Waste ‘Loopholes’ Inquiry as Three Held After Toxic Find in Brazil
Three men were arrested yesterday in connection with the alleged illegal
export of 1,400 tonnes of hazardous household and clinical waste from
Britain to Brazil.
The arrests in Swindon, Wiltshire, came as the Environment Agency said that it
was reviewing rules covering the recycling industry because of concerns that
companies were exploiting loopholes to avoid scrutiny.
Companies that handle waste can avoid inspections and auditing by applying for
exemption from the need to obtain an environmental permit. If they claim
that they are handling low-risk waste, such as recyclable plastic, the
agency generally grants exemption without making checks.
This loophole allows them to profit by mixing toxic waste with recyclable
items with little risk of detection.
Yesterday's arrests come after the discovery of 99 shipping containers of
hazardous waste mixed with recyclable plastic at several Brazilian ports.
The Brazilian Institute for the Environment and Renewable Resources (Ibama)
said that the waste included syringes, bags of blood, condoms, nappies and
used bandages. The shipping manifest stated that the contents were
Ibama said that the waste was sent to Brazil by Worldwide Biorecyclables and
UK Multiplas Recycling, which share a director and are both based in
Worldwide had contracts to recycle plastic waste collected by Swindon Council
and Wiltshire County Council. The Environment Agency had granted it
exemption from needing an environmental permit. UK Multiplas had not been
granted exemption and did not have a permit.
Two of those arrested were understood yesterday to be Andre de Oliveira, 28,
and Julio da Costa, 48, Brazilians who set up the two companies in 2007. A
24-year-old man was also arrested.
Officers from the Environment Agency national environmental crime team and
Wiltshire Police made the arrests during early morning raids on three
The agency said that it was arranging to have the containers returned to
Britain where it planned to inspect their contents to verify the findings
reported by Ibama.
Waste can be sent abroad for recycling but it is illegal to export it for
disposal. The maximum penalty for breaking the rules is an unlimited fine or
up to two years in prison.
A shipping company informed the Environment Agency on July 1 that Ibama had
seized two containers that it had delivered to Brazil. The agency contacted
Ibama on July 10 to discuss returning the containers to Britain.
The agency stepped up the pace of its investigation last Friday after a senior
Ibama official was shown on Brazilian national television news opening
containers and demanding that Britain take responsibility.
Liz Parkes, the agency's head of waste, told The Times that the
system of granting exemption certificates was being reviewed. She said: "We
are concerned that some of what is being exported under the guise of being
paper or plastic for recycling has a higher degree of contamination than is
She said that the global economic downturn and fall in the oil price had
reduced the value of recyclable plastic. The recent increase in the tax on
landfill had made it more expensive to dispose of non-recyclable waste. "As
the cost of handling waste legitimately rises, unfortunately there will be
those who seek to flout the rules and profit from that."
Ms Parkes admitted that the existing rules had weaknesses. "Clearly the system
isn't working if we have cases of illegal activity. If, when we have
conducted this investigation, we find there are areas which need to be
tightened up, we will be working with the Government on those areas," she