Justin Simmons, a journalist who worked for the Sinclair-owned KHGI-TV in Nebrasksa, resigned over efforts by the parent company to force anchors to read pre-packaged scripts he viewed as dishonest. (Photo: Courtesy of CNN)
Apr 04, 2018
As Sinclair continues to face criticism after a viral video showing local news anchors reciting scripts pre-packaged by the right-wing broadcasting behemoth, one TV producer announced Wednesday that the forced propaganda drove him to resign in protest.
"I didn't go into news to give people biased information," said Justin Simmons of Sinclair-owned KHGI-TV in Nebrasksa.
While the forced scripts put a spotlight in recent days on the power wielded by the right-wing media giant--and its proposed merger with Tribune Media--he toldCNNMoney, "I've always kind of been on edge about Sinclair." Simmons, who tendered his resignation on March 26, cited increasingly frequent "must-run" segments such as the "Terrorism Alert Desk."
It was the promo highlighted in the viral video--which Simmons said was "almost forcing local anchors to lie to their viewers"--that served as the last straw.
"Resigning seemed like the least I could do," he added. "I wish there was more."
While other local broadcasters have also spoken out in the wake of the viral video by Deadspin, news of Simmons' resignation comes amid renewed focus this week on the Sinclair-Tribune merger and the right-leaning coverage pushed by Sinclair executives, including CEO David Smith.
"There isn't a viral video long enough to demonstrate the type of power Sinclair would have to push its partisan political agenda into all of our homes if the company is successful in gobbling up so many stations that only two owners remain."
--Karl Frisch, Allied ProgressAccording to Karl Frisch, executive director of the liberal watchdog group Allied Progress, Sinclair is dangerous not just because of its political agenda, but because of Smith's stated desire for nearly total market domination by powerful broadcasters like his.
In a 2004 interview with an broadcast industry news outlet, Smith stated that if he "was going to wish for anything and I could snap my fingers and make it happen [...] it would be for an instantaneous final consolidation of the industry." Smith went on to say that such a consolidation--a nightmare scenario for progressives who see the corporate control of the media system as a direct assault on the role of journalism in a democracy--was "absolutely doable" in the future.
"The Sinclair/Tribune merger isn't dinner--it's the appetizer," warned Frisch. "Smith won't be content until his singular wish of the local news industry's 'final consolidation' is complete. That's a frightening prospect."
He concluded, "There isn't a viral video long enough to demonstrate the type of power Sinclair would have to push its partisan political agenda into all of our homes if the company is successful in gobbling up so many stations that only two owners remain."
In an essay published at the Huffington Post on Wednesday, a separate Sinclair producer--who requested anonymity over fears of retribution--told people: "If you want to make a difference, lobby your lawmakers to have them stop the Tribune deal from going through, because that is what is dangerous about this. It's dangerous for any company to own as many stations as Sinclair does."
Join Us: News for people demanding a better world
Common Dreams is powered by optimists who believe in the power of informed and engaged citizens to ignite and enact change to make the world a better place. We're hundreds of thousands strong, but every single supporter makes the difference. Your contribution supports this bold media model—free, independent, and dedicated to reporting the facts every day. Stand with us in the fight for economic equality, social justice, human rights, and a more sustainable future. As a people-powered nonprofit news outlet, we cover the issues the corporate media never will. Join with us today! |
Our work is licensed under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). Feel free to republish and share widely.
Andrea Germanos
Andrea Germanos is a senior editor and staff writer at Common Dreams.
Jon Queally
Jon Queally is managing editor of Common Dreams.
As Sinclair continues to face criticism after a viral video showing local news anchors reciting scripts pre-packaged by the right-wing broadcasting behemoth, one TV producer announced Wednesday that the forced propaganda drove him to resign in protest.
"I didn't go into news to give people biased information," said Justin Simmons of Sinclair-owned KHGI-TV in Nebrasksa.
While the forced scripts put a spotlight in recent days on the power wielded by the right-wing media giant--and its proposed merger with Tribune Media--he toldCNNMoney, "I've always kind of been on edge about Sinclair." Simmons, who tendered his resignation on March 26, cited increasingly frequent "must-run" segments such as the "Terrorism Alert Desk."
It was the promo highlighted in the viral video--which Simmons said was "almost forcing local anchors to lie to their viewers"--that served as the last straw.
"Resigning seemed like the least I could do," he added. "I wish there was more."
While other local broadcasters have also spoken out in the wake of the viral video by Deadspin, news of Simmons' resignation comes amid renewed focus this week on the Sinclair-Tribune merger and the right-leaning coverage pushed by Sinclair executives, including CEO David Smith.
"There isn't a viral video long enough to demonstrate the type of power Sinclair would have to push its partisan political agenda into all of our homes if the company is successful in gobbling up so many stations that only two owners remain."
--Karl Frisch, Allied ProgressAccording to Karl Frisch, executive director of the liberal watchdog group Allied Progress, Sinclair is dangerous not just because of its political agenda, but because of Smith's stated desire for nearly total market domination by powerful broadcasters like his.
In a 2004 interview with an broadcast industry news outlet, Smith stated that if he "was going to wish for anything and I could snap my fingers and make it happen [...] it would be for an instantaneous final consolidation of the industry." Smith went on to say that such a consolidation--a nightmare scenario for progressives who see the corporate control of the media system as a direct assault on the role of journalism in a democracy--was "absolutely doable" in the future.
"The Sinclair/Tribune merger isn't dinner--it's the appetizer," warned Frisch. "Smith won't be content until his singular wish of the local news industry's 'final consolidation' is complete. That's a frightening prospect."
He concluded, "There isn't a viral video long enough to demonstrate the type of power Sinclair would have to push its partisan political agenda into all of our homes if the company is successful in gobbling up so many stations that only two owners remain."
In an essay published at the Huffington Post on Wednesday, a separate Sinclair producer--who requested anonymity over fears of retribution--told people: "If you want to make a difference, lobby your lawmakers to have them stop the Tribune deal from going through, because that is what is dangerous about this. It's dangerous for any company to own as many stations as Sinclair does."
Andrea Germanos
Andrea Germanos is a senior editor and staff writer at Common Dreams.
Jon Queally
Jon Queally is managing editor of Common Dreams.
As Sinclair continues to face criticism after a viral video showing local news anchors reciting scripts pre-packaged by the right-wing broadcasting behemoth, one TV producer announced Wednesday that the forced propaganda drove him to resign in protest.
"I didn't go into news to give people biased information," said Justin Simmons of Sinclair-owned KHGI-TV in Nebrasksa.
While the forced scripts put a spotlight in recent days on the power wielded by the right-wing media giant--and its proposed merger with Tribune Media--he toldCNNMoney, "I've always kind of been on edge about Sinclair." Simmons, who tendered his resignation on March 26, cited increasingly frequent "must-run" segments such as the "Terrorism Alert Desk."
It was the promo highlighted in the viral video--which Simmons said was "almost forcing local anchors to lie to their viewers"--that served as the last straw.
"Resigning seemed like the least I could do," he added. "I wish there was more."
While other local broadcasters have also spoken out in the wake of the viral video by Deadspin, news of Simmons' resignation comes amid renewed focus this week on the Sinclair-Tribune merger and the right-leaning coverage pushed by Sinclair executives, including CEO David Smith.
"There isn't a viral video long enough to demonstrate the type of power Sinclair would have to push its partisan political agenda into all of our homes if the company is successful in gobbling up so many stations that only two owners remain."
--Karl Frisch, Allied ProgressAccording to Karl Frisch, executive director of the liberal watchdog group Allied Progress, Sinclair is dangerous not just because of its political agenda, but because of Smith's stated desire for nearly total market domination by powerful broadcasters like his.
In a 2004 interview with an broadcast industry news outlet, Smith stated that if he "was going to wish for anything and I could snap my fingers and make it happen [...] it would be for an instantaneous final consolidation of the industry." Smith went on to say that such a consolidation--a nightmare scenario for progressives who see the corporate control of the media system as a direct assault on the role of journalism in a democracy--was "absolutely doable" in the future.
"The Sinclair/Tribune merger isn't dinner--it's the appetizer," warned Frisch. "Smith won't be content until his singular wish of the local news industry's 'final consolidation' is complete. That's a frightening prospect."
He concluded, "There isn't a viral video long enough to demonstrate the type of power Sinclair would have to push its partisan political agenda into all of our homes if the company is successful in gobbling up so many stations that only two owners remain."
In an essay published at the Huffington Post on Wednesday, a separate Sinclair producer--who requested anonymity over fears of retribution--told people: "If you want to make a difference, lobby your lawmakers to have them stop the Tribune deal from going through, because that is what is dangerous about this. It's dangerous for any company to own as many stations as Sinclair does."
We've had enough. The 1% own and operate the corporate media. They are doing everything they can to defend the status quo, squash dissent and protect the wealthy and the powerful. The Common Dreams media model is different. We cover the news that matters to the 99%. Our mission? To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good. How? Nonprofit. Independent. Reader-supported. Free to read. Free to republish. Free to share. With no advertising. No paywalls. No selling of your data. Thousands of small donations fund our newsroom and allow us to continue publishing. Can you chip in? We can't do it without you. Thank you.