Joe Scarborough Is Shocked, Yet Awed by Single-Payer Logic

Something rather remarkable happened on Tuesday's Morning Joe.
Rep. Anthony Weiner of New York pointed out that the health insurance
industry has no clothes, and Joe Scarborough, after first trying to
spin it some gossamer threads, broke down and said, By God, you're
right, this emperor is a naked money-making machine!

Well, he didn't use those exact words, but Joe did seem to finally get
that America has granted insurance companies the right to create
bottlenecks in the financing of health care in order to extract profits
out of the suffering of ordinary people--without providing any actual
health care whatsoever.

"Why are we paying profits for insurance companies?" Weiner asked
Scarborough. "Why are we paying overhead for insurance companies? Why,"
he asked, bringing it all home, "are we paying for their TV

Weiner, who recently warned that President Obama could lose as many
as 100 votes on a health bill if a public option is not included,
really wants single payer--Medicare for all Americans is his goal. What
a crazy, way-out, reckless notion, Joe went into their encounter
believing. But Weiner asked some simple, direct questions that no
politician, much less Obama or HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius, has
managed to pose:

What is an insurance company? They don't do a single
check-up. They don't do a single exam, they don't perform an operation.
Medicare has a 4 percent overhead rate. The real question is why do we
have a private plan?

"It sounds like you're saying you think there is no need for us to
have private insurance in health care," Joe asked at one point.

Weiner replied: "I've asked you three times. What is their value? What are they bringing to the deal?"

Scraping the bottom of a seemingly bottomless pit of spin, Joe is
repeatedly left speechless, "stunned" and "astounded," he said, by the
questions themselves. Indeed, when confronted with unfettered
capitalism's massive failures, the right usually has nothing to say.
The "free market" is supposed to eternally grow, not crash under its
own greed. They're left ideologically crippled.

But unlike, say, Lou Dobbs, who began dobbering
when confronted with similarly direct argument for single-payer, Joe
was able to take a deep breath and return from a break with his eyes

He even repeated Weiner's points clearly: The goverment would take
over only the "paying mechanism" of health care, not the doctors or
their medical decisions themselves. His ears perked up every time
Weiner mentioned that the nonprofit Medicare spends 4 percent on
overhead, while private insurers spend 30 percent.

And Joe, who has been criticizing mob rule at town halls, seemed to
appreciate the way Weiner counters the fearmongering over Medicare:
After decades of railing against the program's wasteful, "runaway"
spending, Republicans have done a 180 and are now trying to scare seniors
that the Democrats' proposed Medicare cuts will come directly from
their medical care and not, as is actually proposed, from wasteful,
stupid practices in the system--like, as Weiner mentions, putting
people into a $700-a-night hospital bed when all they really need, and
often prefer, is a visit by a homecare attendant in the two-digit-a-day

Maybe the real turning point came when Weiner asked, "How does Wal-mart
offer $4 prescriptions?" Joe and co-host Mika Brzezinski looked as if
they'd been thwacked by a hardback copy of Atlas Shrugged, and sat back to let the congressman explain it all to them:

They go to the pharmaceutical companies and say, "Listen, we have a
giant buying pool here. You're going to give us a great deal."

Who's bigger than Wal-Mart? We are, the taxpayers. Do we do that? No.
Because we have outsourced this to insurance companies who don't have
necessarily as much incentive to keep those costs down because,
frankly, they are getting a piece of the action.

Progressives tend to understand this stuff, but many conservatives
won't trust such logic, especially in the abstract, which is how most
Dems have been communicating. But Weiner, aware that if you can't
visualize something it ain't going to stick, argued with a specific,
familiar visual--that of a successful, supercapitalist, and, as Mika might say,
"real American" company. And suddenly, as the mote dropped from the MJ
crew's eyes, Weiner went from "scaring American citizens," in Joe's
words, to instant celeb.

"That was SO great!" said Mika, as she and Joe asked Anthony to please, please come back soon, this week if possible!

"You have succeeded in doing something that no one else has done on
this show in two years," said Joe, his fists rapidly knocking the table
in excitement. "You made me speechless. And you made me speechless
because you so clearly came here and stated your position."

While maintaining that he and Weiner have "different worldviews,"
Joe nevertheless raved, "This is fascinating, and one of the problems
with the president's message is that it's muddled." And, damn, that's

Could this episode herald a Single-Payer Awakening? Or is this just the
thrill of logic running up Joe's leg, soon to be forgotten as corporate
media try to undermine real reform of a system that feeds the nets
millions in ad revenue? When the big mainstream players shouted in
unison to prematurely declare the public option dead, I couldn't help
but think: In the corporate media's total takeover of ideas, they, too,
have a death panel--made up of three or four conglomerate owners and
chaired by Rupert Murdoch--that will determine whether an idea lives or
gets its plug pulled.

On Thursday, Morning Joe replayed Weiner's best hits, but
Joe was occasionally dobbering himself, complaining that our health
care problems come down to costs, costs, costs but "now all the
President is talking about is a moral imperative." (Of course, Obama
put morality on the table only yesterday; until then, he focused on
costs, costs, costs.)

We'll see how far this relative openness to single-payer goes. In
the meantime, though, the education of Joe Scarborough is, as always, a
sight to behold:

Join Us: News for people demanding a better world

Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place.

We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference.

Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. Join with us today!

Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.