It is a frightening picture: beef contaminated with toxic heavy metals,
pesticides and antibiotics making its way into the nation's
Phyllis K. Fong, the Agriculture Department's inspector general, looked at how beef is tested for harmful substances.
According to her new report, inspectors charged with checking
cattle for disease and meat for contaminants were, "unable to determine
if meat has unacceptable levels of... potentially hazardous substances
[and do] not test for pesticides... determined to be of high risk."
The inspectors also failed to test beef for 23 pesticides, the report says.
The study -- entitled the National Residue Program for Cattle
Audit Report -- says there are no standards for how much of certain
dangerous substances, such as copper and highly toxic dioxin, is too
much for someone to eat.?? As a result, meat containing these
substances has gotten into the nation's food supply, it finds.
The report says the health danger to people who eat this beef is a "growing concern,"
and calls for better coordination among the USDA Food Safety and
Inspection Service, the Environmental Protection Agency and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration to ensure the safety of the country's meat supply.
"When it comes to this particular issue of these foreign chemicals,
pollutants, antibiotics, things like that -- they haven't been doing
enough, that's what's clear," says Patty Lovera of Food & Water
Watch, a consumer advocacy group.
The audit report, which took place in 2007 and 2008, cited
instances when inspectors found beef containing excessive levels of
contaminants, but declined to recall it.
"I think the thing that was most alarming was when lab tests
were failed, there was no real concerted effort to recall the failed
supply," says Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack.
The report also found that the metal copper has made its way into American beef.
Often a waste product from industry, it can seep into the water that's fed to cattle.??
In one incident in 2008, Mexican officials refused a shipment of U.S. beef because it contained more copper than Mexico allows.
America has no such restriction.
Copper can be dangerous if consumed in food over the long term.
It is known to cause jaundice and kidney failure and can even be
"The Mexicans refused the meat that was going into their
country yet there was nothing that could be done to prevent American
consumers from being exposed to that," says David Acheson, former
managing director for FDA Food and Import Safety. "That certainly is
totally unacceptable in my book!"
Toxins In Your Meat?
The government bans nine different antibiotics from use in beef cattle.
Thirty-five others are allowed if they've cleared out of the animals'
systems before slaughter.
But the audit found instances when inspectors detected antibiotics in beef, but didn't issue a recall.??
When consumed in food, anti-biotics have the potential to
trigger allergic or toxic reactions in some people and to lower
resistance to bacteria.??
In a statement released today, the National Cattlemen's Beef Association expressed their support for the recommendations.
"It is critical that the federal government continue funding
food safety research at a high level, focusing on the validation of
safety systems and process controls to reduce any potential hazards,"
the statement reads. "While the U.S. beef supply is extraordinarily
safe by any nation's standards, we take seriously any potential food
Additionally, unlike with bacteria such as E. coli
or Salmonella, cooking meat thoroughly not only does not kill the
harmful substances, it can actually break them down into compounds that
are even more harmful.
Still, Vilsack says Americans should be assured that steps are
being taken to address these problems. He says that overall, the
nation's beef supply is safe.
"We're asking the suppliers of beef to do a better job of
keeping a better eye on repeat violations of suppliers so they are in a
position to go back to farms that are providing beef that is not
right--to correct the situation," he says.