Published on

Bush White House Emails Won't Be Public For Years

Zachary Roth

The Obama administration and two good government groups yesterday announced, with some fanfare, that they'd come to an agreement on those missing emails from the Bush White House.

But if you think the news means we're finally about to get the full
story on the Valerie Plame leak, or the deliberations that took us to
war in Iraq, think again. Many of the roughly 22 million emails secured
through the deal likely won't be made public until 2022. And even the
ones that can be released sooner won't see the light of day for around
three years.

The emails will be turned over to the National Archives, where
they'll be treated, initially at least, as presidential records, Anne
Weismann, a senior lawyer for CREW, one of the groups that had sued
over the emails, explained to TPMmuckraker. That means that, under the Presidential Records Act, they won't be made public for five years. But President Bush has broad latitude
to direct the Archives to keep them secret for an additional seven
years -- indeed, he may already have done so. Given the former
president's record on issues of openness and transparency, it's a good
bet he'll opt to do so. The administration or the Archives could
challenge that directive, arguing that Bush's reasons aren't spelled
out in the law. But, said Weismann, it's very unlikely that either
would do so.

However, some of the emails -- those from an agency like the Council
on Environmental Quality, rather than from a political adviser -- may
soon be designated federal, rather than presidential, records. That
would mean, said Weismann, that they'd likely be made public in about
three years, after the National Archives has processed them and
prepared them for release.

None of this is to suggest the settlement was any kind of Pyrrhic
victory for the plaintiffs. The important point is that the emails --
at least those that there's enough money to recover -- will be made
public, helping to shape our understanding of key events in our

It just means that we're unlikely to see a Karl Rove frogwalk any time soon.

Sustain our Journalism

If you believe in Common Dreams, if you believe in people-powered independent journalism, please support our Spring drive now and help progressive media that believes as passionately as you do in defending the common good and building a more just, sustainable, and equitable world.

Share This Article

More in: