coalition, made up of organizations including media giant Bloomberg,
the Writers Guild of America, West and advocacy groups like Free Press
and Media Access Project, wrote to FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski on Monday voicing their opposition to the proposed merger of Comcast and NBC-Universal.
Monday is the last day for organizations to submit public comment to the FCC on the proposed merger, which would create
a new $30 billion joint venture merging the Philadelphia cable giant's
content division with NBC Universal's (NBCU) stable of television
networks, film studios and theme parks. Govs. Arnold Schwarzenegger,
(R-Calif.), David Paterson, (D-N.Y.) and Ed Rendell (D-Pa.) have
expressed support for the merger.
The groups argue the new entity would have unprecedented control over the country's media landscape, raising antitrust concerns.
proposed merger of Comcast and NBC-Universal is poised to fundamentally
alter the landscape of the U.S. media market," the letter states. "We
are a group of varied organizations with many specific concerns with
this merger, but we have joined together because the threat of this
merger to consumers is so great."
"As filed," it goes on, "we oppose this merger."
to the letter, the new entity created by the merger would include the
largest cable company, the largest residential broadband Internet
service provider, the owner of one of the four national broadcast
networks, several prominent local stations, cable networks and some of
the most popular websites.
This would give the company "a degree of market power unrivaled in our nation's media history," the letter claims.
Comcast executive vice president for public policy David Cohen responded to criticism of the deal Monday afternoon in a lengthy blog
post citing the numerous elected officials, advocacy groups and labor
organizations that have endorsed the merger. He also indicated that
many critics are motivated by business interests, not concern for
"It is important to keep in mind as you read the
comments from opponents of this transaction that the businesses in
which Comcast operates in today – distribution, programming, online,
high-speed Internet, and voice — are all fiercely competitive," Cohen
"Comcast and NBCU don’t compete against each other
in most segments of the market, so there is no new concentration. There
are no cable systems involved in this deal, so Comcast’s distribution
platform will not grow."
“If the Comcast-NBC deal goes through,
it would be one of the largest media mergers in a generation, leaving
Americans with even higher cable bills and fewer diverse, independent
choices on the dial," said Free Press President Josh Silver. "Approval
of the deal would be business as usual in Washington, letting the
largest companies have their way at the public’s expense."
said the deal is particularly bad for consumers in the 12 markets where
Comcast is the leading cable and broadband Internet provider and NBC
has a local TV station, including Washington, D.C. He also warned the
deal could threaten the viability of online video sites like Hulu.com,
claiming Comcast could prioritize its own online content in violation
of the principle of net neutrality.
Sen. Herb Kohl, (D-Wis.),
chairman of the Senate Judiciary subcommittee on antitrust, competition
policy and consumer rights, wrote to the FCC last month asking the
commission to impose a host of conditions on the deal, including a
promise from Comcast not to discriminate against content from other
The full list of organizations that co-signed the letter follows:
Communications Workers of America
Media Access Project
The National Association of Independent Networks
The National Coalition of African-American Owned Media
National Consumers League
The Organization for the Promotion and Advancement of Small Telecommunications Companies
National Telecommunications Cooperative Association
Writers Guild of America, West