Published on
The Boston Globe

Ridge Felt a Push to Politicize Alert Levels

Globe Staff and Agencies

WASHINGTON - The first Homeland Security secretary, Tom Ridge, says
in a new book that he was pressured by other members of President
George W. Bush’s Cabinet to raise the nation’s terror alert level just
before the 2004 presidential election.

Ridge says he successfully objected to raising the security level
despite the urgings of former Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld and
then-Attorney General John Ashcroft, according to a release from
Ridge’s publisher.

Ridge writes that there was a “vigorous, some might say dramatic,
discussion’’ about raising the threat level. The former Republican
governor of Pennsylvania says his aides told the White House that doing
so would politicize national security.

“I believe our strong interventions had pulled the ‘go-up’ advocates
back from the brink,’’ he writes. “But I consider the episode to be not
only a dramatic moment in Washington’s recent history, but another
illustration of the intersection of politics, fear, credibility, and

He said the episode convinced him to follow through with his plans
to leave the administration for the private sector; he resigned weeks
after the election, which Bush won over Senator John F. Kerry of

Ridge’s account could fuel the claims of Bush critics, who have long
said that his White House used terror threats to distract the public
from the unpopular Iraq war and to boost support during an election

But Bush’s former homeland security adviser, Frances Townsend, said
yesterday that politics never played a role in determining alert levels.

She noted that in the weeks leading up to the election two
videotapes were released by al Qaeda, including one by terrorist leader
Osama bin Laden, that she said contained “very graphic’’ and
threatening messages.

Townsend said that any time there was a discussion of changing the
alert level, she first spoke with Ridge and then, if necessary, called
a meeting of the homeland security council. The group then made a
recommendation to the president about whether the color-coded threat
level should be raised.

Asked if there was any reason for Ridge to have felt pressured,
Townsend said: “He was certainly not pressured. And, by the way, he
didn’t object when it was raised, and he certainly didn’t object when
it wasn’t raised.’’

Ridge’s publicist, Joe Rinaldi, said Ridge was out of town and was
not doing interviews until his book, “The Test of Our Times: America
Under Siege . . . and How We Can Be Safe Again,’’ is released on Sept.

In 2005, Ridge said his agency had been the most reluctant to raise
the alert level. But his book appears to be the first time he publicly
attributes some of the pressure to politics.

Asked about the allegation, White House spokesman Robert Gibbs noted
yesterday that current Homeland Security Janet Napolitano launched a
study whether to scrap the color-coded system, which critics say is
ineffective and confusing.

“Decisions regarding the terror threat should be made based on the
rise and fall of that threat, not based on anything else,’’ Gibbs said.

This is the world we live in. This is the world we cover.

Because of people like you, another world is possible. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. Common Dreams is not your normal news site. We don't survive on clicks. We don't want advertising dollars. We want the world to be a better place. But we can't do it alone. It doesn't work that way. We need you. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do.

Share This Article

More in: