Published on
Rethink Afghanistan/Brave New Films

Media Failing to Ask Tough Questions on Afghanistan War...Again

Derrick Crowe

General Petraeus is on a media tour to sell the idea that the U.S.
military is "making progress" in Afghanistan, a well-worn message aimed
at convincing elites to extend this brutal, futile war. So far, it looks like the mainstream media is buying it, hook, line, and sinker.

Petraeus kicked off his spin campaign this morning with an hour-long special on Meet the Press
with David Gregory. The piece opened with a montage of Petraeus doing
sit-ups, and later showed him jogging, with Gregory opining about him
wearing out troops half his age. Gregory went out of his way to set up a
"Petraeus saves the day" narrative, asking the general if the
situation in Afghanistan reminds him of the "dark days" in Iraq just
before Petraeus "succeeded" with the surge. Petraeus hammered home his
one-word message relentlessly: progress. Gregory feigned tough
skepticism, but betrayed his hero-worship with setups like, "Watch how
savvy Petraeus is when he answers my tough question." Throughout,
Gregory's sheepish grin conveyed the sense that he wanted to hug
Petraeus instead of critically probe his assertions.

As Petraeus
battered viewers again and again with his "making progress" theme,
Gregory failed to ask probing, skeptical questions. When Petraeus
mentioned "oil spots," as if the stain spreading across Afghanistan
were one of security, Gregory failed to press him on the huge increase in civilian deaths, the 87-percent spike in violence and the incredible explosion of IED attacks over the last several months. When he brought up the outrageous TIME Magazine cover showing a woman's mutilated face, Gregory failed to mention the attack happened last year and that TIME Magazine's cover grossly distorts the choices before the United States. When Petraeus denounced the Taliban's recent killing of a pregnant woman, Gregory failed to press Petraeus on ISAF's own killing of pregnant women earlier this year in which bullets were reportedly dug out of a screaming woman by special forces troops before she bled to death. Gregory didn't do journalism today. He provided a platform for military spin.

and Gregory jovially closed the interview by quoting Generals Grant
and Sherman, with Petraeus saying he's no politician. Don't believe that for a second. The military wants to extend this war,
and it sees American public opinion as an obstacle in getting what it
wants. Petraeus admitted as much when he told Gregory that the point of
his upcoming media appearances were scheduled in the hopes of showing
"people in Washington" and the public that we're making progress
(Finish your drink!) and to shore up support for the failing war
effort. This media blitz is about Petraeus shaping public opinion to
affect the political environment for a future push to extend the war
far beyond the bounds implied by Obama's December 2009 West Point
speech. In short, the military is turning its several-billion-dollar
public relations apparatus on the American people, and the mainstream
media is so far complicit. To quote one of my favorite bands, "There is a war going on for your mind."

the media fail to ask hard questions, there's a chance Petraeus could
get what he wants: the freedom to extend an extremely unpopular war
that's not making us safer. We've got to push back, and we've got to do
it now.

CBS' Katie Couric is next in line to talk to Petraeus during his high-profile spin campaign, so we're starting with her. Sign
our petition to Couric and push her to ask tough questions
about Petraeus' claims of "progress" and his attempt to extend the
Afghanistan War
. If you're not a Twitter user, don't worry--there are instructions on how you can participate without it.

Petraeus' media blitz is just getting started. We've got to push our
media--hard--to ask real questions and prevent easily disproved spin
from polluting the debate. Petraeus wants to change public opinion, and
he's spending your money to sell you a brutal, futile war that's not
making us safer. If you're tired of this kind of manipulation, join the
tens of thousands of other people working to end this war with Rethink Afghanistan.

Plug into the Movement to End the War:



This is the world we live in. This is the world we cover.

Because of people like you, another world is possible. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. Common Dreams is not your normal news site. We don't survive on clicks. We don't want advertising dollars. We want the world to be a better place. But we can't do it alone. It doesn't work that way. We need you. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do. Without Your Support We Won't Exist.

Please select a donation method:

Share This Article

More in: