For Immediate Release
New Picture Has Emerged of Woman Facing Imminent Execution in Virginia
"Mastermind" of Crime Was in Reality Led Along by Actual Killers Who Received Lesser Sentences
WASHINGTON - Unless the governor or the U.S. Supreme Court intervenes, Teresa Lewis will be
put to death on September 23 in Virginia, the first woman to be executed in that state in
a century. But the woman whom the sentencing judge assumed was the mastermind in
the murders of her husband and adult stepson now has been shown to be a simpler
person who was readily led by others and the target of a scam by an ambitious hitman.
Ms. Lewis has taken full responsibility for her role in the crime, but was probably less
culpable than the two men who used her and actually carried out the killings. Those
men were given life sentences, while Lewis pleaded guilty and received a death
"The issue in this case," said Richard Dieter, Executive Director of the Death
Penalty Information Center, "is not that Teresa Lewis is a woman and should be treated
differently. But it would be grossly unfair if the one person among those involved who
is probably the least danger to society, who is certainly no more guilty than those who
carried out the murders, and whose disabilities call out for mercy, is the only person
scheduled to die for this crime."
Teresa Lewis has an IQ of 72, close to the level of intellectual disability that would
exempt her from the death penalty. She has been diagnosed with a dependent
personality disorder that meant she looked to others for help and direction, and she
was addicted to prescription drugs at the time of the crime. At a very low time in her
life following the death of her mother, Matthew Shallenberger (IQ 113) and Rodney
Fuller became her acquaintances, and she followed their suggestions in planning a
crime to gain insurance money. But far from being the ringleader, Lewis was more of a
pawn, as a letter from Shallenberger to a girlfriend indicates. He wrote that he
considered his romantic involvement with Teresa "just part of what had to be done to
get the money" and that she was "just what I was looking for: some ugly bitch who
married her husband for the money and I knew I could get to fall head over heals [sic]
for me." (Shallenberger later committed suicide in prison.)
A psychologist who interviewed Shallenberger reported that he "boasted of
dreams of becoming a 'hitman' for the Mafia." Teresa, on the other hand, bungled
attempts to retrieve her husband's cash and insurance after the murder, including
presenting an obviously forged check to the bank. When she was questioned by
police, she could not tell a straight story and quickly confessed her involvement,
alerting police to Shallenberger and Fuller.
Rodney Fuller, Shallenberger's accomplice in the murders, agreed that Teresa
was a follower, not a leader: "It seemed to me that Mrs. Lewis would do just about
anything Shallenberger asked her to do. As between Mrs. Lewis and Shallenberger,
Shallenberger was definitely the one in charge of things, not Mrs. Lewis."
Since being sent to death row, Teresa Lewis has been remorseful and a model
inmate. A prison chaplain noted that Teresa held steadfastly to her faith and shared her
love and support with women in the cells around her. Prison officials have talked about
her singing hymns in her cell that calmed the entire wing.
SCROLL TO CONTINUE WITH CONTENT
Get our best delivered to your inbox.
Lynn Litchfield, the former chaplain in Virginia where Lewis is being held,
recently described her in Newsweek's "My Turn" section:
Teresa seemed meek, almost pliant. When I hugged her-the only
hug we ever shared-she was so grateful. She didn't look like a
remorseless killer, a "mastermind" who plotted two murders, as the judge
put it (her original lawyers did little to dispute this image). In one of our
sessions, she collapsed into great soul-shattering, body-heaving sobs and
cried into my wrist, the only part of me I could get through the slot in the
In addition to a clemency petition to Governor Robert McDonnell, Lewis's
lawyers have asked the Supreme Court for a stay of execution while it considers her
legal petition. Virginia sets execution dates before the Supreme Court decides whether
it will take a case, making a petition for a stay necessary so the Court can give
reasonable consideration to her issues.
Before the Court, Lewis's attorneys assert that she pleaded guilty in order to
allow the judge determine her sentence. Virginia law required that in order to have a
judge, rather than a jury, she had to waive her right to a jury throughout the process,
including the determination of whether she was eligible for the death penalty. Whether
that is a constitutional deprivation of her right to trial is an arguable issue deserving
For further information, contact Lewis's attorney James E. Rocap, III, Steptoe &
Johnson, 202-429-8152; email@example.com; or Richard Dieter, Executive Director,
Death Penalty Information Center, 202-289-2275; firstname.lastname@example.org.
Further information is available on a website devoted to this case.
This is the world we live in. This is the world we cover.
Because of people like you, another world is possible. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. Common Dreams is not your normal news site. We don't survive on clicks. We don't want advertising dollars. We want the world to be a better place. But we can't do it alone. It doesn't work that way. We need you. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do. Without Your Support We Won't Exist.
Please select a donation method: