Published on
The Hill

‘Professional Left’ Not Ready to Back an Obama Primary Challenger in '12

Sam Youngman

President Obama returns to the White House after a day in Texas on August 9th. Despite an uproar over recent statements from the White House and an overall frustration on the part of progressives, there is little talk of a primary challenge to Obama for 2012. (AP)

As angry as it might be, the professional left isn't ready to back a primary challenger to President Obama just yet.

Two high-profile liberals on Thursday said they are not
interested in running against the president in 2012, and liberal bloggers say
any challenge to Obama would be fraught with difficulty.

"I haven't heard of a credible name that has been floated
that would challenge President Obama," said David Sirota, a prominent liberal
blogger. "I haven't heard of that. I think it would be very difficult to do."

Moulitsas of Daily Kos, who is also a columnist for The Hill, said he
didn't think Obama would get a 2012 primary challenge "in a million
years." In an e-mail, Moulitsas also said Obama shouldn't be challenged.

Still, some influential figures on the left, which erupted
in fury this week at criticism White House press secretary Robert Gibbs made in
an interview with The Hill, suggest a multitude of voices in New Hampshire and
Iowa could be helpful to the party.

"I have always encouraged a diversity of voices in the
primary process, within all parties and at all levels of government," said Jane
Hamsher, founder of, a leading liberal blog.

"It's a sign of a healthy democracy," said Hamsher, who
suggested this week that Gibbs's comments could depress turnout in the November
midterm elections for Congress.

Former Vermont Gov. Howard Dean and Rep. Dennis Kucinich
(D-Ohio), a frequent presidential candidate, both said Thursday they had no
plans to challenge Obama.

Gibbs invoked Kucinich's name in The Hill interview,
saying some on the left wouldn't be satisfied if the prominent progressive who
has called for a Department of Peace were in the Oval Office.

But Kucinich told ABC he had no plans to challenge Obama
in 2012, and he pressed Democrats to concentrate on coming together.

Challenges to sitting presidents have been uncommon in
recent elections, but they are hardly unheard of.

President George H.W. Bush faced a primary challenge from
conservative commentator Pat Buchanan in 1992 after Bush won scorn from the
political right for breaking a pledge not to raise taxes.

After his election, President George W. Bush was
determined to avoid the same fate.

Karl Rove, Bush's chief political adviser, told The Hill
on Thursday that the younger Bush was largely inoculated from intra-party
challenges because he worked to make sure he "kept an open door to all elements
of the party."

Like Bill Clinton in 1996, the second president Bush did
not face a meaningful primary challenge when he was up for reelection.

Rove, now a commentator on Fox News, said Obama's
advisers need to take steps on a daily basis to protect him so that he does not
face a challenge from the left.

"The president's people ought to be doing things in a way
that keeps from providing people reasons to challenge him," Rove told The Hill.

Liberal commentators this week said they had plenty to
complain about. They're disappointed Obama has not closed the detention center
at Guantanamo Bay despite his promise to do so. Most also oppose Obama's
handling of the Afghanistan war.

The left was disappointed Obama did not do more to achieve
a public option in the health insurance bill, and they would like the president
to do more to end the ban on gays serving openly in the military.

Sirota said liberals feel "100 percent" taken for granted
by the Obama White House.

He and others on the left are worried Obama is taking a
page from Clinton's playbook and using triangulation to move to the middle in
advance of reelection.

Liberals are wary of some members of Obama's inner circle,
including Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel, who worked in the Clinton White House
and is a former investment banker.

"This is an administration that is teeming with
Clintonites and former corporate-connected people," Sirota said.

Rove believes Obama has little to worry about it. In the
end, he predicts, liberals will stick with Obama in 2012 in the primary and
general elections.

"They'll grouse about it, they'll bitch and moan about it,
but at the end of the day they will [vote for Obama]," Rove said.

This is the world we live in. This is the world we cover.

Because of people like you, another world is possible. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. Common Dreams is not your normal news site. We don't survive on clicks. We don't want advertising dollars. We want the world to be a better place. But we can't do it alone. It doesn't work that way. We need you. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do. Without Your Support We Simply Don't Exist.

Please select a donation method:

Share This Article