Tortured Logic: In The Government's Own Words

The torture memos produced by the OLC were never meant to be seen and parsed by the public.

These memos used incredibly tortured logic to justify acts which, in prior wars, the United States prosecuted as war crimes.

The ACLU has put together a video of these words of tortured logic being read aloud. Watch it.

The words you are hearing were written by and for the US government.
As guidance for governmental agencies acting in all of our names.

The ACLU is asking that you send these words to Attorney General Eric Holder. Ask for accountability on torture. You can do so here.

These OLC memos, along with a wholesale disregard for the rule of law, have led the US to what Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly recently said in a memorandum opinion in the Al Mutairi case (full opinion here in PDF format):

Taking this evidence as a whole, the
Government has at best shown that some of Al Mutairi's conduct is
consistent with persons who may have become a part of al Wafa or al
Qaida, but there is nothing in the record beyond speculation that Al
Mutairi did, in fact, train or otherwise become a part of one or more
of those organizations, where he would have done so, and with which
organization. While Al Mutairi's described peregrinations within
Afghanistan lack credibility, the Government has not filled in these
blanks nor supplanted Al Mutairi's version of his travels and
activities with sufficiently credible and reliable evidence to meet its
burden by a preponderance of the evidence. Accordingly, the Court shall
grant Al Mutairi's petition for habeas corpus.

The flimsy, insufficient evidence question has come up time and time again in detainee habeas cases, where the government has only tangential-at-best information about someone we have held for years.

Honestly, Al Mutairi doesn't exactly sound like a completely
innocent "babe in the woods." Especially when you see how many
problems Judge Kollar-Kotelly has with his version of events. He has
that feel that I used to get from every skeezy defendant who wouldn't
have known the truth if it hit him in the ass. But just because
someone was skeezy doesn't make them guilty of every crime.

You are supposed to prosecute in the name of justice, not just because you can.

As the judge says pointedly, it is not up to Al Mutairi to prove
his innocence. It is up to the government -- as it is in all such
cases -- to demonstrate by a preponderance of the evidence the
defendant's actions point to, in this case, an association with al Wafa
or al Qaeda.

There must be a connection sustained by evidence to justify prosecution.

What is baffling? Al Mutairi was apprehended by the Pakistanis and
turned over to US custody on or around November 21, 2001. He filed his
habeas petition on May 1, 2002, making his the oldest habeas petition
for any US detainee.

During these many years of detention, and all the subsequent
hearings, proceedings, filings, defense evidentiary challenges, and up
to and including demands directly from Judge Kollar-Kotelly -- no
newbie to intel proceedings, having just finished a term as the head of
the FISA Court -- for particulars on evidentiary issues of questionable
detail and firmness? That evidence still isn't there.

That evidence, after all these many years, has neither been firmed
up nor been corroborated by additional intelligence gathering or other
investigative means. We have bupkis.

Who are we and what have we done with competence and a commitment to justice?

ACLUblog quotes a human rights lawyer who gets this exactly right:

[P]rinciples don't really matter much
in times of peace. It's easy to maintain your ideology when everything
is stable and life is good; it's during times of conflict that holding
fast to your values really matters. It is conflict that truly tests
your beliefs.

We have failed -- and continue to fail -- that test. And we will continue to do so unless and until we hold those at the top levels of government responsible for the actions taken at their direction.

Join Us: News for people demanding a better world

Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place.

We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference.

Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. Join with us today!

© 2023 FireDogLake