Skip to main content

Sign up for our newsletter.

Quality journalism. Progressive values. Direct to your inbox.

A prison execution chamber. (Photo: T. Woodard)

Ninth Circuit Judge: No 'Masking Brutality' of Death Penalty

In dissenting opinion, appeals court judge argues that lethal injection is 'misguided' attempt to shield reality

Lauren McCauley

A top federal judge on Monday issued an evocative and forthright attack on the death penalty, saying that the practice of "lethal injection" is a misguided attempt by society to "mask" the "horrendous brutality" of the act.

"Using drugs meant for individuals with medical needs to carry out executions is a misguided effort to maks the brutality of executions by making them look serene and peaceful—like something any one of us might experience in our final moments," Ninth Circuit Court chief justice Alex Kozinski, wrote in a dissenting opinion in the lethal injection secrecy case of Joseph Wood.

"But executions are, in fact, nothing like that," Kozinski continued. "They are brutal, savage events, and nothing the state tries to do can mask that reality."

The comments were made, unexpectedly, in Kozinski's dissenting opinion in the Ninth Circuit Court ruling that denied the state of Arizona grounds to challenge the postponement of Wood's execution, which is being delayed over the secrecy of its capital punishment procedures.

Though Kozinski is for the death penalty, he argued that, "If we as a society want to carry out executions, we should be willing to face the fact that the state is committing a horrendous brutality on our behalf."

According to the Guardian's Ed Pilkington, the statement represents "one of the most high-profile attacks on the U.S. death penalty," as the practice of death by lethal injection has come under increasing scrutiny following Europe's boycott of producing death penalty drugs.

The dissent was issued days after a California judge declared the state's death penalty system "unconstitutional," arguing that long delays and uncertainty over whether one will ever be executed amounts to "cruel or unusual punishment."

"If we are willing to carry out executions, we should not shield ourselves from the reality that we are shedding human blood."
—Ninth Circuit Court chief justice Alex Kozinski

In the Wood v. Ryan dissent, Kozinski said that if governments wish to continue carrying out the death penalty, they must "return to more primitive—and foolproof—methods of execution."

After weighing the drawbacks of historic alternatives, Kozinski settled on the firing squad as being the "most promising."

"Sure, firing squads can be messy," he wrote, "but if we are willing to carry out executions, we should not shield ourselves from the reality that we are shedding human blood."

"If we, as a society, cannot stomach the splatter from an execution carried out by firing squad, then we shouldn't be carrying out executions at all."

We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.

Watchdog: Secret Service Didn't Notify Capitol Police of Threat to Pelosi Until After Jan. 6 Attack

"This is deeply disturbing and requires a full investigation," said one legal expert.

Jessica Corbett ·

Advocates Welcome Temporary Block on South Carolina's 6-Week Abortion Ban

"Today's decision is a huge relief for people who desperately need abortion care in South Carolina right now," said one reproductive rights lawyer.

Brett Wilkins ·

Federal Court Strikes Down Ruling That Blocked Biden's Drilling Moratorium

"Today's decision demonstrates how flawed the preliminary injunction issued in June 2021 was, and that Interior must quickly take action to reform the federal fossil fuel program," said one environmental lawyer.

Julia Conley ·

Two Weeks Before Payments Resume, Progressives Tell Biden 'Time to Cancel Student Debt'

U.S. Education Secretary Miguel Cardona said that "we're having conversations daily with the White House and borrowers will know directly and soon from us when a decision is made."

Jessica Corbett ·

Progressive Mandela Barnes Leads Ron Johnson by 7 Points in New Poll

"People are done being represented by an out-of-touch, self-serving multimillionaire like Ron Johnson," said Wisconsin's Democratic Senate nominee.

Kenny Stancil ·

Common Dreams Logo