For Immediate Release
Boehner to Immigrants: Work and Go Home
Obama to Immigrants: We Can Get it Done
WASHINGTON - Sunday, House Minority Leader John Boehner (R-OH) appeared for the very first time on Univision's Al Punto - the Spanish language equivalent of a high-profile appearance on Meet the Press. His interview followed that of President Obama. What did Boehner say?
When asked whether he would "consider" supporting legalization of the
undocumented workforce, Boehner said: "We're a nation of laws, and
enforcing the law has to be the first step in this process. There is a
way to allow [undocumented immigrants] to continue to work in the
United States for a temporary period of time. And if they want to
become citizens, they need to do what everybody else in the world does,
and that's apply for their home countries."
In other words,
there should be ramped up enforcement, presumably of the kind that is
terrifying and dividing immigrant families already, followed by some
sort of a temporary work permit, presumably with second class labor,
civil, and political rights. Then, these workers should leave the
country to get in line to apply for permanent resident status, despite
the fact that the entire viewing audience knows that the primary cause
of illegal immigration is that there simply is no "line" to get into,
whether in the country of origin or here in the United States. Mr.
Boehner's too-clever-by-half sound-bite - enforcement-first, followed
by guest worker status, followed by the chance to go home to get in a
non-existent line - is rightly understood in the immigrant community as
the ridiculous "report-to-deport" scheme first popularized by the likes
of Senator John Cornyn (R-TX) and Jon Kyl (R-AZ) in 2005.
ON LATINO VOTERS:
When asked why Republicans saw their share of the Latino vote drop from
44% in 2004 to 31% in 2008, Boehner blamed unnamed candidates and the
"overall political environment." He then went on to stress the reasons
he thinks the Republican Party is a "great home for Hispanics,"
emphasizing family values, limited government, and school choice.
In other words,
please ignore the fact that the GOP has spent many years and many
millions of dollars demonizing immigrants in an effort to mobilize base
voters and appeal to white swing voters. Dear Latinos, please
understand that your alienation from the Republican Party is due to bad
candidates and bad weather, not the statements and policy positions of
a Party that wants to deny citizenship opportunities to your loved ones
and deport as many of them as possible.
to Frank Sharry, Executive Director of America's Voice, "If this is the
best the Republican Party has to offer to Latino immigrant voters,
perhaps Mr. Boehner and his colleagues in Republican leadership should
stay close to Fox News and away from Spanish language television. The
fact that the House Republicans' top leader went on the most prominent
political affairs show for Latino immigrant voters and recommended a
stronger crackdown, second-class treatment, and what amounts to
self-deportation shows that the GOP leadership just doesn't get it.
The House Republican conference is dominated by militants such as Rep.
Lamar Smith (R-TX), former FAIR lobbyist Rep. Brian Bilbray (R-CA), and
Rep. Steve King (R-IA), who argue that the best policy is one that
ramps up enforcement until 12 million undocumented
immigrants--presumably along with the four million citizen children who
live in their households--are forced to leave the country."
added, "Mr. Boehner should face the uncomfortable truth and speak it.
Latino voters rejected the Republican Party in 2008 in record numbers
not because of bad candidates, but because of bad policies and harsh
rhetoric. As a result, Republicans have gone from being competitive
with Latino immigrant voters to being shunned by them. In 2004,
Spanish-dominant voters virtually split their vote between John Kerry
and George W. Bush, with Kerry winning 52% - 48%; in 2008,
Spanish-dominant voters turned out in record numbers and voted for
Barack Obama by a margin of 75%-25%, a differential that would have
been even greater had someone other than John McCain been the
candidate. This is one of the most dramatic shifts in electoral
support in modern American political history, and deserves a more
thoughtful answer than blaming unnamed ‘candidates' or ‘the overall
Meanwhile, appearing on Al Punto before
Minority Leader Boehner, President Obama recommitted to making
comprehensive immigration reform a reality: "I am not backing off one
minute from getting this done, but let's face it, I've had a few things
to do. We had an economic crisis that almost saw a financial meltdown.
Health care has taken longer than I would have liked, but it's a big,
tough issue. Immigration reform is gonna be tough as well, but I think
we can get it done."
voters will be watching to see if President Obama delivers on his
promise and makes a determined effort to enact comprehensive
immigration reform that includes a means for undocumented immigrants
get legal, pay their full share of taxes, and get in line to work
towards citizenship. Until the Republican Party offers up more than
the back of the hand to Latino and
immigrant families, the question for Democrats will not be whether
Latino voters turn to Republicans in the next election, but whether
they turn away from Democrats for failing to move forward on reform and