Published on
The New York Times

On Day of Hope, Disappointment: Bans in 3 States on Gay Marriage

Jesse McKinley and Laurie Goodstein

Protesters block Santa Monica Boulevard in West Hollywood, Calif., Wednesday, Nov. 5, 2008 during a "No on Prop 8'' rally. In a defeat for the gay-rights movement, California voters put a stop to gay marriage, creating uncertainty about the legal status of 18,000 same-sex couples who tied the knot during a four-month window of opportunity opened by the state's highest court. (AP Photo/Kevork Djansezian)

SAN FRANCISCO - A giant rainbow-colored flag in the gay-friendly
Castro neighborhood of San Francisco was flying at half-staff on
Wednesday as social and religious conservatives celebrated the passage
of measures that ban same-sex marriage in California, Florida and Arizona.

In California, where same-sex marriage had been performed since
June, the ban had more than 52 percent of the vote, according to
figures by the secretary of state, and was projected to win by several
Californian news media outlets. Opponents of same-sex marriage won by
even bigger margins in Arizona and Florida. Just two years ago, Arizona
rejected a similar ban.

The across-the-board sweep, coupled with passage of a measure in
Arkansas intended to bar gay men and lesbians from adopting children,
was a stunning victory for religious conservatives, who had little else
to celebrate on an Election Day that saw Senator John McCain lose and other ballot measures, like efforts to restrict abortion in South Dakota, California and Colorado, rejected.

"It was a great victory," said the Rev. James Garlow, senior pastor
of Skyline Church in San Diego County and a leader of the campaign to
pass the California measure, Proposition 8. "We saw the people just
rise up."

The losses devastated supporters of same-sex marriage and ignited a
debate about whether the movement to expand the rights of same-sex
couples had hit a cultural brick wall, even at a time of another civil
rights success, the election of a black president.

Thirty states have now passed bans on same-sex marriage.

Supporters of same-sex marriage in California, where the fight on
Tuesday was fiercest, appeared to have been outflanked by the measure's
highly organized backers and, exit polls indicated, hurt by the large
turnout among black and Hispanic voters drawn to Senator Barack Obama's candidacy. Mr. Obama opposes same-sex marriage.

California will still allow same-sex civil unions, but that is not
an option in Arizona and Florida. Exit polls in California found that
70 percent of black voters backed the ban. Slightly more than half of
Latino voters, who made up almost 20 percent of voters, favored the
ban, while 53 percent of whites opposed it.

Julius Turman, a chairman of the Alice B. Toklas L.G.B.T. Democratic
Club, a gay political group here, said he called his mother in tears
when Mr. Obama won the presidency, only to be crying over the same-sex
marriage vote in a different way not much later.

"It is the definition of bittersweet," Mr. Turman said. "As an
African-American, I rejoiced in the symbolism of yesterday. As a gay
man, I thought, ‘How can this be happening?' "

Proposition 8's passage left only Massachusetts and Connecticut as
states where same-sex marriages are legal, though both Rhode Island and
New York will continue to recognize such ceremonies performed
elsewhere. Civil unions or domestic partnerships, which carry many of
the same rights as marriage, are allowed in a handful of states. More
than 40 states now have constitutional bans or laws against same-sex

On Wednesday, five months of same-sex marriages in California -
declared legal by the State Supreme Court in May - appeared to have
come to a halt. "This city is no longer marrying people" of the same
sex, Gavin Newsom,
the mayor of San Francisco, announced at a grim news conference at City
Hall, where hundreds of same-sex couples had rushed to marry in the
days and hours leading up to Tuesday's vote.

The status of those marriages, among 17,000 same-sex unions
performed in the state, was left in doubt by the vote. The state's
attorney general, Jerry Brown, reiterated Wednesday that he believed that those marriages would remain valid, but legal skirmishes were expected.

The cities of Los Angeles and San Francisco, and Santa Clara County,
as well as several civil rights and gay rights groups, said on
Wednesday that they would sue to block the ban.

Some opponents of the proposition were also still holding out slim
hopes that a batch of perhaps as many as four million provisional and
vote-by-mail ballots would somehow turn the tide.

The victory of the social and religious conservatives came on a core
issue that has defined their engagement in politics over the past

The Rev. Joel Hunter, an evangelical pastor in Florida, said many
religious conservatives felt more urgency about stopping same-sex
marriage than about abortion, another hotly contested issue long locked
in a stalemate.

"There is enough of the population that is alarmed at the general
breakdown of the family, that has been so inundated with images of
homosexual relationships in all of the media," said Mr. Hunter, who
gave the benediction at the Democratic National Convention
this year, yet supported the same-sex marriage ban in his state. "It's
almost like it's obligatory these days to have a homosexual couple in
every TV show or every movie."

Supporters of the bans in California, Arizona and Florida benefited
from the donations and volunteers mobilized by a broad array of
churches and religious groups from across the ethnic spectrum.

The Rev. Samuel Rodriguez, a pastor in Sacramento and president of
the National Hispanic Christian Leadership Conference, said the
campaign to pass Proposition 8 had begun with white evangelical
churches but had spread to more than 1,130 Hispanic churches whose
pastors convinced their members that same-sex marriage threatened the
traditional family.

"Without the Latino vote," Mr. Rodriguez said, "Proposition 8 would never have succeeded."

Frank Schubert, the campaign manager for Protect Marriage, the
leading group behind Proposition 8, agreed that minority votes had put
the measure over the top, saying that a strategy of working with
conservative black pastors and community leaders had paid off.

"It's a big reason why we won, no doubt about it," he said.

Proposition 8 was one of the most expensive ballot measures ever
waged, with combined spending of more than $75 million. Focus on the
Family and other religious conservative groups contributed money to
help pass the same-sex marriage measures in all three states.

Forces on both sides viewed California as a critical test of the
nation's acceptance of gay people, who have made remarkable strides in
the decades since the 1969 riots in New York at the Stonewall Inn,
considered the beginning of the gay rights movement.

Scholars were divided on how large a setback Tuesday's votes would
be for that movement. Andrew Koppelman, a professor of law at Northwestern University
and the author of "Same Sex, Different States," a study of same-sex
marriage, said the outcome had a silver lining, namely that it was
closer than in previous statewide measures.

A 2000 ballot measure establishing a California state law against
same-sex marriage passed with 61 percent of the vote. That law was
overturned in May by the State Supreme Court.

In Arizona, where same-sex marriage was already against the law, the
victory for Proposition 102, which amends the State Constitution, was
met with a shrug by some.

"I think the country was like, ‘Look, you get Obama, call it a day
and go home,' " said Kyrsten Sinema, a Democratic state representative
who led opponents against Proposition 102. "And frankly, I'll take it."

Jesse McKinley reported from San Francisco, and Laurie Goodstein from New York.

This is the world we live in. This is the world we cover.

Because of people like you, another world is possible. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. Common Dreams is not your normal news site. We don't survive on clicks. We don't want advertising dollars. We want the world to be a better place. But we can't do it alone. It doesn't work that way. We need you. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do.

Share This Article

More in: