets in protest.
| Tweets about #AndyPuzder OR #NotOurLaborSec OR #fightfor15 |
Days before Puzder's confirmation hearing on Thursday, hundreds of cashiers and cooks are rallying in front of the St. Louis headquarters of Hardee's and the Anaheim, Calif. offices of CKE Restaurants, the conglomerate overseen by Puzder that includes Carl's Jr. and Hardee's restaurants.
Fast food workers aren't the only people objecting to Puzder's nomination. Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) sent a blistering letter (pdf) to Puzder Monday in which she charged him with "a sneering contempt for the workers in your stores and a vehement opposition to the laws you will be charged with enforcing."
Indeed, workers say that wage theft, discrimination, and sexual harassment are rampant at Puzder's chains. Those allegations are backed up by publicly available data and have also prompted multiple investigations from the Department of Labor, as media reports have noted.
"Andy Puzder is unfit to be Labor Secretary--period," said Angel Gallegos, a Carl's Jr. cashier from Los Angeles, Calif. "We're stepping up our fight to demand that Puzder withdraw his nomination, and if he won't, then the U.S. Senate should reject him. Working families need a real labor secretary who will fight for ordinary people, not powerful corporations."
One former Carl's Jr. employee spoke out Monday on Democracy Now! about being ignored when she reported sexual harassment while working for Puzder's chain:
Puzder has also recently come under fire for hiring an undocumented immigrant as a housekeeper and avoiding taxes on her labor, as Common Dreams reported.
In fact, the battle over Puzder is heating up, The Hill reports, with Democrats seeing his nomination as on even shakier ground than that of Education Secretary Betsy DeVos, whose confirmation required a tie-breaking vote from the vice president for the first time in U.S. history.
" Donald Trump ran on the promise of putting workers first, and what he's done in nominating Puzder, is show he never intended to keep that promise," a Senate Democratic aide commented to The Hill. "For a lot of voters, that's not what they had in mind when they entrusted Trump with their futures."
Watch the rally at Carl's Jr. headquarters here:
And follow the protests nationwide on social media, under the hashtags #NotOurLaborSec and #Fightfor15.
Labor unions and workers' rights advocates are pressuring President Donald Trump to drop his nominee for Labor Secretary, Andy Puzder, over the fast-food CEO's recent admission that he had hired an undocumented immigrant as a housekeeper.
The AFL-CIO, the nation's largest labor union, penned a letter (pdf) to Trump--signed by 128 progressive organizations, including the Service Employees International Union (SEIU), Jobs With Justice, and the NAACP--calling on him to ditch Puzder and pick "a suitable nominee who shows proper respect for working people and our nation's employment laws."
Puzder on Monday admitted that he had also failed to pay taxes on his housekeeper while she was in his employ, although he claimed he did not know of her immigration status at the time. He said he later fired her and has since paid back what he owed--but opponents say that's reason enough to drop him.
Indeed, they say, Puzder only repaid his taxes when his nomination was imminent.
"Mr. Puzder is an experienced attorney and a CEO of a major fast-food chain, so he cannot plausibly claim ignorance of his legal obligations as an employer," the letter reads. "We already have ample cause to doubt Mr. Puzder's fitness for the job as Secretary of Labor, and this latest news confirms our view that he should not be confirmed."
"If he cannot be trusted to follow even one of the most basic laws of employment in his own home, there is no way we can expect him to enforce the crucial laws the Department of Labor oversees on behalf of working people," it states.
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) likewise called for Trump to withdraw Puzder's nomination, calling him "one of the most anti-worker nominees to any cabinet position, and probably the most anti-worker to the Department of Labor ever."
Watch below:
The letter comes just before large-scale protests against Puzder's nomination are scheduled to launch nationwide. The actions, organized by the workers' rights collective Fight for $15, will take place Monday, days before his confirmation hearing, which was rescheduled for the fifth time this week and is now set to take place February 16.
Puzder is the CEO of CKE Restaurants, which operates Hardee's and Carl's Jr., among other chains. Workers from several of Puzder's restaurants in January filed 33 complaints with state and federal agencies alleging wage theft, sexual harassment, and retaliation against organizing. His record continues to be a major rallying point for opponents.
"Andy Puzder is unfit to be Labor Secretary--period," said Angel Gallegos, a Carl's Jr. cashier from Los Angeles, California. "We're stepping up our fight to demand that Puzder withdraw his nomination, and if he won't, then the U.S. Senate should reject him. Working families need a real Labor Secretary who will fight for ordinary people, not powerful corporations."
Doreatha Hines, a Hardee's cashier from Orlando, Florida, said, "By picking Puzder, Donald Trump has shown that instead of taking on the rigged economy, he wants to rig it up even more."
"If Trump is going to be a president for the fast-food corporations instead of for the fast-food workers he is going to be on the wrong side of history," Hines said. "And one thing is for sure, whether Puzder's nomination is confirmed, denied or withdrawn: we won't back down for one minute in our demands for $15 an hour and union rights for all working Americans."
With President Donald Trump's Labor secretary pick, fast-food CEO Andy Puzder, facing increasing scrutiny and a growing opposition campaign, four GOP senators are reportedly "withholding judgement" on the controversial nominee.
According to CNN reporter Manu Raju on Tuesday, Republican Sens. Susan Collins (Maine), Lisa Murkowski (Alaska), Tim Scott (S.C.), and Johnny Isakson (Ga.) are "all withholding judgment on Puzder's nomination after he revealed he hired undocumented immigrant."
That revelation came Monday in a statement from Puzder:
My wife and I employed a housekeeper for a few years, during which I was unaware that she was not legally permitted to work in the U.S. When I learned of her status, we immediately ended her employment and offered her assistance in getting legal status. We have fully paid back taxes to the IRS and the state of California and submitted all required paperwork.
As news outlets have noted, similar admissions have torpedoed previous nominees' chances in the past.
Labor advocates said the revelations raised more questions about his fitness for the post.
"Puzder wants to be the chief enforcer of the nation's labor laws, but his history of flouting those laws makes it clear that he is unfit for the job," wrote Economic Policy Institute vice president Ross Eisenbrey on Tuesday. "Puzder's violations of immigration law make him a strange choice to be a cabinet officer in President Donald Trump's administration, given the president's near hysteria about the presence of undocumented immigrant workers in the United States."
And in her statement about the news, National Employment Law Project executive director Christine Owens asked, "How can anyone--especially members of the U.S. Senate--still think he is qualified to lead the Labor Department?"
Also giving Puzder trouble is a "brutally damning" essay published Tuesday at the Washington Post.
"The headlines ponder what [Puzder's nomination] may mean for working people in America, but I already know," wrote JoAnn Wise, who worked for 21 years at Hardee's, one of the major restaurants in Puzder's CKE Restaurants orbit.
Wise continued:
I already know what Trump/Puzder economics look like because I'm living it every day. Despite giving everything I had to Puzder's company for 21 years, I left without a penny of savings, with no healthcare, and no pension. Now, while I live in poverty, Trump, who promised to fix the rigged economy, has chosen for labor secretary someone who wants to rig it up even more. He's chosen the chief executive of a company who recently made more than $10 million in a year, while I'm scraping by on Supplemental Security payments.
The cooks and cashiers at Hardee's and Carl's Jr. are the reason Puzder can take home more than $10 million in a single year and live in a plush mansion with movie star neighbors--while his workers like me skip meals to pay our rent and are forced to live in homeless shelters.
We are their corporate strategy: Pay us as little as legally allowed, steal from our meager paychecks as needed, and force us onto public assistance to get by. Sadly, that's the America Trump and Puzder believe in: an America where workers give everything to an employer, and in return, receive nothing. Their America means that an older woman in retirement fighting a chronic illness has to rely on Supplemental Security Income to survive.
Among those drawing attention to Wise's op-ed was Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), who sits on the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions--where Puzder will eventually appear for his confirmation hearing. The hearing has been postponed multiple times.
The Los Angeles Times reports:
Sen. Patty Murray (D-Wash.), the top Democrat on the committee, did not address the housekeeper issue directly Tuesday. But she said Puzder had "a lot of explaining to do."
"Eight weeks and four canceled hearing dates since his nomination was announced, we still have yet to see a single shred of paperwork from Mr. Puzder--but what we have heard is story after story about how he spent his career squeezing workers for profit, leaving many with lost wages, no financial security and no retirement," she said.
Meanwhile, Puzder opponents took the occasion of Tuesday's 24th anniversary of the Family Medical Leave Act to bolster their campaign against the nominee, whom they said would weaken such critical worker protections.
Others tweeted about Puzder under the hashtag #AntiLaborSecretary:
U.S. Labor Secretary nominee and billionaire fast food chain owner Andy Puzder has been slapped with 33 labor complaints--about wage theft, sexual harassment, and unfair labor practices--from cooks and cashiers at his own fast food chains, all filed on Thursday at state and federal agencies.
"If Andy Puzder can't be trusted to pay his workers what they've earned, why should we expect him to enforce laws meant to protect working Americans?"
--Angel Gallegos,
Carl's Jr. cook
Cooks and cashiers who work for CKE Restaurants, Puzder's fast food conglomerate that includes the chains Hardee's and Carl's Jr., filed the complaints along with labor advocacy groups exactly one week before Puzder's confirmation hearing before the U.S. Senate.
"The filings reveal a restaurant chain rife with labor violations," wrote the Fight for $15 campaign in a press statement. "In Whittier, California, a worker went a full month without a paycheck. In Durham, N.C., workers were paid via debit card that included transaction fees that took hourly wages below the federal minimum wage of $7.25. In Oakland, California, a gay Carl's Jr. worker was repeatedly harassed by his manager, who told customers and co-workers that he 'likes boys' and used a feminized version of his name."
"Recently the restaurant I worked at went an entire month without paying me a dime, and they only agreed to pay me after I stopped coming to work in protest," said Angel Gallegos, a Carl's Jr. cook in Los Angeles, in a statement. "If Andy Puzder can't be trusted to pay his workers what they've earned, why should we expect him to enforce laws meant to protect working Americans?"
Fight for $15 adds:
In an interview last year, Puzder said he prefers machines to workers because they "never take a vacation, they never show up late, there's never a slip-and-fall, or an age, sex, or race discrimination case." And in a 2011 address to students at Westmont College, he detailed his hiring practices saying "In fast food, you sort of compete for the best of the worst," adding that at Hardee's his employees were "the worst of the worst."
"In addition to complaints by workers," the group writes, "local Fight for $15 chapters filed seven Unfair Labor Practices complaints against CKE franchisees for illegal surveillance, threats, and intimidation of workers. In one case, a franchisee sent an internal memo to employees stating that 'the press is NOT our friend' and that 'our franchise agreement with CKE' requires that 'no one in this franchise is to talk to any reporter or individual asking questions about our operations.'"
One filing specifically addresses the fact that CKE outsourced administrative positions to the Philippines, something the company acknowledges, which contradicts President Donald Trump's virulent rhetoric against outsourcing jobs to other countries. In fact, in this past week "Trump warned that he would impose a 'substantial border tax' on companies that move their manufacturing out of the United States," the Associated Press reports. "He also promised tax advantages to companies that produce products domestically."
The filings came as workers in 31 cities protested against Puzder, marking the second series of nationwide protests by employees of CKE restaurants since Puzder's nomination as labor secretary.
Observers are sharing images and videos from the nationwide protests on Twitter:
Tweets about #antilaborsecretary OR #fightfor15 OR #notourlaborsec
Building on a growing resistance movement, more than 100 actions are planned nationwide for Tuesday to demand U.S. senators vote against President Donald Trump's controversial cabinet picks.
| #SwampCabinet Tweets |
The rallies and protests at local offices of Democratic and Republican senators will urge lawmakers to "Stop the #SwampCabinet"--from public school enemy and Education nominee Betsy DeVos to anti-worker Labor nominee Andrew Puzder to Scott Pruitt, Trump's Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) pick who has made a career of suing the EPA.
" Donald Trump riled up crowds claiming he'd 'drain the swamp' and chase corruption out of Washington, but so far his politics have only furthered a culture of corruption, and nowhere is that clearer than in the greed and hate embodied by the nominees to his Swamp Cabinet," said Vicki Kaplan, organizing director for MoveOn.org, which is coordinating the demonstrations along with People's Action and the Working Families Party.
"Millions of Americans are taking action--meeting, marching, and organizing--to ensure Trump and the GOP don't take away our healthcare, destroy public education, pollute our air and water, and put in charge billionaires and racists who look out for only themselves at the expense of the rest of us," Kaplan said.
So far, the Senate has confirmed two Trump cabinet nominees: retired Marine Gen. James Mattis to run the Department of Defense and retired Gen. John Kelly to lead the Department of Homeland Security. Votes are expected on Monday on former ExxonMobil CEO Rex Tillerson's nomination as Secretary of State and Rep. Mike Pompeo's (R-Kansas) bid to lead the CIA.
Other nominees have faced a tougher road to confirmation.
McClatchy reported Monday afternoon that the top Democrat on the Senate Judiciary Committee, Sen. Dianne Feinstein (Calif.), will request a delay on the confirmation vote on Sen. Jeff Sessions for U.S. attorney general. The vote was supposed to take place Tuesday and will now take place January 31.
The Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions vote on DeVos for secretary of the Department of Education was similarly postponed until January 31 to give members time to review the billionaire's letter to the Office of Government Ethics outlining steps she agreed to take to avoid conflicts of interests. On Monday, 10 Democrats on the committee and Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) formally asked chairman Lamar Alexander (R-Tenn.) to have a second confirmation hearing for DeVos; Alexander denied that request.
Tuesday will likely see Senate Commerce Committee votes on Transportation Secretary nominee Elaine Chao and Wilbur Ross to head the Commerce Department.
Also taking place Tuesday are confirmation hearings for Rep. Tom Price, the Obamacare opponent who Trump wants to head the Department of Health and Human Services; Rep. Mick Mulvaney (S.C.), Trump's pick for Office of Management and Budget director; and wrestling magnate Linda McMahon, nominated to head the Small Business Administration.
Price already sat for one hearing before the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions, but the Senate Finance Committee, which will grill him on Tuesday, is the one to vote on his confirmation.
Ahead of his Finance Committee hearing, Democratic Sens. Patty Murray (Wash.) and Ron Wyden (Ore.) demanded more documents about his stock trading--which has already been the focus of intense scrutiny, along with his intent to cut the healthcare safety net.
"Most Americans didn't vote for Trump, but nearly all of us will suffer under his administration," said Seong-Ah Cho, who is participating in the People's Lobby #SwampCabinet event in Chicago on Tuesday. "It's on us to use this crisis, and all our fear and anger, to come together in a powerful movement that will not only resist Trump's agenda, but also fight for our progressive future."
Throughout the campaign and the transition period leading up to the Inauguration, whenever Donald Trump was caught lying or tweeting something outrageous we were told by his acolytes that we should ignore his words and instead pay attention to his deeds. Kellyanne Conway, Trump's Queen of Bull, who has moved from campaign manager to White House counselor, actually has argued that what he says should not be taken literally, even telling CNN's Chris Cuomo, "You always want to go with what's come out of his mouth rather than look at what's in his heart."
Well, we're journalists, not cardiologists but okay, by that standard, President Trump's inaugural address was of a piece, much of it appealing to his core constituency -- white workers and the middle class angry that they've been left out of the good times, as indeed they have been. But the speech was hollow rhetoric when compared to all the things Trump and his fledgling administration actually have done in just the last few weeks and hours.
"Today, we are not merely transferring power from one administration to another or from one party to another," Trump declared. "But we are transferring power from Washington, DC, and giving it back to you, the people... The establishment protected itself but not the citizens of our country. Their victories have not been your victories. Their triumphs have not been your triumphs."
Fine, we'll do as Kellyanne Conway recommends. Rather than heed the rhetoric we'll look at his deeds and try to plumb the depths of his tiny heart. Truth is, Donald Trump has surrounded himself with many of the very elitists responsible for the plight of those everyday people he promised never to forget. The establishment he decried in his speech is front and center; six Goldman Sachs alumni alone already are in his administration, including Treasury Secretary-designate Steve Mnuchin, the man who parked a hundred million dollars in an offshore account and forgot to tell the Senate about it (we're not making this up).
Trump bragged Thursday night about the collective high IQ of his Cabinet but the real number that's troubling, as the website Quartz noted last month, is that the first 17 people he named to the Cabinet or Cabinet-ranking posts "have well over $9.5 billion in combined wealth... This collection of wealth is greater than that of the 43 million least wealthy American households combined."
Let that sink in. Those first 17 people plucked by Trump to help him govern have more wealth "than over one-third of the 126 million households total in the US. Affluence of this magnitude in a US presidential Cabinet is unprecedented."
How about billionaire Wilbur Ross firing an undocumented household staff member to avoid being embarrassed when Trump picked Ross as secretary of commerce? Could it be he suddenly developed an interest in immigration policy?
Or Labor Secretary-designate Andrew Puzder, CEO of Carl's Jr. and Hardee's restaurants, his profits built on cutting corners and paying workers the lowest wages possible. Unless he has suddenly developed the common touch, it's not likely he'll be a robust advocate for blue- and white-collar workers.
Or Education Secretary-designate Betsy DeVos, whose confirmation hearings this past week revealed she knows almost nothing about public education -- which, by the way, she doesn't believe in -- but whose lack of credentials pale in importance beside the more than $20 million she and her family have given to Republican candidates at the federal level, including many of the senators who will vote for her confirmation.
And how about Trump himself -- stopping his inaugural parade to get out of his limousine in front of his DC hotel, of course -- but so far failing to keep his promise last week that by Jan. 20 he would transfer complete control of his businesses? According to Pro Publica's Derek Kravitz and Al Shaw, none of the required documents have been filed.
No time for that, apparently, but plenty of time during his first hours in office to eliminate a climate change page on the White House website and replace it with attacks on the "burdensome" regulation of the energy industry -- exactly what the global warming giants of fossil fuel sought to achieve with their campaign contributions. The new president already has forgotten those ordinary people out there experiencing the erratic weather brought on by climate change, many of them watching the waters rise around their homes and small businesses. Perhaps Trump plans to build them an ark.
Speaking of everyday people: If you're one of the homeowners struggling to make ends meet, some of the people Trump pledged in his inaugural address to defend, consider this as well: One of his first executive orders Friday suspended his predecessor's plan to decrease insurance premiums on Federal Housing Administration mortgages, a move Obama intended to help stabilize the housing market. Congratulations -- if you're one of those mortgage holders, you've been Trumped!
"A punch in the gut to middle-class buyers" -- that's how it was described by Sarah Edelman, director of housing policy at the Center for American Progress. "...With mortgage interest rates already on the rise, reversing the FHA's move to cut insurance premiums in fact puts the dream of homeownership farther out of reach for millions of hardworking Americans."
Contrast that cheapskate move with the money being spent on Trump's big inaugural weekend. Nicholas Fandos at The New York Times reported last week that, "All told, the group planning the inaugural festivities says it has raised more than $100 million, which would be nearly double the record for an inauguration, with much of it coming in six- and seven-figure checks from America's corporate suites." That includes a million bucks from Boeing and half a million from Chevron. A small price to pay for the kind of influence and thinly veiled bribery that are sure to characterize the Trump years.
"We will make America wealthy again," Trump bellowed in his speech -- he just didn't say that the wealth won't be shared. Fact is, "the forgotten men and women of our country" whom Trump addressed in the speech don't have a chance against the army of influence peddlers with whom the new president already has surrounded himself.
For example, it was announced on Thursday that 13 -- yes, 13 -- lawyers from the high-powered law firm of Jones Day will be moving to top positions in the administration, seven of them at the White House alone. It's s "a ton of top jobs" for one Washington firm, as David Lat of the website Above the Law put it: "This is very good news for Jones Day and the lawyers remaining at the firm. It's great for the firm's prestige, and it also means that JD lawyers will be eagerly sought after by clients with issues pending before their former colleagues." (italics added).
This must be what they mean by "draining the swamp" -- they just divert it over to the White House.
A pall of contradiction hung over the whole ceremony Friday -- between the rhetoric aimed at those millions of working people and middle-class Americans to whom Trump said he was talking and the fabulous wealth concentrated in his personal and official circles. Not once did he mention the words democracy, or equality, or even the Constitution. And while the clergy who offered prayers frequently invoked the names of God and Jesus, no one disturbed the official piety by reminding the privileged and powerful gathered around the new president that Jesus told his followers, "... I was hungry and you gave me food. I was thirsty and you gave me drink. I was a stranger and you welcomed me."
Or had said to a certain rich young man: "You lack one thing. Sell what you own and give the money to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come, follow me."
Or had admonished his followers: "When you give a banquet, invite the poor, the crippled, the lame and the blind."
It wasn't that kind of affair, of course. Instead, a few hours after the swearing-in, President Trump, in another of his first official acts, signed an executive order moving forward the repeal of the Affordable Care Act, which could ultimately remove 18 to 32 million people from health insurance. Many of them presumably voted for Trump. Not a few may now need a miracle to survive.
By the way, according to Darren Samuelsohn at Politico, the end of the ACA would personally save our billionaire president "at least $6.7 million" in Medicare taxes.
Let us pray. After we march.
Ahead of nationwide protests taking place Thursday against Donald Trump's labor secretary nominee Andy Puzder, workers are drawing attention to poor conditions at the fast-food CEO's restaurants.
Puzder's confirmation hearing before the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Committee was tentatively planned for January 17, but Politico reported Tuesday that with education nominee Betsy DeVos' hearing now pushed to that date, Puzder may have to wait until February for his time before the panel.
"We're here to start the real inquiry, about whether or not Mr. Puzder is a person who can be trusted to stand up for you and for all the workers of America."
--Sen. Elizabeth Warren
But Senate Democrats and labor advocates aren't holding their fire. After Republicans denied (pdf) their request to allow testimony from Puzder's employees at his hearing, Sens. Patty Murray (D-Wash.) and Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) on Tuesday organized a forum to hear from those very workers.
The forum featured testimony from three current and former employees of CKE Restaurants, the fast-food company run by Puzder that is known for its Carl's Jr. and Hardee's chains, as well as National Employment Law Project executive director Christine Owens. They spoke of wage theft, working without overtime pay, and struggling to get by on minimum wage. Puzder, who made $4 million in 2012, has publicly come out against raising the minimum wage.
More than 100 Carls Jr. and Hardee's workers were present in the chamber during Tuesday's forum.
"If Andy Puzder is confirmed as labor secretary, what happened to me at Carl's Jr. will be multiplied on the national level," said Roberto Ramirez, who worked at a Carl's Jr. for 18 years and said he was so overworked he had to start 30 minutes before clocking in.
"You're right, this is not right," Warren told Carl's Jr. employee Lupe Guzman, a 47-year-old mother of six who provides for her family on $8.75 an hour and said wage theft was common. "And this is what the secretary of labor is supposed to stand up for, is people like you. We're here to start the real inquiry, about whether or not Mr. Puzder is a person who can be trusted to stand up for you and for all the workers of America."
She added on Twitter:
Watch the forum below:
Also Tuesday, Warren unveiled the results of a Restaurant Opportunities Center (ROC) United survey of CKE workers on their wages and working conditions. The survey, conducted between December 19 and January 7, found high rates of wage and hour violations, age discrimination, and sexual harassment.
"If Puzder is confirmed as labor secretary, it will mean the Trump years will be about low pay, wage theft, sexual harassment, and racial discrimination instead of making lives better for working Americans like me."
--Terrance Dixon, Hardee's worker
A statement from ROC United declared: "Under Puzder's leadership, CKE Restaurants has established a record of multiple lawsuits for discriminating against workers and failing to pay overtime, and has been accused of firing workers for protesting against poverty wages. Workers at CKE restaurants spoke of extensive wage and hour violations and excessive rates of sexual harassment. Considering the mission of the U.S. Department of Labor--promoting the welfare of wage earners, improving working conditions, and enforcing worker protections--these findings call into question the viability of Andrew Puzder for the role of the nation's secretary of labor."
That is the message of protests taking place Thursday at Carl's Jr. and Hardee's restaurants and corporate offices and at U.S. Department of Labor branches in more than 24 cities nationwide.
According to organizers, thousands of Carl's Jr. and Hardee's cooks and cashiers will lead marches and rallies, holding signs that read, "Meet Andy Puzder: CEO of the rigged economy" and "Puzder gets rich while keeping workers poor."
"Andy Puzder represents the worst of the rigged economy Donald Trump pledged to take on as president," said Terrance Dixon, a Hardee's worker from St. Louis, who is paid $9 an hour. "If Puzder is confirmed as labor secretary, it will mean the Trump years will be about low pay, wage theft, sexual harassment, and racial discrimination instead of making lives better for working Americans like me."
Puzder opponents are tweeting about the nominee under the hashtag #AntiLaborSecretary:
The Republican party appears to be employing a strategy wherein the public--and even lawmakers--will be too distracted to place much needed scrutiny on President-elect Donald Trump's cabinet nominees.
Not only are six major confirmation hearings now scheduled for the same day (see below)--"preventing any one nominee from dominating a news cycle," as the Washington Post put it--but Trump himself rescheduled a long-awaited press conference for that very day: January 11. And that same Wednesday also happens to be when Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) plans to begin a so-called vote-o-rama, "in which senators take dozens and dozens of votes on amendments with no clear end," Politico explains.
Indeed, as Sen. Chris Coons (D-Del.) told NPR of secretary of state nominee Rex Tillerson's hearing in particular: "It may well happen on a day where we are literally voting continuously for 24 hours. I don't think that's the right day to hold a hearing where the members of the Foreign Relations Committee who have real concerns--both Republicans and Democrats--want to hear his full answers, not just race in and out."
But that could be just what some Republicans are hoping for.
"The GOP leadership's approach will minimize unflattering process stories and prevent Trump's nominees from receiving the kind of full airing and scrutiny that they would otherwise," James Hohmann wrote for the Post. "It's the political equivalent of running a no-huddle offense in the first quarter and throwing a lot of deep balls when you know the defense is outmatched. The other side's best safety is still recovering from a pulled hamstring, and the defensive coordinator is distracted by the head coaching job he's going to take next season. The odds are that Team Trump will score a bunch of touchdowns."
According to the Senate calendar and various news outlets, here's where the schedule stands thus far:
Tuesday, January 10:
Wednesday, January 11:
Thursday, January 12:
Wednesday, January 18:
Additionally, Politico reports that the hearing for Ben Carson, Trump's pick for Housing and Urban Development secretary, will take place at the Senate Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs Committee during the week of January 9; and that the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions will hold a hearing on Labor nominee Andrew Puzder during the week of January 16.
According to CNN, hearings for Steven Mnuchin (Treasury), Scott Pruit (EPA), Mike Mulvaney (Office of Management and Budget), Ryan Zinke (Interior), Rick Perry (Energy), and Nikki Haley (UN Ambassador) have yet to be scheduled.
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) has been warned that Senate Democrats are planning to "aggressively target" eight of President-elect Donald Trump's Cabinet nominees, aiming to delay as long as possible the confirmation hearings slated to start next week.
"President-elect Trump is attempting to fill his rigged cabinet with nominees that would break key campaign promises and have made billions off the industries they'd be tasked with regulating," Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) said in a statement Sunday reported by the Washington Post.
"Any attempt by Republicans to have a series of rushed, truncated hearings before Inauguration Day and before the Congress and public have adequate information on all of them is something Democrats will vehemently resist," Schumer said. "If Republicans think they can quickly jam through a whole slate of nominees without a fair hearing process, they're sorely mistaken."
The nominees in the Democrats' crosshairs are:
Confirmation hearings for Tillerson and Sessions are expected to begin next week.
But environmental groups have vowed to make Tillerson's hearing a referendum on his company's climate record, while civil rights and progressive advocacy groups are mounting a concerted fight against Sessions.
In a statement released late last week, the NAACP explained its opposition to Sessions' nomination "for the following reasons: a record on voting rights that is unreliable at best and hostile at worse; a failing record on other civil rights; a record of racially offensive remarks and behavior; and dismal record on criminal justice reform issues."
The statement read:
Given that these are issues our nation the attorney general is sworn to protect and enforce his nomination represents an ongoing and dangerous threat to our civic birthrights.
We call upon the Senate to reject Sessions and for President-elect Donald J. Trump to replace Sessions with a nominee with a record of inclusion and commitment to protecting the civil rights of the American majority.
Meanwhile, CNN reported Sunday that three groups--the National Council of Asian Pacific Americans, People For the American Way, and Alliance for Justice--are calling for Sessions' hearing to be blocked until he provides sufficient information as requested on a Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaire.
According to CNN:
The groups say Sessions failed to provide media interviews, speeches, op-eds, and more from his time as U.S. attorney in Alabama, the state's attorney general, and from his first term as senator, from 1997 through 2002.
They said Sessions listed just 20 media interviews, 16 speeches outside the Senate, two op-eds, an academic article, and a training manual, as well as just 11 clips of interviews with print publications--including none prior to 2003.
"Sen. Sessions claims that records do not exist for the vast majority of press interviews he has given over the years. However, many are easily located online," the groups said, calling the omission "inexplicable."
As Common Dreams reported, the wealthy nominees' financial conflicts of interest could also prove to be a stumbling block. Last month, 16 leading Democrats demanded that each confirmation only move forward if the nominee has cleared an FBI background check; provided a complete financial disclosure; submitted an ethics agreement approved by the Office of Government Ethics; and "satisfied reasonable requests for additional information" that lawmakers have time to review.
On Twitter last week, Schumer noted that while the Senate now has tax returns from Mnuchin and Price, "we're still waiting on Tillerson & rest of Cabinet."
While it remains unclear exactly how Democrats could gum up the confirmation works, Politico reported:
Democrats can use Senate procedures to throw sand in the gears of the chamber, though a 2013 rules change prevents them from unilaterally blocking Trump's cabinet selections. One strategy would force the Senate to go into recess in order to hold some committee hearings; they could also deploy parliamentary tactics to force cloture votes on nominees and drag out debate for days. Democrats estimate they could make the confirmation process take as long as two months.
Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.) is vowing to force a "full conversation" on the Senate floor as allowed by the rules, which allow up to 30 hours of debate on cabinet nominations.
The Post points out: "Absent from the Democratic hit list are retired Marine Gen. James N. Mattis, the pick for defense secretary; South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley, whom Trump has nominated to serve as ambassador to the United Nations; and John Kelly, a former Marine general and Trump's selection to lead the Department of Homeland Security, signaling that all three should expect little trouble from Democrats."