A little more than two months ago, Brock McIntosh was fighting in
Afghanistan, a member of the Army National Guard. This week, he's
walking the halls of Congress, trying to end a war that began when he
was 13 years old.
McIntosh, now 21, and four other vets are in Washington for
something of a preemptive strike. A new pro-war group calling itself
Vets For Freedom plans to begin lobbying Congress Thursday, pushing for
an escalation. The anti-war vets hope to head them off.
But if their erstwhile comrades and now political opponents are "for
freedom," that raises an unusual question. "What does that make us?"
mocks Devon Read, 29, served for eight years and took part in the
invasion of Iraq before leaving the Marine Corps in 2008. "Vets Against
Freedom? Vets For Terrorism?"
Technically, they're with Veterans For Rethinking Afghanistan, having linked up with Brave New Films president Robert Greenwald, whose documentary project "Rethink Afghanistan" urges a drawdown of the American presence in that country.
As the vets wait outside the office of Rep. Raúl Grijalva, a
Democrat who co-chairs the Congressional Progressive Caucus, Jake
Diliberto, 27, recounts tales from the first skirmish with Vets For
Freedom earlier in the morning.
Diliberto went mano a mano
on CNN with VFF rep Thomas Cotton. Cotton had a simple appeal to
authority: He's for whatever General Stanley McChrystal wants -- and
that's more troops.
Before they went on, says Diliberto, he could hear his opponent
prepping himself. "He kept repeating, 'General Stanley McChrystal.
General Stanley McChrystal. General Stanley McChrystal.' "
Backers of escalating the eight-year-old war present a variety of
complex arguments, but at their heart is Cotton's mantra: "General
Stanley McChrystal. General Stanley McChrystal. General Stanley
The troops were joined in Grijalva's office by Malalai Joya, an
Afghan member of parliament who has been suspended for speaking out
against the warlords who run the country. She is appealing her
suspension and, in the meantime, promoting her new book, "A Woman Among Warlords." Joya, too, has a simple message: Go home, USA.
"It's much easier to fight against one enemy than two," Malalai Joya
tells Grijalva, identifying the two current enemies as the Taliban on
the one hand and the United States and the Afghan government it props
up on the other.
The Afghan government, she says, is hopelessly corrupt; President
Hamid Karzai is in league with powerful warlords and druglords, some of
whom are his close relatives. His top opponent, Abdullah Abdullah, is
himself a well-known warlord, she says. The election process is
controlled by warlords for their benefit. The farce that was the
previous election will not lead to a run-off because Abdullah doesn't believe it will be fair.
"It's not important who's voting. It's important who's counting,"
says Joya, adding that the canceled election matters little since both
candidates are representatives of the warlord class. "They both call
the Taliban brother."
Both President Obama and General McChrystal have said that the U.S.
effort in Afghanistan cannot succeed without a governing partner that
is seen as legitimate by the Afghan people. That's a tremendous problem
for proponents of a troop escalation, since Karzai is seen as anything
The problem for the war's opponents, however, is that it's hard to
comprehend just how corrupt the Karzai regime is. Seeing it first hand
persuaded the troops.
"The Taliban isn't their enemy," says Rick Reyes, who served with
the Marine Infantry in Afghanistan. "The greatest enemy of the Afghan
people is the Afghan government and the occupation forces."
McIntosh, who takes some time to get over his nerves in the
congressman's office, tells Grijalva that the Afghan people appreciate
the occupation army most for the medical services it provides. Afghan
doctors, he says, were poorly trained, because the Taliban banned
pictures in text books. The health care makes them dependent, he says,
when what they need is training.
"They can do it on their own," he says. "They're fully capable human beings."
Grijalva nods, acknowledging the wisdom from the young man who just recently got the legal right to drink.
The kind of training Afghans don't need, the Marines say, is
military. We've been training young men to fight in Afghanistan for
decades, they note, and look where it's gotten us. An overwhelming
number of men trained by the U.S. go on to fight for the Taliban
instead, which was itself originally trained by the U.S., notes Reyes.
"So if we train 400,000 soldiers and 200,000 go fight for the Taliban,
what have we gained?"
"We don't expect anything good from you," Joya tells Grijalva. "Just
stop doing wrong." As she brandishes photos of dead civilians, known
warlords, and evidence of Karzai's corruption, her voice gradually
rises. With a finger pointed squarely at the progressive congressman,
she repeatedly indicts the occupation and those who allow it to
"This is what your government has done," she fumes. "Silence of good people is worse than action of bad people."
Witnessing her rough treatment of Grivala, who agrees with her, it
isn't hard to see how she has found herself out of favor among the
After the meeting, Grijalva says that Joya helped alter his
perspective. "Sometimes in our urge to fix things, we just pile money
on top of a [friendly] government," he says. But Joya had convinced
him, he says, that the U.S. is "funding fundamentally the people who
are unraveling the country."
Outside in the hall, the vets assess the meeting. "I don't think he
needed a whole lot of convincing," offers Diliberto. Next up: Reps.
John Tierney (D-Mass.), Maxine Waters (D-Calif.) and Barbara Lee
(D-Calif.). "But we're not just meeting with progressives," assures
Leighton Woodhouse, a Brave New Films aide escorting the men. Rep. Dana
Rohrbacher (R-Calif.), Adam Smith (D-Wash.), David Price (D-N.C.), Tim
Johnson (R-Ill.) and Sylvestre Reyes (D-Texas) were also scheduled to
receive the veterans.
One member had previously offered a "walk and talk" with the vets,
but had since demoted them to a sit down meeting with the chief of
He might not get off that easy. The vets are neither your typical
lobbyist nor your standard anti-war protesters. Diliberto suggested
they deal with that congressman in a way that would convey the gravity
of their message.
"We should just go to his door," he suggests, 'and say, 'Look, motherfucker.'"